Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Goal for Spring-Better Sharpening

Posts

Goal for Spring-Better Sharpening

#1

Goal for Spring-Better Sharpening

George in Minnesota

>As the winter thaw starts here in Minnesota, I have set a goal to improve my sharpening setup as well as my sharpening skills. I can clearly see that I do not get nearly as sharp an edge at home as compared to when I am in a workshop getting the assistance of the instructor. With regard to my setup, I have an 8" slow speed grinder (the one Woodcraft routinely puts on sale) with the original wheels. I also have the Wolverine jig with the Varigrind attachment. My questions on the setup are:

1. What are good wheels to replace the originals with? I will predominately use both wheels for dressing the edges. I remember a recent thread on this.

2. Is the wheel balancing system a necessity?

3. What is easiest to use wheel dresser that also does a good job?

With regards to my sharpening skills, I am more of a visual learner and was wondering if there is anyone in the Twin Cities that gives instruction on sharpening? I checked with my local club and so far have not come up with a resource (although I haven't asked too many yet).

Thanks

George

Re: Goal for Spring-Better Sharpening

#2

Re: Goal for Spring-Better Sharpening

George Van

>George, are you anywhere near Duluth?

Re: Goal for Spring-Better Sharpening

#3

Re: Goal for Spring-Better Sharpening

Greg Haugen

>George, I'm just south of La Crosse, WI. If you're ever in the area you're always welcome to stop by. I'd check with Tim Heil, Bob Boettcher (sp), or some of the other turners that do a fair amount of turning in that club up there. I have the same set up as you; the woodcraft grinder and the wolverine. I like it, it does what it's suppose to. The whole issue with the wheels is this, perference. The "white" wheels that come with grinder are decent AO wheels. One is 120 and one is 60. If you like those grits, stay with them. In my opinion the best wheel on the market is a "K" grade Norton 3X wheel. They only come in 80 and 46 grit wheels which is a good balance for spindle or bowl tools. Sharpening Supplies (.com) has "k" grade wheels for $46 each. White wheels will usually run around $20. Pink AO, a little harder than white so lasts a little longer, are around $30. The Norton 3X will out last white and pink wheels by quite a bit.

I've never found a reason to have a balancer. Possibly if they're really cheap crappy wheels, but by the time you buy it, just buy better wheels and save yourself the headache. I just have never had a reason or an issue. If there were an issue, I'd try spending a few dollars in changing the plastic bushings on the wheel before the bucks for a balancer. I've bad or loose bushings and for a couple of bucks, a new set fixed the problem.

The best wheel dresser, in my opinion, is the single point style that Bill Grumbine (wonderfulwood.com) sells. I've used one before, even though I don't own one, yet. I currently have the usual "T" shape style but I like the other style alot better. It will be an upcoming purchase soon.

Hope that helps,

Greg H.

Re: Goal for Spring-Better Sharpening

#4

Re: Goal for Spring-Better Sharpening

John K Jordan

>George,

There are recent threads on wheels and balancing. Search the recent messages back 4-5 months for keywords like Norton 3x, balancing, grinding wheel. I bought the blue norton 3x K series in 46 and 80 grit for use on the slowspeed grinder Woodcraft sells.

I use the Oneway balancing system which is very nice, although your wheels may balance OK without it after truing - mine had significant vibration.

I bought the single-point diamond dresser that Bill Grumbine sells - it works great with the Wolverine for truing. I also use a T-shaped multi-diamond truing stick for touching up the surface while sharpening so I don't have to mess with the jig or table position.

I use the Tormek for most gouges and scrapers - it's hard to imagine an easier way to get a consistent and flawless razor edge on a tool. It's kind of worthless for reshaping and can be tedious for skews. Like others, I hone many times between sharpenings.

