Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

Posts

Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

#1

Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

charlie belden

>Having gotten through another opportunity to be inspired (food poisoning), I finished up some stuff I've been working on about methods to unlearn how to NOT be creative.

Another "opportunity" has come up - a tooth implant that's come loose and will require some minor dental surgery - which will of course involve "discomfort allayers" (read PAIN medication).

I've heard that morphine and codeine have inspired some pretty unusual ideas. . .

Comments, suggestions and constructive criticism will be greatly appreciated.


Unlearning How To NOT Be Creative

Re: Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

#2

thanks - this will be fun to read.

john lucas

>

Re: Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

#3

Re: Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative"

Cyril Griesbach

>Nicely done, Charlie. I went through most of it and found a lot of nails being hit right on the head. Thanks.

Re: Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

#4

How About "I'm just not artistic"?

Texian

>I'm (mechanically) creative as hell, but am struggling to make contact with my artistic muse. Got any tips for that?

Re: Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

#5

Re: How About "I'm just not artistic"?

charlie belden

>Texian:

Let's deal with one mental block at a time. ; )

Took me a week to put this stuff together on ways of getting around the mental blocks just the word "creativity" seems to put up in many people's minds.

Mentioning "art" could open up the "art" vs "craft" can of worms.

Re: Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

#6

Being An "Artist" Is Not A Requirement

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>It seems as if so many are hung up on being an "artist", "finding your voice" and all that other rubbish. Good grief, just enjoy turning or whatever you are doing. If you have the ability to be "artistic" then you don't have to think about it and agonize over it. "To be creative" is as about a subjective concept as you can come up with. IMHO it is a waste of good time to try to force something that may not be there.

Re: Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

#7

Re: Being An "Artist" Is Not A Requirement

john lucas

>Barbara I don't look at it as forcing someone. If the desire is there to learn, it can be taught, at least to some extent. I think this is what the articles were all about.

I took a class under Frank Sudol. Frank was probably a prime example of someone who elevated a craft to a fine art. It didn't come naturally, at least maybe not. Frank read a lot of books and studied with people like Mike Hosaluk to learn how to elevate his work to a new level. I read one of the books that he recommended and tried some of the exercises in the book. It was quite interesting. I'm not sure it made me an artist but it did make me think more about what I am doing.

I think it still boils down to your personal intent with this hobby. Some will have the desire to take it as far as they can and some will be perfectly happy making handmirrors all the time. Consequently I am open to both because they all have something to offer me, and that is education.

Re: Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

#8

John, That Is More Or Less What I Saident

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

#9

I Think You Need To Re-Read

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>My reference to "forcing" was not referring to someone forcing someone else. It was (simply) in reference to an individual who may not have the ability for creative thought with a unique outcome trying to force what they perceive as an "artistic" thought.

IMHO a truly creative person with unique perceptions has not learned this ability. We can teach techniques which can be used by different people to different levels of output.

Re: Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

#10

Re: Being An "Artist" Is Not A Requirement

Barry Elder

>Well said, Barbara! Thank you from all us klutzheads!

Re: Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

#11

Re: I Think You Need To Re-Read

charlie belden

>The Your Either Born With It - Or Not When It Comes To Being Creative view is kind of hard to support - if you've hung around with kids for any amount of time at all. Sometimes they have to get bored enough to start using their inherent creativity - but once they do - they can be very creative. They're born that way.

My premise - that we all, or at least a vast majority of we humans, start out creative and then are taught how to not be creative - seems true - based on personal observation - as a parent, teacher of both kids and adults, and as "the old guy in the neighborhood who has a bunch of stuff he'll help you make things out of". With little kids it may be just glueing a bunch of scraps and cuttoffs together and some poster paint, with teens it may be making a trebuchet which started out as "something to hurl water balloons at my neighbor's house" and with adults - well that one takes a bit of effort and encouragement.

I think it's the baggage that words seem to acquire. "ART" and "CREATIVE" are given connotations which can get in the way of the IDEA of the terms. Some seem to associate ART with "audacity", "snootiness", "affectation", "uppityness", "exclusivity" and other negative connotations. Same goes for CREATIVITY.

I haven't settled in on ART, but I'm pretty sure CREATIVITY is pretty universal - if you can get passed I CAN'T. I think almost anyone can learn to tap into their inherent creativity - and, if willing, get over the mental block - and be creative. Maybe not at an Einstein or Picasso level - but creative none the less.

So if the stuff I put together helps just one person over the I'm Just Not Creative self imposed roadblock - then I'm a happy camper.

Your mileage may vary. Void where prohibited by law. See local and state regulations for your area.

Re: Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

#12

You Are Very Welcome Barry.

