Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

New lathe choice

Posts

New lathe choice

#1

New lathe choice

Marc Phillips

>Hi all.... been gone awhile, but after surgery and a move and a job change I have a shop again and started turning again... sure feels good!

Anyway, I have been turning on the Jet 1236 for about 3 years, and due to a decent tax refund I am considering getting a larger and better lathe...

I have been looking and reading and comparing, and, unless you have a better suggestion (I am all ears) I have so far narrowed it down to the Jet 2hp 16" or the DVR... both are around $2100 or so...

I can't picture outboard turning on the Jet with the headstock slid down to the other end.... is there an outboard attachment?

..... and I would like to have reversible capability to help with the sanding chores... and I don't think the Jet has that... and I have never turned on a lathe with this capability so I don't even know how valuable this is... or isn't :)

I am a little leery of the DVR due to being uncomfortable with electronics in a wood shop... and if it breaks the whole headstock goes back to the repairman?

I would sure appreciate your input on this... I have wanted a larger lathe for years and this will be the only chance I have to get one...

Thanks...

Re: New lathe choice

#2

Re: New lathe choice

paul waddle

>I share your concern about the electronics,but the DVR sure is a good one in this price range-BUT darn I love the look of a Robust! pw

Re: New lathe choice

#3

Bob Moffett

Re: New lathe choice

Bob Moffett

>I have had a DVR for about 5 years and am very pleased with it. I had problems with the electronics 1 time and they sent me a new headstock within a couple of days. It is easy to take the old headstock off and replace it. The headstock they sent me had the newer version of the electtonincs. I have also turned on the Jet 16". Both are good lathes, but I prefer the DVR. I have added one bed extension and the outborad turning attachment. If you are turning platters, the outboard tool rest is good. You can also turn larger than 16" and use the standard tool rest if you rotate the headstock to 22 1/2 degrees position. I don't have any financial affiliation with either Jet or Nova, just a very satisfied customer.

Re: New lathe choice

#4

Re: New lathe choice

Ron McKinley

>My third year on the DVR XP with no problems. The swivel head is the main reason I bought it and use it on every bowl and box that I turn. Never a problem with belts and pulleys, just continuous usable speeds from about 50 to 3000 rpm.........Ron

Re: New lathe choice

#5

Re: New lathe choice

John Jordan

>That Jet is a very nice lathe-we would have trade our mothers for one of those 20 years ago. You don't need outboard, you just slide it halfway down. It has a nice stand, too. If you look around you can get it considerably cheaper than that. I demo on both these lathes quite a lot, and prefer the Jet.

Nothing wrong with the DVR, but it's got some expensive proprietary parts.

John

Re: New lathe choice

#6

Re: New lathe choice

Marc Phillips

>I don't know where to look for a deal on the Jet or DVR honestly... seems like all the online places have the same price.

Do you have a source?

Re: New lathe choice

#7

Re: New lathe choice

david holley

>The jet has the reversible capability. You will like the way the jet is build

Re: New lathe choice

#8

Re: New lathe choice

Greg Haugen

>Marc,

I'd watch for Jet promos as well as places like Woodcraft or a local Jet dealer for sales. We have a dealer locally that has semi-annual sales that are pretty nice. Their service is also incredible! I've had the 1 1/2 horse Jet for about a year now. At the time I bought it, it was $500 to $700 more for the 1/2 horse upgrade to 2hp. Couldn't justify it for that. I've been really pleased with it. I like the features and how it's built. Most of the time I turn with it in "short bed configuration" with the headstock a little more than half way slid down for bowls and boxes. That's very nice!! If I'm turning a handle or something longer I just slide the headstock back and turn it. No adjusting the alignment.

Very happy with my Jet.

To be fair though, I haven't turned on a DVR.

Greg H.

Re: New lathe choice

#9

Re: New lathe choice

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Marc, you can find better prices at places like Amazon.

For most turners, the 1 1/2 HP is all they need. The 2 HP is around $350 more and is wired for 220 V while the 1 1/2 is 115.

One of the biggest improvements in lathes in years is the sliding headstock, which gives you a choice of a longbed or a shortbed lathe. For bowl and hollowform turning the shortbed is a huge improvement.

Wally

Re: New lathe choice

#10

Re: New lathe choice

Marc Phillips

>Ah... so, the 1 1/2hp version is identical except for the horsepower/voltage?

