The Static, View Only, Constraint
charlie belden
>The Static, View Only, Constraint
This one�s been bugging me more and more. The more turnings I do, the more pieces I see that I want to pick up and play with - but can�t - the more it bugs me.
I�ll start by repeating something I�ve brought up before.
The actual process of turning a piece is dynamic - literally and figuratively - the piece spinning, the tool moving and pivoting, chips and/or curlies flying, fingers, hands, shoulders legs and feet moving and body swaying - the visual feedback influencing the mind�s eye of where things are going. Yet when the process is over - the result is static - a View Only thing - which may actually be handled by a very few.
And by �handled� I don�t mean the �handled� in Shipping & Handling, or taken care of as in �I�ll handle it� - but actually HELD - in your hands - to feel - how smooth the surfaces are, or not - how light or surprisingly heavy - to trace a contour with finger tip - to tilt and turn the piece to see the details, or how the look of the grain changes depending on the light.
So the product of the process must rely on just its visual impact specifically ONLY the light its surface reflects - and of that reflected light, only the light that strikes the retina of the viewers eyes. Though the viewer may be able to move around and see more of the piece, but only a half at a time, only sight is utilized. The piece remains static, requiring the viewer to be the dynamic partner, and a limited partner at that since DO NOT TOUCH is clearly stated on a sign - or heavily implied. The piece is confined to being merely displayed.
But the viewer has four other senses that aren�t called on or engaged at all - beauty, or whatever the effect of the piece COULD have, is literally - only in the eye of the beholder.
Then I think of children�s playgrounds, children�s Discovery Museums, San Francisco�s Exploratoreum - where objects aren�t just displayed but out there for kids to play with - to interact with - to be explored/investigated - via sight - and sound - and touch - maybe even smell (taste - well that one might have some health issue constraints).
I�ve been able to see - up close and personal - turnings by demonstrators at our turning club. Holding one of these pieces permits close examination -- with eyes and finger tips - to feel the heft of one, the airy lightness and delicateness of another - to tilt and turn the piece over and around to see views not possible when it is merely being displayed. While textured pieces may convey something interesting - visually - actually feeling that same texture, with eyes open or close - reinforces the impression sight provides - AND - adds more information about the piece for the mind to process.
And even when actually handled - most pieces are - frozen snapshots - or fine portraits of - a fixed, static object - WYSIWYG (pronounced wisee-wig) - What You See Is What You Get. There�s seldom an opportunity for the �viewer� to change the piece - in anyway. The piece is DONE - and you can�t change it - even a little. OK - so you may be able to remove the top of a lidded box - but that�s IT. Any interaction with the object is visual - and mental. It sits still and you LOOK at it. BUT god forbid you should pick it up - and - PLAY with it!
It�s not that there aren�t pieces being done that CAN engage more than just the visual sense - TOPS being one of the few that come with permission to play with it. There are pieces intentionally made to be unstable which, by intent rock and spin and wobble. And there are pieces with moveable parts - a marble waiting to move over a texture to create a sound or sounds, perhaps bouncing or swooshing along a path the maker created for it specifically for that purpose - to engage the �viewer�s� senseS (plural).
Now there�s a risk to allowing physical interaction with a piece - there�s always that one idiot who will intentionally or unitnentionally damage the piece. From personal experience - there seems to be a dispraportionate share of them attending Craft Shows ( a guy with an 18� neck trying to get a delicate 16� chain around his neck - breaking the chain - and then wanting a discount �Cause It�s broken.�.). On the other hand - it�s really a kick to see someone pick up a piece and explore it - and discover something that surprises them - or intriques them in some way - or clicks in some special way, maybe a childhood memory - to PLAY with the piece.
Sight, sound, touch, smell, taste - why be limited to just sight when there are so many ways to go beyond just that single sense - especially if most of the pieces we turn are for ourselves or friends and family - or - for those here whose works are for galleries and collection knowledgable collector?. The probablity of a piece being abused - by you, someone you know, or by someone who buys a piece at a show or from a gallery is pretty low. So why think in terms of STATIC when developing a piece - when there are so many more possibilities?
If you were to make a turned piece - for a blind person . . .
With the look of the wood gone - what could take its place - or provide some of what�s missing for the blind? It would probably be more accurate to say "What are we visually dominated missing?".
We hear vibration - moving air. But a person with hearing loss - or profound deafness may not �hear� the sound a hearing person does - in the same way. Touch can fill in some of what the non-hearing person experiences - sensing vibration. How could that be used in a piece for a deaf person - or - hearing person as well?
If breakage or damage weren�t an issue - how would your pieces change?
How would a gallery of turned objects - for the blind - "look"? Or one for kids?
ps - There's something magic about touch. I used to take my chocolate lab with me when visiting my dad in a nursing home. I encountered folks I just couldn't engage - they remained whereever their mind had them no matter what I did. But if I had Nitro with me he'd engage them - dogs having that abilitiy. And once the persons hand touched his head - or ear - or nose - the person came back from whereever their mind WAS - and engaged the dog - and then anyone with the dog. Seems they'd all had a dog, or had a friend who had a dog they made friends with. Didn't matter what kind of dog they actually had - the one they were touching "is just like my (Fluffy, or Max, or Spot)." Memories long thought lost return - and once they do - others follow. The stories I heard and the things I learned from and about these folks were amazing - all thanks to a dog - and touch.



