Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Hollow Form ChuckING

Posts

Hollow Form ChuckING

#1

Lyle Jamieson

Hollow Form ChuckING

Lyle Jamieson

>I was asked in the Hollow Form drying thread about how I hang onto hollow forms. The best way to transfer the power and stability of your lathe out to your wood WITHOUT vibration is with screws (many screws) in a faceplate with a prepared concave surface on the wood. No hump or bumps=no vibration.

A chuck has limitations, I want to open up possibilities not limit them so I dont use chucks. The chuck itself is a good tool...but...it is the wood that fails when we try to use it for turning. We are grabbing a sponge that will flex, mush, crush, and allow vibration. Its the wood that fails not the chuck. You have to realize the limitations of a chuck and not exceed them. A hollow form shape exceeds chuck capabilities big time. If you grab a soft wet piece of walnut, of whatever wood you wish, with a chuck and tenon, than go out to the mouth opening and start hollowing 6-8-10 inches away from the support there is no way you will hollow without vibration. So now what!! I have vibration and need to do unproductive things like using a steadyrest when it is not needed. For example I can hollow out a goblet 16 inches tall without a steadyrest. Stop the source of vibration first so you dont have the hassle of steadyrest use.

We have an almost endless source of wood down all around us, no matter where we live. It only takes an extra inch of wood to get screws in it with a good faceplate. Lyle Jamieson

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

#2

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

Paul Zerjay

>Thank you...No humps or bumps

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

#3

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

marvin ewing

>I 100% agree with you Lyle

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

#4

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I agree. If you are turning problem wood, soft or with flaws that limit the use of screws use dowels. The screw goes into a hardwood dowel and becomes very secure. The pic will what I mean.

Wally


img

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

#5

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

Carole Valentine

>Well dang...I never would have thought of that Wally! Thanks.

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

#6

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

robo hippy

>Well, I will have to think about this. I don't do that many hollow forms, but when I do, I prefer a chuck because it is less hastle, and I waste less wood. I have turned up to 12 inches deep, and without a steady rest, and with no vibration. I would think that bigger jaws , like 4 inch would help with stability. Isn't it a leverage thing, as in the more surface the foot sits on, the more stable it will be? I wouldn't try to grip a 4 inch tenon with jaws that close tight at 2 1/2 inches. Dove tailed jaws do hold better than straight. I did know the dowel trick though.

robo hippy

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

#7

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

john lucas

>I have no doubt that bolted to a faceplate is more solid. People like Lyle, John Jordan, and others who turn hollow forms for a living all recommend it. When I took the class with Frank Sudol where we turned some large deep very thin vessels we used faceplates.

I also agree with Robo. I use a Vicmarc chuck with dovetail jaws. I turn turn the tenon so the jaws only have 1/4" gap or less when fully closed on the tenon. For bigger work I use the 3" or 4" jaws. haven't turned anything over 14" deep on hollow forms but I have turned bowls 19" in diameter and 8" deep. So far no problems. The vibration that I have is due to tool diameter rather than chucking problems. I can switch to thicker tools and it will go away.

So I guess I'm saying that if you are having vibration problems, get rid of the nylon washers, try using a thicker tool and switch to a faceplate. One or all 3 will probably solve the problem.

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

#8

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

Lyle Jamieson

>As I indicated the chuck has limitations. Just know and understand that a faceplate will be a better source of security. The larger tenon/jumbo jaws will get you deeper but a larger facplate will get you even deeper then that. Whatever you use dont let vibration happen. I have done a 16 inch tall goblet 4 inch diameter without a steady or vibration. There are some that think "well I just spent $3-400.00 for a chuck buy golly I am going to use it".

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

#9

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

Norm Smith

>Lyle is dead on. You cant beat the security of a face plate. When I am turning an expensive piece of wood I often glue on a waste block and screw the face plate to that.

Norm

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

#10

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

bowlman

>Lyle is 100% correct. Before chucks all we knew was faceplates. David Ellsworth showed me how to mount blanks using a modified faceplate. The modifications were to countersink/chamfer the underside of the holes so that any wood that spirals up from the screws has somewhere to go. Otherwise the wood fibers jam against the faceplate and the wood does not seat against it. Others professional turners also prefer faceplates to chucks for hollow forms and bowls. Frank Sudol, Walley Dickerman, John Jordan, Don Geiger and Rude Osolnik are among those that I can cite. Don't get me wrong, I have and use chucks, many of them home made, but, I understand the inherent limitations of squeezing onto a spigot. There are times when a faceplate is just flat out better. Sometimes, the old ways are the best.

