Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

hollowing tools

Posts

hollowing tools

#1

hollowing tools

Ponch

>I am a fairly new turner,and have turned bowles, stoppers ect. I would like to take on hollow vessels. What is the best system for hollowing vases ect. There are so many on the market, a bit confusing.

Re: hollowing tools

#2

Dick Hines

Re: hollowing tools

Dick Hines

>Now you opened a can of worms. I can't wait to see how many replays you get. Every hollow from turner on their sight has the best one. I know I do but I will wait to see what everyone else says.

Re: hollowing tools

#3

Re: hollowing tools

Greg Haugen

>Ponch,

Before this explodes, would you give us some more information. What size lathe do you have, what size or style (tall, squat, etc.) of hollow forms would you like to make, how much does price matter, and is the size of the opening critically important?

Thanks.

Greg H.

Re: hollowing tools

#4

Re: hollowing tools

Ponch

>Greg, I have a 3520 lathe I would like to hollow anything from a one inch hole to 4 or 5 inches. Thanks

Re: hollowing tools

#5

Jamieson's System *LINK*

Greg Haugen

>I'd recommend the Jamieson system. It's very versatile, a wide range of cutters and attachments, has the laser option to help with wall thicknesses, and since it's captured/restrained there's a lot less stress on you and more enjoyment. Plus, Lyle is a very nice guy to talk to and he's very helpful. Plus it's to have the carbide cutter options from Hunter tools. A superior finish from the cut and no grinding.

Just my 2 cents...

Greg H.


Lyle's Tool Site

Re: hollowing tools

#6

Re: hollowing tools

Paul Waddle

>Just getting into this myself. I've researched this some and like the following: Lyle Jamieson,Kobra,Little Monster,Mini "O" and more. Lye is very descriptive and is very helpful,not saying others are not. I believe John Jordan and Fred Holder probably have them all. John Lucas can advise as well.BEFORE jumping in and spending 4-500$,do what Clayton Forster showed us how to do:Make the outside of the hollow form,part it in half,dig out the inside like a bowl,glue it back together and disguise the glue joint. Its just plain old monotonus work diggin out the insides and NO one can see it!!! I personally think making finials is more rewarding. pw

Re: hollowing tools

#7

Steven Antonucci

Before you invest in a system

Steve Antonucci

>I highly recommend you work with handheld tooling. It doesn't take much to make the tools, and if you are considering holling through a small hole, you probably have the mechanical skills required to make a captive system yourself for very little money.

It's not rocket surgery.

Steve

Re: hollowing tools

#8

Steve, do you have pictures....

Greg Haugen

>Steve, do you have pictures of some "homemade" tools as examples for him.

Also on Jamieson's site he gives directions to build a captured system.

Greg H.

Re: hollowing tools

#9

Re: hollowing tools

Joe Flemig

>#1 - If at all possible, borrow some tools and try them before buying. #2 - There are hollowing sets for all sizes and shapes of vessels. To get the best advice, please let those advising what vessel size(s), and vessel shape(s) you want to turn. I have to admit to being a hollow tool junkie and I have a lot.

1" - 3" diameter: I use Packard mini hollowers and Kelton mini hollowers

3" - 5" diameter: I like Kelton small hollowers, and Jordan's 1/2" tools. There is the Stinger from Don Pencil too which is a pretty good system.

4" to 7" diameter: This is the toughest size range if you want a small opening. Most small tools are not long enough and longer tools are too fat. I use a combination of tools depending on the vessel. Don Derry hollowing system (captive). Jordan's smaller tools are good. I have a couple of homemade tools with 1/2" shafts I use here. Kelton medium are great too, but the opening needs to get a bit larger. I'm experimenting with a new tool from Mike Jackofsky that works really well too, but I'm still a new user. Its a cutting tool (see his website).

6" to 12" diameter: Don Derry hollowing system is my first pick. Jordan tools. Stewart tools. Bosch tools. Kelton medium and large. All of these have excellent asymmetric swan neck shapes for hollowing. Avoid the Sorby hollowers because they use a symmetric swan neck head that does not work so well going in and out of a vessel while hollowing. Look at the catalogs to compare shapes to see what I mean. Again, Mike Jackofsky tools are worth a look, but I'm still a new user. They are cutters, not scrapers.

