>I'm trying to figure out how I should turn/dry hollow forms.
For open bowls, I'm turning to 10% thickness, sealing with anchorseal, and placing in paper bags.
I'm trying to adapt this to hollowforms. I've come up with several questions?
1. Should I turn them to 10% and let them dry and return months later.
2. Do you treat them different if pieces are short, rounded like a closed bowl or tall and thin like a vase?
3. If I turn green and dry, the return, how do I attach the piece to begin with? The tenon/chuck method seems a little difficult to remount. Especially after wood movement. Could runout at the end of a long piece could exceed the thickness of the piece?
4. Do I leave them attached to a faceplate or faceplate ring as they dry?
Does wood movement make the screws less effective? I've heard that screwing into endgrain isn't as effective compared to facegrain, all things equal.
5. Just turning green and finishing is an option, but some I'd like to finish when they're dry.
One of the best, if not THE BEST, resources for this is the John Jordan DVD "Aesth. and Prop. of Wood". There's no better place to start then to get that. There's one critical point to remember. "Moisture dries by air flow moving over the surface and carrying the moisture vapor away." An extreme example would be a fan blowing on a wet floor. Slow the air movement, you slow (and control) the drying.
I use a few different options. First, turn it green and finish it. For these pieces I usually place in a cardboard box. I'll start with it shut, and then after a while I'll open one flap, and continue until it's dried. I'll also use a grocery bag if I'm out of boxes or space. By having the piece in the "enclosure" the air flow is being controlled. I've recently made some urns. For that I needed a dried piece to fit a lid to securely-any movement wasn't an option. For that I rough turned, following the same 10% rule, sealed the outside with anchorseal and placed the piece in my "kiln" that is made out of an old upright freezer. About 4 weeks later I had a 6% moisture content vessel that I could return and make a lid.
If I use the box/bag method I've never found a reason to seal the piece first. I will sometimes add a some shavings to start it and then take them out later. If I just let the piece air dry or put it my kiln I seal the outside and leave it alone.
I'd treat a hollow form the same I would a bowl. If I'm finishing turning it green I use the box or bag method. If I'm returning something to be fitted with a lid or want a bowl to be "true" I'll seal it.
No Piths allowed!! IMHO. Other's make it work and I like their work. "When in doubt, cut it out."
Just my two cents, and you probably deserve change back...
>you'll likely lose 90% of the forms you turn. I've never had any success trying to dry hollowforms and return.
I think 1/2" thickness is about the thickest I've left them without losing one. Thicker forms almost always crack. If you can get them down to 1/4" or less, you should be able to save 90% or more following Greg's advice.
>When I was making the urns, and couldn't have any movement to fit a lid, the kiln worked great. Here's a picture of it, now filled with bowls from some recent bowl coring. Bowls range from 14" plus diameter down to 6" diameter. "Knock on wood" I haven't had one piece crack yet and the count is at 53 pieces (bowls, urns, and boxes) being finished turned from it. It's a full size, rather large upright freezer that I gutted and converted to a kiln.
If you're not fitting a lid, this really isn't needed for a vessel, but if you are, it works very well.
>I haven't dried very many hollow forms. I turn most of them to completion. the ones that I have dried were treated just like bowls. I rough them to around 10% or a little less. I seal the end grain on the outside and any suspect areas such as a limb protrusion. then I put it in a paper sack or box on the floor of my shop. It will stay there for several weeks or until I remember to move it up on the shelf. Then depending on how badly I want that piece I may leave it in the bag or I may remove it. I have lost more pieces due to putting them up too soon. I have on occasion sprayed the outside of the piece with water a few days after putting it up. This is on pieces that I absolutely cannot loose. Those pieces I monitor almost every day when I walk in the shop. It's a pain in the butt but has worked.
When I try to rough them to thinner dimensions I have lost some due to wood movement. Too out of round to save. It really helps to understand how the wood moves so you can predict what will likely happen. For that reason I will also suggest John Jordan's DVD. Bruce Hoadley's book is also excellent but you have to study it. I'm getting much better at cutting them correctly from the tree so I don't lose them.
When I rough the pieces I do it between centers. This not only gives me more control of the final appearance of the piece but also leaves a center mark from the tailstock. When I go to remount the pieces I put them between centers again with the top on a homemade jam chuck and then I true up the bottom tenon. The center mark makes it very easy to do this.
>John stated it perfectly, "cutting them correctly from the tree so I don't lose them." The first cut is just as important as the last, except the first cut is with a chainsaw. This is an area I'm working on as well and it makes a big difference. When I cut it right, there's a lost less headache and stress later compared to when I cut sloppy or not balanced.
