Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Repetition Leads to Proficiency OR Boredom?

Posts

Repetition Leads to Proficiency OR Boredom?

#1

Repetition Leads to Proficiency OR Boredom?

charlie belden

>It seems the really good woodturners do basically three or four kinds of pieces, over and over again - of course with variations either in the wood or in subtle changes to the shape, perhaps even adding enhancements - inlaid rims, pedestal base, carved foot, pyrogpraphy,etc..

While it's true that repetition - even with some variations - leads to proficiency - and probably refinement of a shape or technique - for me at least, it gets BORING. There are SO many types of turning, so many shapes/forms, so many tools and techniques to play with (emphasis on play).

About three years into this turning journey I've gotten fair to pretty good with a curved edge skew and a poor man's bedan (a quarter inch bench chisel). I like doing lidded boxes with finials so I've done a couple dozen or three of them - but that's about the only area I've sort of really gotten into. Most of the other areas have been maybe three OF and then boredom sets in - Been There, Done That, Got The T-Shirt. Then, thanks to the internet, I see something else to try and the patterns is repeated - do two or three - get the basics down - and move on. I supect I have TADD - Turner's Attention Deficit Disorder - Hey Look! An Escoulen Chuck! What about Thread Chasing?! TWISTS!

There's always something new to try so it's difficult - at least for me - to be disciplined enough to take one idea or technique and work with it to the point where there's no way to improve it - to take it to the point of being Just So - and then keep turning pieces like that - to that level of refinement.

I admire Cindy Drozda's dedication to her work and can see that discipline and repetition, along with a great sense of proportions, can take something like a finial to a whole new level. Her pieces are exquisite - as close to perfection as possible - in every detail - refined to the Nth degree and finished beautifully. She takes each piece as far as a mere mortal can take it - crisp where it should be crisp, smooth and flowing where it should be smooth and flowing - and everything working together so perfectly - synergy - the whole greater than the sum of its parts.

While I can appreciate such works and admire the skill and discipline required - I can't envision myself ever doing 30, 50 or 100 of basically the same thing using the same technques and procedures - over and over and over again.

Perhaps after 10 or 15 years of running down almost every path I see that looks interesting, I may find one I fall in love with and settle down, next to an ocean - the Siddhartha Syndrome.

But for now, there's Adding Actual Movement, Internal Lighting and Jewelry using mainly turned elements - of wood.

If you've found your "turning love" - do you at times think there might be another out there somewhere? Are you tempted to look?

If you haven't found your "turning love" how will you know when you do?

Just wondering - out loud.

Re: Repetition Leads to Proficiency OR Boredom?

#2

Re: Repetition Leads to Proficiency OR Boredom?

john lucas

>Charlie I tread a fine line on this. I do occasionally do long runs of Christmas ornaments or Wine stoppers. You have to make a game of it. Even though I'm turning the same finial for the 25th time there are very fine details that I try to perfect in each one. You try to get this curve to work with that cove, or you try to get the negative space created by a cove and bead to represent some other shape. It gets kind of interesting doing this.

When I make the ornament balls it's the same thing. You have a shape in mind and you try to improve on it. Then you'll get a piece of wood that just tells you it wants to be a different shape so you try to perfect that shape for a while.

I don't like to do repetitive all the time but they can be fun if you make it that way.

The best thing about repetitive work is the proficiency in tool usage. You learn to use the tools quickly and you play games to see how long you can use one tool or can you use this tool better.

Re: Repetition Leads to Proficiency OR Boredom?

#3

Re: Repetition Leads to Proficiency OR Boredom?

Chip in Plano

>For me it's about growing. I started with home repairs, to carpentry, to building outdoor furniture, to building fine furniture with/without powertool, etc....but all in the flatworld. Turning was the next evolution in working with wood. Now I am about where you are. I am bored but I am excited. I'm working out themes for series pieces and not so much the one-off pieces. I'm studying other people's works. I'm studying nature and man. I'm exploring other arts & crafts. It will all end up in my turnings in some form but I may find the next evolution elsewhere, too. I'm on a path of personal exploration. I am impatient; therefore, I am also a chaos junky so I leave the path repeatedly. I'm growing. If I wasn't growing, I'd be dying. I'm also a bit self-destructive and for that I have sponsors/mentors.....and wear a facemask.

Thanks for sharing. I connected.

Re: Repetition Leads to Proficiency OR Boredom?

#4

Steven Antonucci

Not Or but AND

steve antonucci

>That title is a logical hell, but also the right answer. (I can see Ellis' supercomputers trying to process it right now and smoking...)