10" and larger: Use a captive system. Jamieson is great. Homemade works too. I also use an Exocet system for really large vessels. It is a cutter instead of a scraper. Hard to find, though.

Joe Fleming - San Diego

Re: hollowing tools

#10

Re: hollowing tools

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>You are receiving lots of advice on various kinds of hollowing tools which I'm sure is somewhat confusing. My suggestion is that you do yourself a favor and find a competent teacher and take some lessons on turning HF's. The teacher will have tools for you to use and will also have suggestions for others. Getting the tool is only the beginning. Learning how to use it is the most importand part.

Wally

Re: hollowing tools

#11

Re:I would add to Wally's good advise....

Jamie D

>... that you learn hollowing in the beginning by using hand-held tools. Don't start out hollowing thru small openings until you have a good grasp of the process, and you can perfect the necessary techniques by practicing on mug shaped pieces using the tools, including the Ellsworth style wire calipers for measuring wall thickness. Start small and work your way up to taller pieces with smaller openings, and then if you are still enjoying the blind turning process considered a captured system, but using a laser is cheating!! (;-D)

Re: hollowing tools

#12

Re:I would add to Wally's good advise....

john lucas

>I think Jamie and Wally have given you good advice. I'm a fan of the John Jordan tools because they are so simple and do exactly what you need. They can also be easily adapted to the captured bar systems later if you so desire. Hollowing and carving is all John does so these tools have evolved over the years into what works best.

I think turning smaller vessels with large openings, whatever tools you use is the way to learn. Along with finding someone who does hollowing to help you out.

Re: hollowing tools

#13

Absolutely....

Greg Haugen

>It's always a good idea to turn with someone. You can learn a little from a book, a little more from a video to see the actual "motion" or to hear the "sound", but you can learn A LOT more from putting the tool to the wood with instruction.

I think I miss understood your post about the size. I took it as 1" hole up to a 4" or 5" hole as in you would have a much larger diameter, not the diameter being 4-5". Anything 6" in diameter or less, is definately easily done by hand. You'd also learn about the senses of turning by starting "handheld"; "the feel", the "sound", and the idea of "blind" hollowing. Jordan's tools and Keltons are excellent choices for small work. Trent Bosch also has 1/2" tools now. The only difference in them are the tips, and method of sharpening. The "Ellsworth" style of wire calipers that Jamie suggested are excellent and cheap. For the price of a standard caliper you can make a pile of the wire style. Practice with a "cup" form, very open is a excellent way to start. After your comfortable with that start to shrink the opening with each piece there after.

If you can test drive any of these tools you'll knwo what works for you. What may work for me, John, Wally, or anyone else is fine, but you may "test drive" something else and like that the best. If you have a local club, get with some turners and try their tools and ask which ones they prefer. Most people will have a few options but prefer one or two for different reason or different applications.

I'm not sure where you are, but if you're near SW Wisconsin, you're always welcome to come and play in my shop.

Greg H.

Re: hollowing tools

#14

Steven Antonucci

Sure-

Steve Antonucci

>What dumbfounds me is that most people don't "decompose" what a hollowing system is into the basic components. It's a bar with the capability of reaching into a hole to a certain distance and holding a cutting bit.

A captive system is the same thing, with the handheld component removed. I could easily adapt these tools to be captive by making a toolrest that limited vertical motion. A simple way would be to do it from plywood and have it adjustable with some wing nuts. The round handle could be replaced by a 2x4 to sit on a back platform out of wood scraps. If you are cutting correctly, the materials don't need to be that strong (hence, cutting by hand first to understand what the components all do!)

Steve

P.S. Cost is probably under $20 and you get to use up shop scraps!


img

Re: hollowing tools

#15

Lyle Jamieson

Re: hollowing tools

Lyle Jamieson

>It is very confusing and complicated. As others have mentioned and I will repeat. USE IT FIRST. Someone in your club has one of my tools and one of most other brands on the market today. Borrow it if it fits on your lathe or go to another club members shop and use it on their lathe...but use it before you buy. Dont be afraid to ask for the above help, you will be suprised how many will contribute to your learning curve. I also second the motion about getting some hands-on instruction. That always will get you a step ahead of the self taught bunch. But get the help from someone that has the tools you want. The methods and process is even more confusing than which tool to use. There are many good ways to do hollow forms. Call me if I can be of any help to you as you go throught this maze. Lyle Jamieson