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

#11

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

john lucas

>On top of countersinking the wood side of the screw holes, I also drill extra holes in my facelplates. Many only come with 4 or 6 holes. I drill at least 8 if possible and will sometimes offset them. I also drill the holes in the faceplate to a larger size so I can use heavier sheet metal screws.

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

#12

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

John Jordan

>I just think of it as the six-screw or eight-screw chuck.

If the right faceplate is used, it does not require you to "waste" any wood-that's not a good argument. The shape fits within the screw pattern.

I used to tell people that for $300, you could buy several faceplates and 10 pounds of screws.

Having said all that, I do use the chuck quite a lot for modest-medium scale work, but I know when it's time for the faceplate. A lot of us learned with faceplates anyway, because there weren't any decent chucks.

Good advice Lyle.

John

John

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

#13

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

robo hippy

>As a production bowl turner, I never use a face plate. Simply a waste of time. No face plate and screws, no waste blocks, no problems with bowls coming off the lathe. I am very agressive when roughing and coring. Green wood 14 inch by 6 inch deep, 4 bowl set, turned to finish thickness is about 45 minutes. Please note here, professional driver on closed course, do not attempt without training. I did have some problems when first starting because I was doing some things wrong. I figured it out. I use a big forstner bit to drill a recess on the top of the bowl blank. Expand into it and turn the bottom, turn a recess, which I prefer to a tenon, reverse, core, finish turn. The core has a center recess in it already, no face plate necessary, and no screw holes in that last small core. The chuck never comes off the lathe. No tailstock either. I have done bowls up to 22 inches this way.

Lyle, you this would be interesting to put in Fred's magazine.

robo hippy

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

#14

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING *LINK*

Ron in Drums PA

>I work the same way as Reed (robo).

I don't think I ever put a faceplate on my 3520. Probably never will.

I just posted this link on another forum, as I said there, ask 10 turners how they do something and you get 15 different answers


http://www.simplyturning.com/Tips/MountingBowlBlanks/index.html

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

#15

Dick Hines

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

Dick Hines

>To face plate or not to face plate? That is the question. On hollow froms less than 6" deep I will use a chuck. Anything over 6" I will go with a face plate.

It also depends on the diameter. I use the 6" rule there too.

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

#16

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

Chip in Plano

>How do you folks feel about using a faceplate on a sacrificial block epoxied/glued to the actual stock? What species of blocks? What glue? What grain orientation? I've tried them all and I've made a few mistakes along the way. I do hate fussing with a steady rest. When I get vibration with a chuck, it's usually because I didn't give it that extra grunt with the wrench to seat it firmly.

I'm open to amending my ways for a better experience/outcome. Thanks for the thread. I needed to here it.

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

#17

Glue Blocks...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Sure, I use glue blocks a lot. I usually use med. CA glue because I can mount the piece immediately, but yellow glue works very well. My wood of choice is alder. Alder never warps so it's always true and flat which it must be for a good glue joint. You can cut a tenon for a chuck, or you can use a faceplate, or you can use a screw center, which I often do.

I seldom use a glue block with anything deeper than 6 or 7 inches. I seldom use one with endgrain pieces. If I ever do, I cut a small tenon on the blank and a corresponding opening in the glue block for a better glue joint.

Wally

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

#18

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

Lyle Jamieson

>Response to robo-hippy. The process you describe is one that a large number of turners use. My comments do not imply that it is the WROGH way...just different. I think there is a huge advantage to using a chuck for a productiuon turner. Its faster!! In cantrast, I want to savor the moment. Most of us are not production turning, we just want to have some fun at the lathe. I think it would be safe to say even a production turner would seldom use chucks for tall hollow forms. It all goes back to the limitations. We try to stretch the limits of our skills, our lathes, and our tools. A faceplate will get you farther down the road.

