Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

Posts

Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

#1

Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Which is your primary cut with your bowl gouge...a push cut or a pull cut?

On the outside of a bowl or vessel, turners usually have a preference on which cut they usually use. The pull cut requires a side ground gouge, used with the handle well down, cutting with side grind more than the nose of the tool. It's best use is when cutting from the foot to the rim of a bowl on a face grain blank. The push cut is favored by many for roughing out a bowl because a heavier cut can be taken, especially with a side ground gouge. The cut is made more on the nose of the tool and with the handle closer to level.

Which cut do you most often use? Or do you use the pull cut at all? Some turners don't.

Wally

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

#2

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I have no idea how this was posted twice.

Wally

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

#3

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I forgot to mention that I use the push cut more than I use the pull cut. I seem to be more comforable with it.

Wally

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

#4

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

robo hippy

>Well, I use a scraper for roughing. I can push or pull cut without moving my hands or stance on both the outside and inside of a bowl. When I used a gouge for roughing, it was a pull cut with the handle lever, and the flutes at 90 degrees. For finish cuts, it is a push cut. Again, the handle is level on both the outside and inside of the bowl. When using the scraper at a shear angle for a finish cut, it is always a pulling cut, both on the outside and inside of the bowl.

robo hippy

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

#5

Both

Greg Haugen

>Both.

When I mount a "bandsawn" blank on the lathe, all push cut. Fast waste removal and shaping. I also turn during this time "left handed" so I'm not in the direct "line of fire" of the shavings. Being able to turn with either hand dominant helps alot. The inside of the bowls is always "push" cut obviously.

Depends on the bowl style I'm making will dictate what cut I use to finish the outside. If I have a detail that is pronounced, a bead for example, I'll use the pull more often. If I do not have any "details" pronounced above the line of form, I'll use the push cut. The push cut works much better from the "start to finish" approach without too many interuptions. The Pull cut is alot more forgiving about starting and stopping or even "building" up a detail that's pronounced, like Mahoney's "peak" that he puts on the outside of his bowls.

I use both regularly. Having more "cuts" in the skill arsenal, the better. Each has it's advantages and disadvantages.

Greg H.

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

#6

Re: Both

john lucas

>I use them all. I start a bowl between centers and start with the flute up and scraping type cut to get the corner rounded a little. Then I will use an aggressive pull cut going from the foot around the corner. Somewhere around the corner it turns into a push cut. So far this is the fastest and most controlled way of shaping the bowl for me.

The inside is all push cut.

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

#7

Wally.......

Richard Jones

>I use both. Pull cut for roughing/shaping, push cut for the final cuts, much better dealing with tear out with the push cut, at least for me.

Rich in VA

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

#8

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

Carole Valentine

>Sort of depends on the piece - the wood and the shape. I use both push and pull about equally I suppose. I am comfortable either way.

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

#9

It's the push cut...

Nick Sttagg

>for me, Wally.

I'm a big believer in the Stuart Batty 40 degree grind that leaves a finish ready for 180 sandpaper or higher. The one push cut from foot to rim has no equal as far as I'm concerned. I don't want to take the time to shear scrape a finish when a gouge push cut leaves one that's superior.

I will use a pull cut if the piece is out of round, or contains some inclusions or bark, as soon as it's round, though, I'm back to the push cut.

By the way, Wally, go easy on the BLM burls when you come up to Oregon this summer!!

Nick

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

#10

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

Bill Grumbine - Kutztown PA

>I like a pull cut most of the time, but I can and do use push cuts on occasion. After horsepower, the only limiting factor on how big a shaving I can take with a pull cut is how long the grind is on the gouge. I have been known to bury the edge all the way up to the unsharpened part of the flute. ;-)

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

#11

Push Cut

George Van

>Wally, after almost a year off to work on the house I have been doing some roughing and am actually in the process of finishing a few pieces. I found myself mainly using the push cut for both roughing and finishing. For roughing I found the tool rest takes the force instead of my arms and it doesn�t create tear out . For the shaping and final cuts I also like the push cut, many times with a conventional grind and a Thompson 3/8� round flute gouge. I turn mainly softer wood like black ash and spalted white & yellow birch. I find the small radius on this gouge in a push cut will allow 220 grit or better to start and will not pull the fiber from the soft wood. If I try to sand with the courser grits the detail is lost and the surface will get bumpy. On black ash the difference between the early and late wood will cause ridges, which don't look good if that was not my intention for an effect.