JKJ

Re: Goal for Spring-Better Sharpening

#5

Re: Goal for Spring-Better Sharpening

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

>I use the Woodcraft grinder and use the Norton 3X wheels. I thought I had a good setup (wolverine system) untill wife gave me a Oneway Balancing kit. What a differance! My grinder now runs as smooth as glass It will coast for 5 minutes or so after it is turned off. There is not a sign of tool bounce and the finish on the bevel is far smoother I followed the instructions but wih one differance. After I balanced and trued the wheels, I rebalanced the wheels. The Wolverine Wheel dresser is the best for truing the wheels or removing grooves, but I prefer a T-bone style dresser for touch-up use. One thing that is essential is "USE A LITE TOUCH"! You should be supporting 95 plus precent of the weight of the tool! When I started turning,I bought a set of cheap Harbor Freight tools and used them to practice sharpening on. It was a was a well spent $25.00

Just 2 cents worth,

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

Re: Goal for Spring-Better Sharpening

#6

The Wheels on Your Grinder are OK...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I have the Woodcraft grinder. It seems that some of them run smoothly and others don't. I lucked out because mine runs smooth. I see no need for a balancer. There are better wheels on the market but the wheels that come with that grinder will do the job if you keep them dressed properly.

Wally

Re: Goal for Spring-Better Sharpening

#7

Re: The Woodcraft grinder and wheels.....

Jamie D

>....are usually Ok if they run true. Some need to be aligned by making an index mark on the side of the wheel, then re-positioning by rotating a bit at a time with the nut just loose enough to allow movement. Other problems such as sloppy bushings and stamped metal flanges rather than machined cause the wheels to wobble, and this is often easily corrected by rotating the wheels until they run true.

Re: Goal for Spring-Better Sharpening

#8

Re: The Woodcraft grinder and wheels.....

Gil Jones

>I agree with Wally and Jamie. My Woodcraft (slow speed, $79) grinder and its wheels work just fine. I did need to waste an hour repositioning the wheels to get them to run true, but it was worth the effort. I thought about buying a fresh set of better quality wheels for when these wear out, but in stead I just bought a whole new grinder (same $79 slow speed) for the price of two 8" reasonable quality wheels. A spare grinder and a fresh set of OK wheels are in the box waiting. That may seem like a money waste, but the price has already gone up a bit.

Gil

Re: Goal for Spring-Better Sharpening

#9

Re: Goal for Spring-Better Sharpening

Rich Egan

>Greg:

I have a Norton 3X wheel, and it is a good product, but the one I have was made terribly out of balance. Try as I might, I could not get a sharp tool edge off that wheel. You can't dress out a condition like that. I recently obtained a Oneway balancing kit, which I installed on that wheel, and it made all the difference. I had to slide both screws and washers to the 12-o'clock position (if you have one, you know what I mean) to get that bad boy to run true. The other stock wheel needs the same treatment, but it is a Delta, and does not have a 1" center hole, so the balancer flange will not fit.

Rich

Re: Goal for Spring-Better Sharpening

#10

Re: Goal for Spring-Better Sharpening

George in Minnesota------WebKitFormBoundaryqq8Tyv6

>Thanks for all the input!

George

Re: Goal for Spring-Better Sharpening

#11

shaft off-center?

John K Jordan

>Rich,

Are you sure it's the wheels? Seems odd that two wheels would both be that far out of balance. I read that some of the grinders had shafts a bit off-center due to quality control issues. Could check the shaft with a dial or test indicator or a straight stick.

JKJ

Re: Goal for Spring-Better Sharpening

#12

Re: shaft off-center?

Rich Egan

>John:

I thought of that as well. No movement in the bearings or shafts on the grinder that I can tell. The factory Delta wheel has a 5/8" center hole, so I slipped it over a bearing on the Oneway stand, and it promptly rolled over and settled heavy end down. No doubt it is out of balance. It's my understanding some of these grinders are balanced after the wheels are installed, but not sure that is true. I've been planning to replace that wheel anyway, so now I have an excuse.

Rich