Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Cracks (checks?) developing in bud vases

Posts

Cracks (checks?) developing in bud vases

#1

Chet Kloss

Cracks (checks?) developing in bud vases

Chet Kloss

>I turned a small bud vase for my wife for valentines day. I made it from half of a 6" x 6" x 3" piece of redheart bowl stock I purchased at Woodcraft. My wife liked it so much that she asked me to turn 4 more. I went and bought several more blanks. One of cocobolo, one of purpleheart, and one of figured maple. All of the blanks were covered with parafin except the maple block.

Each budvase was made with half of the bowl blank and is 6" tall and a little less than 3" in diameter at the widest point. They all have a teardrop shape (narrow near the top and bolbous near the bottom).

All vases were finished on the lathe with the same turning finish I use for pens. They all looked really good - for a while.

After between 12 and 36 hours all the vases developed cracks that travel vertically up the vase. All that is except the maple vase.

The purpleheart cracked the quickest - after just 12 hours, then the redheart after about 24 hours, and the cocobolo after about 36 hours. It's been 48 hours and the maple shows no cracks.

Could this be the result of the bowl blanks not being dry enough since they were sealed in parafin and the maple blank wasn't?

Or is there something else at play???

Thanks in advance,

,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,Chet

Re: Cracks (checks?) developing in bud vases

#2

Re: Cracks (checks?) developing in bud vases

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Could this be the result of the bowl blanks not being dry enough since they were sealed in parafin and the maple blank wasn't?

That has to be it, Chet. If you could hollow out the vases, that should solve the problem if they are hollowed to a fairly even wall thickness.

If you have a very small opening for the vase, you could hollow them from the bottom and glue in a plug.

Re: Cracks (checks?) developing in bud vases

#3

Brad Vietje

Re: Cracks (checks?) developing in bud vases

Brad Vietje

>Chet,

Almost certainly the blanks still contained more moisture than the place you stored them after they were finished. Drying doesn't crack them (in most cases), but drying unevenly or drying too fast does. If one area is much thicker, it holds onto more moisture, and creates a moisture gradient between think and thin areas, and that will often cause cracks.

Vendors and turners usually wax wood to slow the drying process so the blanks can be stored with minimal checking. I'd always assume a waxed blank was not dry, and treat it accordingly.

Unfortunately, if you need a finished product right away, like a gift for a particular date, you would be best to select a blank that's already been dried, or rough-turned and air dried sufficiently. The exotics you mentioned are all very hard, and some, like Cocobolo are very dense, oily, and slow-drying, as well. If you use wood that's not fully dry, you'll have to treat it as green wood until it stops losing moisture, then finish turn it.

How you handle unseasoned wood depends on your local climate. I wax exotics, difficult woods like Apple, or valuable pieces, and I usually place most wood species in a paper bag or cardboard box to slow the loss of moisture. Based on a suggestion from Wally Dickerman, I now apply butcher's paste wax to many pieces in the past 3 years instead of Anchorseal. I have an old can of Butcher's wax, and I apply a chunk to the spinning wood and smear/melt it onto the wood, then make sure I've gotten good coverage on at least all the end grain. I usually pile up pieces on the cool, damp-ish (Northern Vermont) floor, then move them to a shelf some months later when they get in my way. By then they've dried enough to rest in a warmer place on a shelf well above the barn floor.

I never use a moisture meter (because I don't have one), but I'm rarely in a hurry to finish a project. If I had to finish turn things on a fixed schedule, I'd either get a moisture meter, or a postal scale to record the moisture (weight) loss, to judge the stability of the wood.

Another strategy is to get the thickness close to the same in all areas of a turning, which often prevents cracking as it dries.

Best wishes and safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Cracks (checks?) developing in bud vases

#4

Re: Cracks (checks?) developing in bud vases

john lucas

>I frequent a lot of turning newsgroups and this is a recurring problem. The wood is most likely wet or at least not dry enough to not check. Ken is correct in his assessment.

Re: Cracks (checks?) developing in bud vases

#5

Richard Allen

Re: Cracks (checks?) developing in bud vases

Richard Allen

>A couple of things.

Did you finish the inside of the bud vases. Putting a finish on the inside can help slow down the moisture movement.

Did the sanding or finishing process heat up the bud vases.

The finish, if applied evenly the finish can provide a means to slow down the drying process.

While less than dry wood is always problematic but knowing the potential problems can make your success rate much higher.

Sanding, take your time and move to finer grits only when the coarser grit has finished doing it's work. Avoid sanding at high speed, with excessive pressure or for prolonged periods. It is a good idea to take your time and inspect the workpiece between grits.

Finish on all exposed surfaces is always a good idea. Epoxy is the only finish I know of which can stop the transfer of moisture. Different finishes slow the transfer of moisture at different rates. Applying the same level of finish to all surfaces will help prevent cracks.

Re: Cracks (checks?) developing in bud vases

#6

Chet Kloss

Thanks for all you help

Chet Kloss

>

Re: Cracks (checks?) developing in bud vases

#7

Re: Cracks (checks?) developing in bud vases

John Jordan

>Chet, as the others have told you, it's because the wood is not dry. If it is fairly straight grain, and I bet it is, put into a cabinet or paper bag, When the drying has equalized, the cracks will close up and may well be invisible. DON'T put glue in the cracks which will just wedge the cracks open.

John

Re: Cracks (checks?) developing in bud vases

#8

Chet Kloss

Thanks John - I'll try this!

Chet Kloss

>

Re: Cracks (checks?) developing in bud vases

#9

Dick Hines

Re: Cracks (checks?) developing in bud vases

Dick Hines

>Most of the wood you get at Woodcraft and other stores that sell to wood turners sell wet wood. If it has a wax coat on it chances the wood is wet.

You could rough the bud vases and let them dry and they may not crack. Maybe.

Re: Cracks (checks?) developing in bud vases

#10

Re: Cracks (checks?) developing in bud vases

Chet Gelnett

>I have nothing on the cracks but saw your first name and had to say Hi.

Re: Cracks (checks?) developing in bud vases

#11

Chet Kloss

Re: Cracks (checks?) developing in bud vases

Chet Kloss

>Chet's of a feather????