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

#13

Re: I Think You Need To Re-Read

john lucas

>Barbara I certainly didn't mean to sound like I was taking you to task over this just trying to explain the other side. :)

Re: Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

#14

Re: Being An "Artist" Is Not A Requirement

john lucas

>Barry I think you would be surprised at the creativity that would come out of you if we give you a little direction. When I was learning photography we studied a lot of why's and to learn why people prefer this photo over that one, and then learned a lot of rules (that we all immediately wanted to break). Then the instructor put extreme limitations on us and sent us out to make a photo story. We all claimed not to be creative thinkers and certainly not artists but when trying to finish this assignment we all had to really attack it. This forced us to think outside out usual boundaries and we came up with surprising results.

I think everyone is creative they just suppress it. That's what Charlie's point is. If you work at it you will find that you still have some creativity down there somewhere.

Re: Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

#15

Re: I Think You Need To Re-Read

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>LOL John, I don't think there is one side or another. My statement was aimed at those people who either don't fancy themselves as "artists" or for one reason or another feel as if they are not full of originally creative thoughts. :-)

Re: Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

#16

My opinion: we are all................

Ruth Niles

>well, most of us humans are created with the same brain power. We can all be musicians, landscapers, chefs, artists. As small children we get direction or inspiration from adults. If we have an interest in something, anything, and we have the desire and discipline to practice.....we can do anything.

IF you really want to be artistic, you will study, research, try, practice and conquer. You may not become rich and famous but you will achieve artistic success.

IF you would like to be artistic but it's not a strong desire, well, you'll try this and that and be content.....which contentment is right on top with success.

Therefore, everyone is "right" in their opinion on artistic ability.

Re: Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative"

keith tompkins

>I'm going to offer a different opinion...we are all unique individuals; for example, if I gave everyone on wood central a block of wood to turn, each one would be different from the next. Since we are unique, we all look at things from our own perspective, based on our life experiences. People get uptight when someone mentions "find your own voice", but there is merit in this statement. Creativity is usually nothing more than taking the time to observe occurances in our everyday life and then applying them to our work..We need to understand our abilities, and focus on what we do best. I am a guitar player; just like visual artists, most guitarists struggle to "find their own voice" or develop a personal, identifiable playing style. For example,you can identify a BB King solo with just one note! Same with pretty much any guitar player...their music has SOMETHING TO SAY to their audience, there is a palpable connection there. Same with the well-known turners...it's not the signature on the bottom that makes the piece, it's the life-time of experience that went into the piece(s) that makes it work. Just like musical playing styles, we can identify the maker of many pieces immediately, with just a quick glance. Can anybody be creative? I'm fortunate to have a good deal of creativity, and teach that aspect of turning in all my classes. We cannot all reach the same level, but we CAN improve our own level of creativity.

Re: Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

#18

Each of us has a different ...

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>combination of talents and types of intelligence. There are many areas of intelligence: mathematical, musical, athletic, social, organizational, economic, linguistic, spatial/artistic. In fact there are books written on types of intelligence.

Some people seem to have ideas within themselves that just have to come out. There is a woodturner in the Capital Area Woodturners club in Alexandria, Virginia, named Chris Light. There were often two tables for show and tell - one for Chris Light and one for the rest of us.

There is a Finnish turner on WoW, Petteri Leppikallio (sp?), who comes up with some fantastic ideas and when you see his work you immediately know who made that piece. You also know that in a million years you would not have thought of that. There is no sequence of experiences that would lead you to think of that idea.

Time at the lathe may improve your skills and ideas may come to make a better "mousetrap", but most of us are going to fall far short of the likes of Chris Light or Petteri Leppikallio.

We are created with equal rights and opportunities, but we are not created with equal talents.

Ed

Re: Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

#19

Very Well Said !

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

#20

Can creativity be learned?

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>I think it might help if we quantify things a little here. When I think of pure creativity in woodturning I think of Michael Hosaluk and Clay Foster. Add Chris Light and Petteri Leppikallio, who I mentioned in my response to Ruth Niles above. These gentlemen are 10's on the imaginary creativity scale. Stephen Hatcher and Binh Pho are 10's on the my imaginary artistic scale, but I distinguish between them and the first four names. They may be equally creative, but I have no way of knowing that - nor do most of you.

Let's say that many of us have a creativity level of 4 or 5. There are probably things that we can do to improve our level to 6 or 7, but beyond that is just not going to happen.

Those who think most people are of about the same intelligence have never experienced being in a room with one of the greatest mathematicians in the world (now deceased). I witnessed a respected mathematician present his research and this man was anticipating the results and proofs as the material was presented. He jumped from mountaintop to mountaintop while us poor mortals struggled up and down the rugged terrain. What was even more remarkable was that the area was one in which the genius had worked twenty years ago and it was no longer his area of research. I never suffered from an inflated opinion of my mathematical abilities, but I knew that I fell far short of this man, as did many of my colleagues, all with their doctorates. It is impossible to understand sheer genius until you have really observed it.