I think repetition leads to proficiency, and proficiency leads to boredom. Part of the early excitement of turning is doing something new and the "danger" that it may not end well...

Once you've aquired the skills necessary through repetition, you lose the element of "will this come off the lathe in one piece?" Success is almost guaranteed, so you can work more quickly and confidently. This leads to making more of the same things- which in my case, bores me endlessly.

I need to go do something that I can't do, so I can feel that sense of accomplishment I had 5 or 10 years ago (even though the work wasn't very good!) I FELT like I had done something new...

Steve

Re: Repetition Leads to Proficiency OR Boredom?

#5

JL

The Zen of turning?

JL

>I do furniture - which means I turn at least four legs for each piece. I have a lot of repetition - and everything has to be pretty much the same.

I also make the spindles for my Windsor chairs by hand (split, rive and shave). They pretty much have to be the same also. (We won't go into the other hand work like making splats or rungs for ladderbacks.)

There is sometimes a Zen like feel to making spindles or turning legs, stretchers and stiles. Sometimes you are "into the moment" and you get close to a feeling of Satori.

You have to become one with the wood, grasshopper ;).

Or maybe it could be extreme boredom. I still make furniture.

Re: Repetition Leads to Proficiency OR Boredom?

#6

Re: Repetition Leads to Proficiency OR Boredom?

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>When I was reading the excellent book, Notes From The Turning Shop by Bill Jones, he made a point about doing repetitive turnings. I think he called it developing muscle memory, the idea that if you do a thing often enough your body learns to do it and you don't really have to think about it. And he makes a case that this is a good thing because most turnings are accomplished with a series of pretty standard cuts. Becoming a proficient turner takes some experience, some repetition.

I also saw some of this when I saw a demonstration by Stuart Mortimer. If you have seen him you know what I mean. He starts by explaining the basic cuts made with a skew, then goes on to show how most everything he turns is based on these basic cuts.

For instance, I make pens. The more pens I make, the easier they are for me to make. What once took a lot of thought is now second nature. When I turn other spindle items, I find that many of the same actions translate over to larger turnings.

Just an opinion.

Scott.

Re: Repetition Leads to Proficiency OR Boredom?

#7

Does it really matter?

Russ Fairfield

>Like most things we do in life, there are only three reasons to turn wood. We do it for the fun of it, for the recognition, or for the money. Sometimes we get lucky and are able to do all three at the same time.

If you are in this just for the fun, then you can do anyuthing you want. If you want the recognition or the money, you have to be good at it. That take practice, and a lot of it. If you find the practice repititous and boring, then you need to find something that is a faster gratification than turning wood.

Re: Repetition Leads to Proficiency OR Boredom?

#8

Re: The Zen of turning?

Donna Banfield

>I understand the Zen feeling you're referring to, but I feel that when I'm using a scary sharp carving or hand tool, as it slowly peels slivers and shavings away from a piece of wood.

There's something immensely satisfying about that.

Maybe I'm weird...

...o.k....no 'maybe' about that. ;^)

Re: Repetition Leads to Proficiency OR Boredom?

#9

Re: Does it really matter?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Well, that suscintly sums it up very well.

Re: Repetition Leads to Proficiency OR Boredom?

#10

Re: When It quits being fun, It becomes work!

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

>

Re: Repetition Leads to Proficiency OR Boredom?

#11

you are correct, but sometimes you just gotta work

john lucas

>

Re: Repetition Leads to Proficiency OR Boredom?

#12

Re: Repetition Leads to Proficiency OR Boredom?

charlie belden

>While it's true that repetition, when it comes to cuts with a specific tool, does develop muscle memory - it's not that type of repition I have trouble with. I've found I do four or five types of cuts with a curved edge skew or poor man's bedan - I use them basically the same way. And I've gotten to the point with those two tools where I can make cuts without thinking about how - think it and the hands and tool do it.

It's making basically the same thing - sure with variations in proportions, size and wood - but the same thing - over and over again. I can trick myself - as suggested - by making it a game - but only for four - maybe five of a kind at most.

Maybe it's that my To Try List is too long - and new ideas keep getting added to it - that makes repetition seem like an anchor - wanting to hold me here - when I want to check out over there.

I have to wonder if the well known turners - with signature pieces in galleries, museums and collections ever feel trapped by their reputation for making one or two types of pieces - Ellsworth Hollow Forms, Nittman's woven/beaded geometric surface treatments. The Gallery/Museum/Collectors create Market Inertia - "You're known for these types of things - that sell well - so that's what we want to handle." If these talented people were to change directions and do something completely different - would they be encouraged - or shoved back to what they're known for.