Re: New lathe choice

#11

Yes...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>

Re: New lathe choice

#12

JL

Re: New lathe choice

JL

>I turned on a friend's DVR. I now have a Jet 1642. The reason? I thought the Jet was beefier. I really like my Jet. I've got the 1.5 hp. Plenty of power - but I turn mostly spindles.

All of the Jet dealer's prices are fairly similar. I got mine at a woodworking show and got a 10% discount. You may try something similar. The dealers are getting hungry. You may want to try Redmond & Son out of Atlanta. They'll ship anywhere. http://www.redmondmachinery.com/

Re: New lathe choice

#13

Re: New lathe choice

Greg Haugen

>Marc,

The price difference is better now, when I bought mine last summer ($1399) it was on sale quite a bit but the 2hp wasn't.

I core bowls on my Jet 1 1/2hp regularly. There's nothing this lathe can't do. When I'm ready to "step up" a notch in lathes, mostly for swing, I'll move on to a Robust, Vega, or something else. For the price and stability of this Jet, I couldn't refuse.

Nice Machine.

Greg H.

Re: New lathe choice

#14

Re: New lathe choice

Marc Phillips

>Funny I didn't think of Redmond... I bought my Unisaw from them!

Thanks

Re: New lathe choice

#15

Re: New lathe choice

Tom Minehan

>I'm not sure you can get an unbiased response to your qurey. Those that have Jets will favor Jets, likewise those that have DVR's will favor DVR's. I don't remember ever reading a posting from someone who turned on both of them over a period of time and made an actual comparison. My only put is that I have turned on a DVR since they came out and have had no problems. I have to believe that reputable manufactures of lathes would take into account the environment that the lathe will see and take whatever precautions are necessary to minimize the problems: ie, dust.

Re: New lathe choice

#16

Re: Old Lathe Disposal Plan :>)

GalenV in Iowa

>Marc:

When you receive your new lathe your Jet 1236 will then be considered hazardous waste due to possible contamination by silica and toxic or non-domestic wood dust. You can safely dispose of said lathe by paying all freight cost to Ames, Iowa, and a standard disposal fee, payable at time of shipment. (Disposal fee adjusted as much as I can get out of you at time of shipment.)

I will insure it is properly handled and placed in a confined area in a concrete enclosure below grade (my basement shop). I wear a fully protected green smock and proper face and breathing protection to insure my own personal safety.

Being this close to Iowa State University, which yet glows from contamination of nuclear waste, and the testing of many animal diseases, I have invested heavily into this research facility and how to handle contaminated materials. (Currently putting two of my kids through ISU, one in Materials Engineering)

Again I want to stress the importance of the proper disposal of such a contaminated machine and feel you should do this as quickly as possible. (For my benefit as well)

Anyway:

Sounds like you can settle down and enjoy some turning after so many life changes.

Good luck with a new lathe. Sounds like things will be turning out well for you now.

Galen

Re: New lathe choice

#17

Re: Old Lathe Disposal Plan :>)

don lewonczyk

>I have a DVR and like it, no problems so far. I have mine extending out so I can turn walking sticks to 60". I have the cast iron legs under it and rigged up with a vacuum system, very nice set up. You might want to try the Toolnut store in N.Y.,you can find them on the web. For what I put in my DVR I bought a PM3520 from them for $2,699.00 including an 18" extention and that was a year ago, still cheaper then my DVR. I know they went up considerablly since then but give them a call. I don't know if they carry the Jet line but since they have the PM's I would think so. Ask for David and tell him you need a deal and he may help you out. It was free shipping also. Luck, DonL

Re: New lathe choice

#18

Re: New lathe choice

John K Jordan

>The Jet 1642? I use that (as do many others) and love it. I have the 110v version and it has PLENTY of power for me. I often turn in reverse, not only for sanding but to cut the inside of bowls - I can see better what I'm doing without leaning over the lathe.

I have some minis, but I'm considering getting a second large lathe for when I get my shop built. I thought about a Stubby or Powermatic, but I can see certain advantages of having two exactly the same.

JKJ

Re: New lathe choice

#19

Re: New lathe choice

Rick Davenport

>I had narrowed down my lathe decision to those two models a few years ago.

At the last minute, I switched to a PM5320.

It stretched my budget and raised my wife's eyebrows, but it is the last lathe I will ever need.

Lots of weight, power, sliding headstock, reverse and that lovely color that will actually grow on you.

R