>Ok, I am turning knitting needles and have completed several set but I am having problems with getting same diameter along the length. Any suggestions? I have the same problem when turning larger diameter spindles also.
>Is the problem a wavy or bumpy surface down the spindle? If so, have you tried angling the skew a little more? As the angle of the edge to the axis gets smaller (the edge more towards horizontal), the cut is sacrificed a bit for fewer bumps down the spindle due to the wider bevel contact. Angling the other way results in a better cut (up to a point) but the shorter bevel contact can ride up and down "waves". For thin spindles I also find it useful to support the skew at the tip with the thumb of my left hand while the fingers ride lightly around the wood. I tend to press the skew tightly into the toolrest a bit as I make the cut which seems to minimize ripples and bumps.
Another way it to take the high spots out with a 2" wide piece of cloth-backed sandpaper wrapped around the spindle!
If the problem is not a bumpy surface down the spindle but just one of getting the proper diameter all the way down, it might help to make a series of depth cuts with a parting tool and calipers, then cut away the wood between. I do this when making rolling pins and things I want a constant diameter without any taper. If I wanted to make a bunch the same diameter, I might make a little gauge.
>What causes ripples? I can turn a 4-6"(2"od) pc down starting from head stock toward tail stock, and I get sorta ripples close to the tail stock.I'm using a skew.
Is my live center bearings bad,bad technique,or head stock bearing wearing out? My Jet 10" is about 2yrs old. I just noticed when drilling a hole with drill chuck in the tail stock,the pc in the head stock, drill bit wants to wobble?? ALWAYS SOMETHING! pw
>Paul It usually the tool and technique. It's all about taking small bites with a very sharp tool, putting as little pressure on the bevel as possible, supporting the backside with your fingers, and keeping the pressure off the tailstock. It takes practice. If you have continual trouble with the skew try a tool that takes a smaller bite. sometimes I find a narrow spingle gouge will eliminate the chatter when I have trouble with the skew. On small spindles my 3/8" skew works better than my big skew.
>Tks john Lucas,I was putting a lot of pressure on the skew. Rubbing the dickens out of the bevel! I was trying to take a good size cut too. I will change my techinque. pw
>My experience is the same as John's. We tend to put to much preasure on the bevel trying to control the tool and waves are the result. As we repeat the cut, the bevel follows the previous wave making it bigger. Instead of rubbing the bevel, what we should be doing is floating the bevel lightly over the surface.
>Is waves rubbing the heel of the skew? How much is turning speed to slow and or moving tool transverse too fast?
All three?
I get into trouble with not using a longer tool rest with the skew as I think I move my hands out of position as I near the end of the short tool rest. Seems like I need longer rest if I want to keep continueing the cut and not trying to retart by moving tool rest for better results. Is that a fair thing to think?
>What wood are you using? A wood with too course of grain will not make it any easier. I doubt if you are using open pore stock for knitting needles, but will make a difference with spindle work. John Lucas has the best tip, I think that I want to turn the wood like I am turning any egg. Well not turning the wood into that shape, but handle the skew, wood, and tool like you will break the shell of an egg. Once you start getting the chatter, it is like a washboard gravel road. You can make it a lot worse, fast. You might have to sand off the chatter and then go at it again. I went after knitting needles with a different design. I have a Veritas dowel maker, and set it up for metric. I make cherry dowel stock, then turn finiales from a contrasting wood.
>I recently had a turner visit my shop with a very similar problem. He makes Indian flutes and turns the outside with a small roughing gouge. He planes with it the same way you would with a skew. He kept getting small uneven lumps on the surface. I got him to tuck the handle against his side and move his body when planing. His problem went away.
Jim Putnam------WebKitFormBoundaryEv8WhBpAeL+YZivJ
Jim Putnam------WebKitFormBoundaryEv8WhBpAeL+YZivJ
Guest
Re: turning spindles with out waves?
Jim Putnam------WebKitFormBoundaryEv8WhBpAeL+YZivJ
>I struggled with the same issue as I turned rolling pins. I'd aligned the tool rest, dressed the tool rest and skew, but still wasn't happy with the small variations in diameter along the length. So, I moved the tool rest and banjo out of the way, got out my 8" long sanding block and straightened things right up. I know, I know, sometimes, though, you just need to 'git er done'.
>Jim My dad is not a good turner and he's using a Shopsmith with exacerbates the problem. He uses a belt sander with the lathe running to get the chatter out of table legs. Whatever works, it's all about the finished product and having fun getting there.
>What speed are you using? A spinning shaft has a critical speed, i.e. the natural frequency of the shaft in bending in terms of rotational velocity (rpm). When you exert a force on the shaft with your tool it has the same effect as introducing a mass, which will lower its natural frequency. Try reducing the speed and exerting less force from the tool. The other thing to watch for is to only apply the minimal amount of longitudinal force from your tailstock necessary to keep the shaft on center. If the shaft is bending, an axial force will cause an eccentric load which exacerbates the vibration, thus lowering its natural frequecy, or critical speed. Slow down, r e a l l y s l o o w w.
Jim Putnam------WebKitFormBoundaryEv8WhBpAeL+YZivJ
Jim Putnam------WebKitFormBoundaryEv8WhBpAeL+YZivJ
Guest
Re: turning spindles with out waves?
Jim Putnam------WebKitFormBoundaryEv8WhBpAeL+YZivJ
>That's my point John, whatever works is OK. The only rules are the safety rules, after that, experiment as needed. With a PM3520, I don't have any excuses - maybe I should stop using a micrometer on spindle work and switch to the TLAR method.