Dylan got booed off the stage the first time he went "electric". He was buttonholed as a folk singer and an acoustic one at that. He was able to overcome his audience's inertia and go off - successfuly - in new directions, and his audience eventually caught up to him - and new folks got into the "new stuff". I doubt whether there are many successful dylanesque wood turners on the scene today.

So maybe it's better to remain in obscurity turning whatever seems interesting - and preferably fun.

Or maybe it'd be a lucky thing to find a form or style that fulfills the interesting and fun criteria and really get into it - early on. Maybe in another two or three years I'll find some combination of spinning wood and pokin' it with a sharp tool that says "THIS is what you've been searching for!".

So - if YOU've found one, or maybe two types of turning that you've developed a real passion for making - and refining - are you ever tempted to have a go at other types of turning? Or does the idea of Climbing Another Learning Curve discourage even trying?

Re: Repetition Leads to Proficiency OR Boredom?

#13

Re: Repetition Leads to Proficiency OR Boredom?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Turners who sell their work have to make a decision. Am I turning for myself and what I like or am I turning for my customers and what they like. Some turners don't want to admit it, but if they are to be sucessful they must turn for the customer.

You are correct in that the big name turners become known for certain forms and certain kinds of enhancements. Most of them have ventured out with other kinds of turnings and not always sucessfully. Most have made changes gradually. I have known J. Paul Fennell for a long time and watched his work develop over the years. He is using the same basic form that he was using 25 years ago, but his development has been in the many forms of enhancements he constantly experiments with. He has reached near perfection in what he does.

Repetition is a necessary part of a turners development. How many hundreds of finials did Cindy Drozda turn before she became known as the queen of finials? How many beaded and enhanced platters did David Nittman turn before they became well known as works of art?

Speaking of repetition, Dale Larson turns several hundred salad bowls every year. He has won awards for his salad bowls in art shows. I know Dale and I can tell you that he turns because he enjoys it.

In my own turning, I have turned many hundreds of variations of the same forms, always striving for the perfect form. I can tell you that the perfect form is very elusive. In recent years my enjoyment has been in trying various kinds of enhancements. It takes a lot repetition to achieve any level of perfection. I've tried beading, pyrography, piercing, coloring, segmenting and more. I'm improving in all of these but there is much room for improvment, and that is where my enjoyment lies.

Wally

Re: Repetition Leads to Proficiency OR Boredom?

#14

Re: Repetition Leads to Proficiency OR Boredom?

charlie belden

>I guess I should have distinguished between repetition of cuts made with a specific tool and repetition of turned objects.

I play mostly with a curved edge skew and lately a poor man's bedan which, in many cases, works like a skew - at least the way I use them. And because I'm not switching tools, muscle memory has developed for them - think a cut and and the muscle memory makes it happen - sometimes there's no pre-thought - it just happens by itself - a cove, bead, V-groove, square cut, peeling cut transitioning to a roll then a counter roll to create an ogee - no thinking involved.

But with repetition of shape/form - there's usually a lot more time involved in doing each piece. Granted, the time required to do the second one, especially right after the first one, and with the first one sitting in front of you, is less than the previous turning - but still involves a fair amount of time. AND - there's still some interest level in the one being turned now.

There are so many things to try - and figure out how to do - in the world of turning possibilities. And when you start thinking in terms of multi-discipliines - there are even more waiting for someone to explore.

Maybe it's my engineering training and my interest in drawing and painting and sculpting and jewelry making that makes me prone to TADD. When an idea pops in my head I can develop it - with pencil and paper or CAD - and because I have all sorts of tools from previous/other addictions - I can make the idea into a tangible object. The result may not be elegant or refined - that can come later, if at all. It's the Proof Of Concept that's the fun part - sometimes refined and, occassionally, maintains an interest level sufficient to yield a piece that goes in my Turnings Cabinet.

Perhaps making variations of a shape or form over and over again might work similar to muscle memory development. With each subsequent piece, the shortcoming(s) of the previous piece are noticed, the source of the problem identified and corrected in the making of the next version. Maybe at some point nice refined, elegant. interesting pieces are turned - effortlessly - without much preplanning or designing.

Even so - there must be some "I'd like to try and make . . ." nagging in the background. Maybe not.

If you have found your form or shape and have perfected techniques to execute them to your satisfaction - what is it that keeps you making more rather than heading off to explore some other area of turning?