I start every piece I do, and end almost every piece I do between centers. I will not know what I have until I start turning and reveal the color, grain, balance, charicter, flaws and faults of the tree. While between centers I can adjust the axis as I rough it down. I can even flip the wood end-for-end. I want to be in control. Once you drill the drill hole for your chuck or screw chuck you have given up your control to the tree. I think your instincts, even as a beginner, are better than a tree. I want to go for spectacular from the piece of wood. In high production work that is not the priority, and thats OK, the way it should be.

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

#19

Brad Vietje

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

Brad Vietje

>Lyle raises very good points (no surprise there, as he's one of the best-known HF turners in the country!).

I want to elaborate just a bit on the part about starting between centers for any beginners reading along...

By starting between centers, the piece can be tipped this way or that to get the most balanced, or spectacular result. This is done before the end (or ends) are flattened and dished out slightly for faceplate attachment (or before forming a tenon for a chuck). Thus, once the ideal orientation is achieved by turning between centers, the faceplate can be mounted to hold the piece with the greatest security and least vibration.

I'll also add that side-grain orientations tend to have more vibration issues -- especially if tools are not sharpened often enough -- due to the alteration of grain direction on each revolution. Some vibration problems when using chucks to turn side-grain blanks could be worsened by including sapwood in the tenon, which is usually much wetter and softer than heartwood, so it deforms more and doesn't hold as well.

I tend to use chucks for up to 8" in height, and faceplates for larger pieces -- almost always in end-grain orientation, and like Lyle, start almost everything I turn between centers.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

#20

more than one way to skin a cat

robo hippy

>Actually, I heard it ment more than one way to skin a cat fish. I do like cats. Anyway, Ron, that looks like a small tenon to me for that size of bowl, but as a very experienced turner, we can get away with things that others can't, which is a good point for turners to consider when experimenting. Hollow forms, and bowls are different, and attaching methods are different. You have to experiment to see what works best for you.

As far as glue/waste blocks, the only 'do not do this' for them as far as I am concerned is don't use plywood. I prefer yellow glue to the CA. I just don't trust that because if it is put on fairly thick, even with accelerator, it takes a while to dry. I do a number of them at once (boxes on waste blocks), and let them dry over night. You can turn them sooner, but I like to be sure. Of course, you want the mating surfaces to be as flat/flush fit as possible. Gluing end grain to flat grain doesn't give a good hold, especially for long term use.

Good thread.

robo hippy

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

#21

Great Thread, all, and a question for FP users

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Hi all,

Great thread! Just to throw out my own 2 cents, I use a chuck for all the hollow forms I have done. OK, sure that's not more than 75 total, but still, it's some.

But here's a question for the faceplate users. Almost invariable, the hollow forms I've done have started with wet wood. I turn, let dry and warp and then return. When I have a tenon turned on the end for the chuck to grab, it's simply a case of re-chucking the piece. If you use a face plate, do you need to somehow re-true the bottom, mating surface of the wood or do you just rescrew the faceplate back onto the bottom. This is assuming you don't have 50 faceplates sitting around that you can leave attached to the piece while it dries!! :)

Again, great discussion.

Mike

So much to learn, so many things to try in Apex, NC!!

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

#22

Re: Great Thread, all, and a question for FP users

John Jordan

>Quit drying and re-turning. That will solve that problem.:)

John

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

#23

Re: Great Thread, all, and a question for FP users

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>That happened to me Mike,

I have s dozen faceplates and all are attached to a drying piece, I am going to switch to turn green and finish it for HF and I already switched to turning bowls and plates with dry wood only, turning twice uses all of my limited storage space.

Take care

Jorge

Re: Hollow Form ChuckING

#24

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Great Thread, all, and a question for FP users

Lyle Jamieson

>Dont leave a chuck or a faceplate on a green turning and let it dry. The shrinking wood will warp. Take faceplates off to expose the bottom to dry. Faceplates left on will loosen the screws and crack the bottom as it dyies. The bottoms have to be trued up in either case, chuck or faceplate. Visualize a chuck grabbing a oval tenon. It will grip only in two high spots and "pivot" with turning pressure and vibrate. Also it will not run true. The clean up to get it round again may cut through one side or the other. Again as JJ said why go through all that trouble?? Just turn green to finish. Once the free water is out of it, it is sandable, put some finish on it. After the bound water is gone and it stabilizes its shape in a few days sit back and admire your work. Lyle