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

#12

Dick Hines

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

Dick Hines

>I use the pull cut to rough the out side of bowls. I like John start between centers. After I get the bowl in the chuck I will make one push cut to true the bowl up.

On the inside I use the push cut most of the time. Some times I will use the pull cut when I am trying to move a lot of wood.

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

#13

Brad Vietje

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

Brad Vietje

>Wally,

For roughing I use the push cut primarily. For finish turning I use a pull cut, with the handle at a steep incline and a healthy shear angle. I also use a "back cut" as Raffan puts it, with the flute facing up and handle close to horizontal, either with an Ellsworth gouge or a traditional straight-across grind on a bowl gouge.

I often use larger bowl gouges on the outside of fat spindles, and fairly often use long-bevel spindle gouges with a lowered tool rest and handle down low to get finishing cuts on the outside of bowls when using figured woods or when its tough to get a clean cut... guess I'm a little mixed up that way.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

#14

Pretty much describes my approach too.

Mike Brazeau

>

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

#15

Steven Antonucci

Same as Bill...

steve antonucci

>Every once in a while, I'll get the bowl "near round", turn the speed up to "fast enough" and take a heavy pull cut to impress the new guys...

20' streams of wood usually do the trick. I usually get a 220 finish with a fresh edge either way. For me, it's more about which one is more comfortable at the time I'm cutting. Some times, I can't drop the handle low enough to make a pull cut or can't steer the cut properly, and I'll use a push cut... Other times, the grain is running in and it's better to cut with the grain pushing in...

A basic skill is having both in your bag...

Steve

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

#16

Back to the pull cut

Steven Kubien

>I recently started using this more, especially for roughing and general shaping. It seems easier on my joints and I also find it easier to find a nice curve this way. Most be where I plant my feet and a pivot point a shift around...

Steve Kubien

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

#17

I remember that one...

Walt Drummond - Middlesex, NJ

>Wasn't that about the time Tommy Treager disappeared on an upward trajectory? :-)

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

#18

About half and half.

Gil Jones

>What ever works for the job at hand is what I use.

I am comfy using either one.

Gil

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

#19

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

Charles Watson------WebKitFormBoundary+ATeQdvhmFc4

>I use both depending on the shape or where I am in the turning process, but the push cut is used more frequently.

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

#20

Same Here

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>The pull cut more than the push in dried or highly figured, the push more so in wet green.

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

#21

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Hi Wally,

Like many others, the answer for me is that it varies. When roughing to get a piece round, I almost always use a pull cut. Once the piece is round, I tend to go about 40/60 towards the pull cut. I just seem to get better shape and control that way. However, once I have the shape, my final pass is almost always a push cut with the tool straight off the grinder. I find that gives the best surface I can get with a gouge and that leads to less sanding.

When working inside a piece, I am almost always pushing from the rim to the bottom.

Mike

Sigh, still winter in Apex, NC...

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

#22

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>I use both. I start everything between centers and generally use a push cut to round a blank and create the general shape I am striving for. I'll use a pull cut in a shear scrape fashion when doing the 'final' shaping of the outside and when establishing the tenon. Most of the time I'll use a push cut inside a bowl from rim to bottom and a pulling shear scrape for a finish cut.

keithz

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

#23

Re: Bowl Gouge...Push Cut or Pull Cut?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Some interesting answers. I'm surprised at how many turners seem to use the pull cut more than they use the push cut. I guess that it's because I didn't learn to use the pull cut until I'd been using the bowl gouge for awhile. Of course when I bought my first bowl gouge shortly after 1980 nobody knew how to use them. We were all self taught. Before 1980 almost nobody in the US had even heard of a bowl gouge. We hollowed bowls the hard way.

Wally