>You have 8 questions that dont need answers if you just turn green to finish. Even with answers you will have a large failure rate. The only reason I can think of to remount a hollow form is to put a lid on it. That is easily done starting between centers, true up the bottom for your new faceplate surface, and screw it into the waste wood with new pilot holes since the wood is dry now. I never use a chuck for hollow forms, I dont want to deal with the vibration issues. But a chuck could be used to REmount it. Clean up the vessel opening hole to make it round again and fit the top.
I agree with John and Greg, but only partly with Steve. I have lost very few HF's to drying, but it depends on so many factors that it isn't quite that simple. I turn many to completion in green wood, but re-mount quite a few, probably most, after seasoning. I almost always turn hollow vessels in end grain orientation -- the only losses I've had were in side grain, or dealing with spalted wood with part spalted, and part sound wood. Hint: spalted and sound wood shrink differently, and can have vastly different strengths, so you can get some weird warping where the two zones meet.
I leave a good strong tenon on the green rough-outs, and re-mount between centers like Greg and John to true up and finish turn. I always use a tenon and never a rabbet or recess to expand into -- that would risk tearing the thing apart when tightening the chuck.
If you need the vessel to be uniform thickness when finished (I always want this), you can consider rounding up the inside before truing up the outside. This takes a little practice, but I find that most people would rather thin and sand the outside when the piece gets a little delicate than try to round up the inside.
What sort of shrinkage allowance you'll need depends a LOT on what sort of wood you use, how dry it is, the orientation of the blank in the tree, and where the blank was cut from in relation to the pith and the bark. As one of many possible examples, an end-grain HF from straight grain wood well away from the pith will tend to shrink to a slight egg-shape, with a narrow or slightly pointy side towards the pith. How much depends on how close to the pith you're working. End-grain spherical forms tend to stay rounder than side-grain bowls, and if uniform in thickness, they are very strong. Steve's perfectly right about thinner being better than thicker -- thin forms will tend to warp and not crack, while thicker ones tend to crack before they're done warping.
Good sources: John Jordan's video/DVD on Hollow Turning shows a 2-piece "bottle" form, and gives great detail on the tools and techniques. Also Robert Chapman's book, Woodturning: A Fresh Approach gives much in-depth detail on how-to, and is an excellent turning book anyway.
Attend the next regional symposium in your part of the world -- there's usually a hollow form turning session on the agenda. If you're in the Northeast, come to the 6th New England Woodturning Symposium, on May 23 at Pinkerton Academy, in Derry, NH (near Manchester), where I'll be in the hot seat doing -- yup, you guessed it -- Intro. To Hollow Forms.
>Thanks to Greg and John for the plug. There's an article dealing with this on my website. I don't usually post the website, but it seems OK here. :) www.johnjordanwoodturning.com under Tech/Articles.
I agree with John and Greg, but only partly with Steve. I have lost very few HF's to drying, but it depends on so many factors that it isn't quite that simple. I turn many to completion in green wood, but re-mount quite a few, probably most, after seasoning. I almost always turn hollow vessels in end grain orientation -- the only losses I've had were in side grain, or dealing with spalted wood with part spalted, and part sound wood. Hint: spalted and sound wood shrink differently, and can have vastly different strengths, so you can get some weird warping where the two zones meet.
I leave a good strong tenon on the green rough-outs, and re-mount between centers like Greg and John to true up and finish turn. I always use a tenon and never a rabbet or recess to expand into -- that would risk tearing the thing apart when tightening the chuck.
If you need the vessel to be uniform thickness when finished (I always want this), you can consider rounding up the inside before truing up the outside. This takes a little practice, but I find that most people would rather thin and sand the outside when the piece gets a little delicate than try to round up the inside.
What sort of shrinkage allowance you'll need depends a LOT on what sort of wood you use, how dry it is, the orientation of the blank in the tree, and where the blank was cut from in relation to the pith and the bark. As one of many possible examples, an end-grain HF from straight grain wood well away from the pith will tend to shrink to a slight egg-shape, with a narrow or slightly pointy side towards the pith. How much depends on how close to the pith you're working. End-grain spherical forms tend to stay rounder than side-grain bowls, and if uniform in thickness, they are very strong. Steve's perfectly right about thinner being better than thicker -- thin forms will tend to warp and not crack, while thicker ones tend to crack before they're done warping.
Good sources: John Jordan's video/DVD on Hollow Turning shows a 2-piece "bottle" form, and gives great detail on the tools and techniques. Also Robert Chapman's book, Woodturning: A Fresh Approach gives much in-depth detail on how-to, and is an excellent turning book anyway.
Attend the next regional symposium in your part of the world -- there's usually a hollow form turning session on the agenda. If you're in the Northeast, come to the 6th New England Woodturning Symposium, on May 23 at Pinkerton Academy, in Derry, NH (near Manchester), where I'll be in the hot seat doing -- yup, you guessed it -- Intro. To Hollow Forms.