I am considering a reciprocating handpiece for the Dremel. Something like Wecheer makes. What are the advantages over normal burrs in a dremel flexshaft? Who has used them before and what were you're experiences? I'd love to hear
>The advantages over rotary burrs are the same as when using hand tools. You can cut different shapes and reach into areas that you can't with rotary tools. One example would be a curved V groove or carving into a sharp corner. You do have to learn to sharpen the tools because they will need it repeatably.
The advantage of the reciprocating tool over hand tools is tough wood carves a little easier and grain direction is not quite as critical. I also find it to be much more controllable in some situations. It's kind of like the difference in rotarty vs hand. There are some things the hand tools will do that the reciprocating won't. The reciprocation tool just does some things more easily. You can still screw up with it if you don't use carving skills.
I agree with John. The recip. action makes carving more comfortable and easier on some denser woods that would be a chore to use a "hand tool". As John mentioned getting into tight areas or fine details is also easier. Along with the carving though there are also some "textures" that can be applied with a recip. tool. I know some will chuck a rounded ground nail in it to apply a light and controlled "orange peel" texture. Below is a picture of a bowl that I carved after turning. I sprayed a sealing coat of lacquer where I was going to carve. I carved, in this case some leaves, and painted the carving. The sealing coat of lacquer is easily sanded off and prevent any paint from absorbing anywhere but the carving. Just an example.
>With the right wood, the cut can be glass-smooth with a sharp reciprocating chisel. (cocobolo cuts beautifully) I find reciprocal carvers easier to control since the motor is applying force in tiny nearly continuous steps while force from the hand or mallet comes in bigger chunks. It is also easier for me to "feel" the grain to avoid work-splitting disasters.
It's a lot less effort as well especially in very hard wood, since the electrical power is providing the effort. I have no idea about the Dremel attachment - I use the Automach. It saves me a lot of time and I think results in a better job when I carve letters for signs. The last one I did was of hard maple.
I've not actually sharpened any bits, but use the honing kit made for hand-held carving chisels. These things stay sharp far longer than turning tools!
The "honing kit", are you talking about the Flexcut system with the different profiles on one side and the leather piece on the back? I've used that and also made some mdf wheels with the profiles on a MT2 arbor. I use the mdf wheels in case I damage an edge or the rest of the time the little Flexcut system works well.
Do you like the Automach? I saw Harbor Freight had "Automachs" for $180(ish). Don't know if they're old models or reconditioned.
Yes, that's the one. An experienced carver told me that's all I'll ever need to keep the tools sharp unless I drop one or run into a rock or something.
I like the Automach fine. It does get a little warm if used continuously for a long time, but I understand some of the other brands do the same thing. I'm thinking about getting the reciprocal head for my Foredom carver just to have a smaller piece to hold in my hand. I have a big hand-carved sign project coming up for a vet's office.
That sounds like a good price at Harbor Freight. I paid more than that at Woodcraft. Maybe I'll check into getting another one as a backup.
Using the dremel and this hand piece will obviously work. I would say it's more on the "light duty" side of spectrum compared to a Automach or something. For the light, occasional carving I do, this is just fine. For someone like the John Jordans (JJ or JKJ) I'd want the Automach.
>I do use mostly rotary carvers but they just won't get into some place. The also leave a rougher finish so if you need to carve an area that will be difficult to sand a sharp chisel is the preferred tool. A good example of that was the areas around the arteries on the heart on my Cardiac lamp and the places where there were folds in the heart.
Going to take a copy of your photo out to Iowa Heart next trip.
That is just what I need to replace my quad bypass that is not working well. I'm sure it would work cause it is a good match with my brain. Yours even comes with connecting tubing so no more veins need to be taken out of my arm or leg.
>Be sure the the Dremel you have will work with this attachment being talked about. A regular (as opposed to a hanging) Dremel will NOT work with it. The hanging Dremel and Foreham have a different type of flex shaft than the regular tubular shaped Dremels.
I use a Master carver system which has the same type flex as the hanging units, it has a table holder and can also be hung up. I like it because of the 4 different hand pieces that can be purchased with it, recip, 1/4" with drill chuck, small hand piece with collets 1/32 through 1/8" and a 90 degree.
I use Flexshaft tools with the reciprocator handpiece.
Really nice machine, I started with regular Dremels like most and 2 of those before finally biting the bullet and getting the Master.