Ed

Re: Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

#21

Brad Vietje

Re: Can creativity be learned?

Brad Vietje

>Ed, and also Keith,

This is an interesting question. I agree with Ed that a certain, perhaps limited, amount of creativity can be "learned" or developed, but I also agree with Keith that for many people there is merit in pursuing something until you develop your own "voice" or style. As Barbara points out, there are also many who just want to have fun and turn wood -- which is a creative act, in my book.

I'll go just a bit further. I'm not really sure creativity can be learned, but rather it can be released. Many of us never find a way to release our creativity. Sometimes structured activities -- like John's photography class assignment, or unstructured activities can release a new level of creativity. Sometimes I need to allow myself the freedom of expression to allow creativity to flow. When tense, worrying about work, or the stresses of life, this is less likely to happen. If we come from families that shunned the creative, and rewarded the pragmatic, this may be difficult to experience. Some people have trained themselves to get in touch with their creative side as a way of escaping the stress and routine of our daily lives. This is the "therapeutic" side of turning, or running, or music, or whatever.

My experience is that if we allow ourselves to play at something, many of us can be far more creative that we give ourselves credit for. The hard part is giving ourselves permission to relax -- and play.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

#22

Richard Feynman?

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>Ed reading your post made me think of Feynman, was that him?

I admire that fellow, too bad I never was exposed to him other than his books post mortem.

Thanks

Jorge

Re: Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

#23

Jean Dieudonne'

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>Jorge,

The mathematical genius I was referring to was the French mathematician Jean Dieudonne'. His knowledge was both deep and wide. Observing him as he anticipated the conclusions of the theorems being presented was truly an epiphany for me. I realized how incredibly talented and intelligent he was and how pedestrian I was.

There are many other mathematical geniuses, but he was the one I happened to observe.

Ed

Re: Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

#24

Re: Can creativity be learned?

charlie belden

>Re: being around geniuses - happened to have the opportunity to attend several of Buckminster Fuller's talks while he was Scholar In Residence at the college (now a university) I was attending. "Even" art students were encouraged by the Head of the Art Dept. to attend - "You may not understand some, perhaps much of what he's saying - but you can tell your kids and grandkids that you had the pleasure of spending several evenings with a 20th Century Renaissance Man.

Not surprising to anyone who attended - there was a burst of creative ideas and some interesting artwork created not long after.

Working with big computers - big for their day - that YOU had to go to IT to use (imagine that!) I often found myself in conversation with some really brilliant people who happened to be also working with computers. Since most "users" were Phds and many I later found out - prominent figures in their fields - they were just other "users" at the center. They, on the other hand, assumed I was one of their cohorts - which I most certainly wasn't.

But I quickly found that ANYONE who is excited by their "work" (though they saw what they were working on as fun and exciting - and often talked of "playing with this idea of . . .") whether wearing the label "artist" or "scientist" or "mathematician" or "physicist" or "musician" - all used much of the same vocabulary - symetry, beauty, amazing, awe inspiring (which ain't that far from AWESOME - leaving out "dude" of course) and elegant.

Though I understood perhaps a tenth of what they were saying, I sure got a creative buzz off of each one of them - enough of a buzz to remember some of those interactions 30 plus years later.

Maybe "If you want to be a lion, hang out with lions. If you want to be a sheep, hang out with sheep." has something to it.

And I sure wish I'd gotten to be around Richard Feynman for a day!

So maybe one of the ways to unlearn how NOT to be creative is to hang out with folks who've already done it. If jam sessions can produce some interesting and creative music, might there be a similar affect of jam sessions of woodturners? Come to think about it - isn't that one of the things that happens here?

Re: Some How To Get Around "I'm just not creative" *LINK*

#25

Re: Can creativity be learned?

George in Minnesota

>This reminds me of an article regarding where artists were divided into two camps; coneptualists and experimentalists. The conceptualists were the "prodigies" (i.e. Mozart) that were brilliant at an early age and then faded. The expermentalists were those who toiled and mastered their craft over many years and blossomed late in their careers. Very few artists span both and maintain and grow throughout their lifetime. Picasso is cited as one rare example of such an individual. An economist by the name of Galenson did an entire study of this. So the bottom line may be if you are not a prodigy, you still be can be creative or artistic through hard work and learning your craft. I would think the experimentalists would be more satisfied with what they have accomplished.

As someone mentioned earlier, people can get hung up with the terms creativity and artistic. If I can design an application at work that makes life a bit easier for an end user because of my training, and experience, I have been creative. If you take a slightly different cut to the piece on the lathe than you have never done before, you are being creative in your own realm. Whether someone thinks it is art or not is irrelevent, you are being creative and that is what fuels the fire within you. After all, most great artists are not celebrated until they are dead! 8-)

I would rather not worry about it and celebrate throughout my life.

George