>Nothing really wrong with my sanding process/technique, just always looking for Something New.
Aside from store-bought vs. home made, what are you thoughts on these tools? Better/same/worse than hand sanding? Better/same/worse than power sanding?
Thanks, have a great day, and wishing all fine relaxation at the lathe.
Rich (going to the Greensboro Woodcraft later today........) in VA
>Richard, abut ten years ago I made Inertia Sanders out of a stick I turned for a handle and drilled a hole through at an angle. Used a forstner bit and made a bearing recess. Use a bearing I had and cut down a large pad I bought at Lowes. It was PSA. There may have been two of them.
It worked well enough, but I eventually bought several H & L disks and use them in a drill. Apparently I like that better, because the Inertia one got retired into a drawer and is seldom seen and never used.
If I were doing it again, I would make six or eight, one for each grit and make a rack for them and keep them in order. This would avoid changing the sandpaper often. Neither type does real well at channing over and over and the PSA type basically won't stand for it. One advantage to this would be to make your own disks out of large sheets of sandpaper. I think you can make them for about a nickle each that way. The same applies to H&L.
>I like "Power"! "grunt grunt grunt-Tim the toolman Taylor"
The useful side of the inertia sanders would an area that could be reached by a straight drill/mandrel. For example, a larger opening vessel to get around the corner and along the wall or something. Even then I'd probably sand it by hand or with a bent forceps. I do think there's a purpose for them, I just don't use one or have one. It would just sit in my drawer too. :-)
Just my two cents and you probably deserve change back. :-)
I probably do over 85% of my sanding using a 'close quarters' angle drill (Milwaukee) and hook and loop abrasives. I also do some hand sanding where appropriate. For that last 5-10% of the sanding jobs on turnings, I use an inertia sander made by Bruce Hoover - "The Sanding Solution" - which is fully adjustable as to head angle and rotating axis position, and also has extension bars, etc. so you can sand within deep vessels. See the link below.
Like everything else about woodturning, it pays to have a few (or many?) specialty tools to do those 'atypical' procedures a bit more efficiently and to produce a higher quality result. Inertia sanders can be counted among these, but if given the choice between inertia and power sanding, power would win without question.
>I'm going to go against the grain here and say that I use my inertia sander a lot. I have the sander that was introduced about 15 years ago by Vic Wood. I've been using mine for that long and it's still going strong. A very similar one is being sold under the name of Skilton.
An intertia sander doesn't work well on the inside of a bowl, but then I seldom turn open bowls.
If your lathe can be run in reverse, it helps a lot on difficult woods to do some of your sanding in reverse.
>You can use a power sander when the lathe isn't spinning which you can't do with an inertial sander. Hand sanding is the slowest, and power sanding is a must for production work.
>think I'll pass on it, looks like a majority. I took my younger daughter with me to Woodcraft, she got to looking at pen blanks, gel refills, etc., and I bought that, forgot all about the sander. Guess senility pays off occasionally......
Thanks for all of your input. Guess I'll stick with the power sanding. Will post a pic when I get home tonight of a power sanded piece and let you be the judge.
>I think it depends on what you turn. On bowls and my hand mirrors I found them pretty much useless so I agree with Jamie. On hollow forms and the outside of bowls they seem to work but for me not worth the money.
>Jamie, as I've already said, I've been using my Vic Wood Inertia sander for about 15 years on hundreds of pieces and it's NOT a useless toy. It doesn't work well on the inside of open bowls, but I seldom turn open bowls
I have a Makita right angle sander which I use at times, such as on the inside of an open bowl, but usually I prefer my inertia sander.
I've tried the Sorby inertia sander and I don't like it.
>I also use the original Vic Wood sander on the outside of bowls and long spindles such as roiling pins and columns. I have a 2" Grip-a-disc sander that I use on everything small including pens, bottle stoppers, weed pots, small bowls, etc. Once mastered, nothing else has worked nearly as good or fast for me.
>I should add that when I use the inertia sander I use it at about the same speed that I turn. Between 1500 and 2000 RPM for pieces under about 9 inches. It won't work well at slow speeds.
>....I tried the Sorby a long time ago and found it to be much more complicated to master than the angled power sanders. I certainly don't think the price justifies the investment over a good power sanding set-up that can do just about all the sanding operations needed.