Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

More on threading boxes? Long..

Posts

More on threading boxes? Long..

#1

More on threading boxes? Long..

paul waddle

>I've just finished reading part of Fred Holder's book on cutting threads in wood. Saving the hand threading for last.

Fred discusses Bonnie Klein jig,Nova orinmental jig,and Beal jig.Each works differently todo the threading. There is one outstanding feature of the expensive Nova jig(involved with threading that is),one can loosen the "grub" screw (American is set screw ha ha),swing the chucked up box part,and test the thread fit. I suppose,if the threading screw is long enough,you can back it off on the BK jig or put a stop on the lathe bed and loosen the complete jig and pull back and return to start without loosing accuracy. I have to back off my cross feed 4 complete turns to do so,then go back the same amt. I manage,but there's a place where inaccuracies can result if too much slack in the cross slide screw. Best to lget a good fit first cut...

There is one question I cannot understand: when cuttin the outside thread on the male(bottom part),its climb cutting? I guess it is a moot item,but for a right handed cutter,it has to put more pressure on the threads. Now its not dicussed,with the Nova and BK jig,one can start at the rear shoulder of the box and cut the thread backing out the feed screw... I've tried this,it works,but makes no difference that I can discern.....I believe with the Beal jig,one can reverse the feed and use a left hand cutter...hmm.wonder how that works...pw

Re: More on threading boxes? Long..

#2

Re: More on threading boxes? Long..

john lucas

>Paul I have cut threads in both directions with my Baxter threader and both the router and my Nova Comet as the drive. I can't tell the difference. It does seem to cut a cleaner on soft woods with the router but it's running at 20K while the Nova's top end is 3K.

The Baxter threader has a very long thread so you can turn the threads and then back it off to check for fit. There is a limit however so you can't do taller boxes this way. I'm going to build a now holder for my router and I'm thinking about adding a swinging feature that would index back to the 0 position. This way I could simply swing the router with cutter to the side, test fit the lid and then lock the router back in place and do another cut.

Re: More on threading boxes? Long..

#3

Re: More on threading boxes? Long..

paul waddle

>Now your talking John! I was thinking the same thing. I would mount my tail stock on a "round table". I suppose either cutter or tail stock end turn would work.

After reading Fred's book,I'm afraid my box lids have to be turned 3 or 4 times to open. I'm either going to have to make the threaded tenon shorter or go for a coarser thread.

I am a little confused about Fred's box making technique,in the beginning pages he first threads the bottom, and then the lid. Later chapter on box making,he threads the lid first-guess can be done either way. Seems at first he turns a tenon on the bottom that barely clears the threads on the lid,then touches the cutter to this to get correct dept. The more in depth I study this,it makes sense, but my

fits don't improve. Either the wood moves or my wood is too soft. pw

Re: More on threading boxes? Long..

#4

Re: More on threading boxes? Long..

john lucas

>Paul I do threaded boxes either way. I haven't found makes much difference. I usually make the bottom first simply because that's the way I learned to make boxes. I do almost always put the male thread on the bottom, at least for functional boxes. I don't want the contents to get in the threads and it makes the interior of the bottom larger. Every once in a while the male thread simply needs to be on the top, such as finials for hollow vessels.

Re: More on threading boxes? Long..

#5

Re: More on threading boxes? Long..

paul waddle

>That makes sense John,after parting the top,the bottom is still chucked up and running true,not much need of removing. I'll try this method. I just learned to do the top first from the BK tape.

Slight change of subject;is there a book or article on making homemade hand threading tools. Maybe solder tool steel in the middle of soft steel,turn and thread in a metal lathe? Then separate, and sharpen? tks,pw

Re: More on threading boxes? Long..

#6

Re: More on threading boxes? Long..

john lucas

>I've seen a few articles over the years on homemade thread chasers. I don't think I can find them. One was on using old chisels and regrinding the tip. I actually saved a chisel for this but ended up using it for something else.

Re: More on threading boxes? Long..

#7

Re: More on threading boxes? Long..

paul waddle

>Oh well, I can use a thread screw pitch guage to lay out the threads and file them in...Seems to envolve less energy this way.

Own my last thread,a person can cut off the longer bottom and leave the top chucked up too. Work on the top without unchucking. Don't understand why Bonnie didn't do that?? Its taking pcs in/out of chuck, that causes some problems -especially wood as it compresses. Oh well,seems to be a myriad of ways of going about this threading-thats what makes it so interesting to me. pw.

Re: More on threading boxes? Long..

#8

Re: More on threading boxes? Long..

robo hippy

>Being rather new to the threaded boxes thing, I find this ineteresting. I never really thought about threading direction when cutting. I do rough turn my pieces first: turn cylinder, part it off into top and bottom, hollow out top and bottom to 1/2 inch thickness to allow wood to 'adjust' before final turning, glue pieces to waste blocks, then final turn a week or 2 later. I do find it a bit of a pain to have to screw the threading jig way out to remove one piece to test the thread cut to see if I need to go deeper. I have thought it would be nice to be able to put a power thing on the mechanism to save the manual work, but not really practicle. A swing away mechanism sounds interesting, but would worry about getting it back on accuratly. I have too many different sizes/depths of boxes to use spacer shims between the headstock and the jig. I have set the jig back up after removing it and had to reallign it up by eyeball, and that works fine if I remember my high magnification glasses. Soft wood or hard wood doesn't seem to cut a whole lot differently, the main thing seems to be when you chase the threads with super glue. I prefer to do it before they are cut all the way to a point on the top of the thread, say at about 90% of final depth. Oh, well, about 1,000 more, and I will have it down.

robo hippy

Re: More on threading boxes? Long..

#9

Re: More on threading boxes? Long..

paul waddle

>robo,are you using a BK,a Baxter,or homemade thread jig? I will glue up a stop when I incorporate this in my homemade jig,so realignment is no problem.If you are threading on the a lathe,you might have to make a 2pc base,so it can be turned.Mark it and return to mark.

I would recommend The Fred Holder book,it shows at least three different threading jigs.Bonnie Klein tape is good,surely Baxter has something similar..

Email me if I can be of any help. I'm curious as to your gluing up waste blocks to your boxes-guess you have to glue and turn these true after glue up? Oh my,there are so many ways to skin this cat....pw

Re: More on threading boxes? Long..

#10

Re: More on threading boxes? Long..

robo hippy

>Paul,

I took a 3 day workshop with Bonnie last fall, and had so much fun that I had to buy a mini lathe and Bonnie's threading jig. It would have been pretty difficult to adapt the jig to my Robust. Only done 50 or so boxes thus far. Bonnie's method (she did mention that she needed to update her video which was 10 years old) is to take a bunch of the 1 inch by 8 tpi locking nuts with the nylon inserts, turn out enough of the nylon so that you can thread it onto your lathe, and glue the nuts into/onto some pine waste blocks. I have 80 or so. You mark rings on the blocks to help center the box pieces on them, lid on one, bottom on the other. No chuck. They do need to be trued up before final turning and threading, but rough turning cuts way down on wood movement after you have turned them. I also cut threads for turning off the bottoms rather than a jam chuck, and keep each one. After a while, I will have one to fit any box I do. Well, at least in theory. Since I glue up 10 or more at a time, I do number each waste block so I don't get any more mixed up than I already am.

robo hippy