Repetition Leads to Proficiency OR Boredom?
charlie belden
>It seems the really good woodturners do basically three or four kinds of pieces, over and over again - of course with variations either in the wood or in subtle changes to the shape, perhaps even adding enhancements - inlaid rims, pedestal base, carved foot, pyrogpraphy,etc..
While it's true that repetition - even with some variations - leads to proficiency - and probably refinement of a shape or technique - for me at least, it gets BORING. There are SO many types of turning, so many shapes/forms, so many tools and techniques to play with (emphasis on play).
About three years into this turning journey I've gotten fair to pretty good with a curved edge skew and a poor man's bedan (a quarter inch bench chisel). I like doing lidded boxes with finials so I've done a couple dozen or three of them - but that's about the only area I've sort of really gotten into. Most of the other areas have been maybe three OF and then boredom sets in - Been There, Done That, Got The T-Shirt. Then, thanks to the internet, I see something else to try and the patterns is repeated - do two or three - get the basics down - and move on. I supect I have TADD - Turner's Attention Deficit Disorder - Hey Look! An Escoulen Chuck! What about Thread Chasing?! TWISTS!
There's always something new to try so it's difficult - at least for me - to be disciplined enough to take one idea or technique and work with it to the point where there's no way to improve it - to take it to the point of being Just So - and then keep turning pieces like that - to that level of refinement.
I admire Cindy Drozda's dedication to her work and can see that discipline and repetition, along with a great sense of proportions, can take something like a finial to a whole new level. Her pieces are exquisite - as close to perfection as possible - in every detail - refined to the Nth degree and finished beautifully. She takes each piece as far as a mere mortal can take it - crisp where it should be crisp, smooth and flowing where it should be smooth and flowing - and everything working together so perfectly - synergy - the whole greater than the sum of its parts.
While I can appreciate such works and admire the skill and discipline required - I can't envision myself ever doing 30, 50 or 100 of basically the same thing using the same technques and procedures - over and over and over again.
Perhaps after 10 or 15 years of running down almost every path I see that looks interesting, I may find one I fall in love with and settle down, next to an ocean - the Siddhartha Syndrome.
But for now, there's Adding Actual Movement, Internal Lighting and Jewelry using mainly turned elements - of wood.
If you've found your "turning love" - do you at times think there might be another out there somewhere? Are you tempted to look?
If you haven't found your "turning love" how will you know when you do?
Just wondering - out loud.