Re: hollowing tools

#16

Re: hollowing tools

robo hippy

>Since it is a new area of turning for you to get into, of course, it another good excuse for a whole new set of tools to get. The size of what you will be doing is another part of it. There seems to be 3 kinds of cutting implements for you to choose from. One is straight bars with different cutters fixed on the ends, like the ones Steve showed. Another is different bits that are in a tip that you can swivel so you can get into all the different areas like under cut shoulders, and some of these are on angled bars that can be extended or retracted. The other seems to be the swan necked tools, which have different bends to get around the inside. The most versatile for me, are the goose necked tools. I prefer them to be unhandled so I can switch them in a captured system, or in an articulated system like the Monster. I prefer the Kelton for roughing, and the carbide discs for clean up work. A captured system for bigger pieces, and the Monster for the smaller pieces. I think a good demo for any club would be to have a hands on presentation where the turners bring in all their end grain cutting tools for try outs.

robo hippy

Re: hollowing tools

#17

Brad Vietje

Ponch: where are you located?

Brad Vietje

>Hey Ponch,

Some people who are used to being anonymous on-line might be uncomfortable with this question, but this is sort of a big, extended family of nice people here.

You have already gotten lots of good advice and tool ideas, so I won't go there. Tell us where you are, and chances are one of us is near enough to be helpful, or can connect you with someone who is. There are turning clubs all over, and they are a great resource, especially to help new turners get started, or experienced turners learn something new. AAW-affiliates are listed at the AAW web site: www.woodturner.org.

You can also learn a ton-and-a-half by attending a turning symposium, and they are available in all sizes from small, local affairs, through regional meetings, all the way to the big national and international conferences.

If you are near New England or New York, there's the Totally Turning conference just north of Albany, in Saratoga this March; and the New England Wood Turning Symposium in southern NH in May. You'll find most turners who do what you want to learn are delighted to have you over to their shop to try a new tool or new technique. You're welcome to come turn hollow forms with me in northern VT -- just wait 'till April or so, or come with very warm boots and coat and an iron constitution, as I don't have a heated shop, and I live almost 1/2 way to the north pole!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: hollowing tools

#18

Dick Hines

Re: hollowing tools

Dick Hines

>Now that's a class guy. It's now by MY hollowing rig. It's test different hollowing rigs to see what you like and what suits you best.

Lyle is a class act.

Re: hollowing tools

#19

Re: hollowing tools

D. Hansen

>Ponch try making your own tools first. Easy to do, fun and the price is right. Darryl

Re: hollowing tools

#20

Re: Make your own

GalenV in Iowa

>I think I learned a lot by making some of my own tools after seeing what some local turners had done. This double ended hollowing tool does work out nice as the square shank keep the cutter level when you cannot see inside. The insert shows the other end of the same tool.

This is a 3/8 bar and I have a 1/2" inch as well. The 3/8" bar has a 3/16" diameter HHS drill bit ground and the 1/2" is a 3/16" square HHS cutter ground.

The tool holder fits the VariGrind to sharpen either cutter.

Try making you'll like it!

Galen


img

Re: hollowing tools

#21

Re:I would add to Wally's good advise....

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>Expanding on what Jamie stated, I started hollowing by turning bowls. After learning how to turn bowls, I started turning them with a wide rim. Then I started under-cutting the rim. Then I started turning potpourri bowls. I eventually progressed to turning hollow forms with 3" openings, then 2", then 3/4" and smaller to 3/8". All the hollowing was done hand-held.

Once I felt comfortable with hollowing hand-held, I took the plunge and bought a hollowing system.

I really think my progressing through the steps I did helps me appreciate the hollowing system and allows me to be able to "listen" to the sounds of the wood as I hollow. I have not yet added a laser as I have more to learn with my other senses first...maybe next year.

keithz

Re: hollowing tools

#22

Re:Practicing with your eyes closed helps!

Jamie D

>

Re: hollowing tools

#23

Re: hollowing tools *LINK*

charlie belden

>Late to this one but you but here goes.

When you go from hollowing out the inside of a plate or bowl to inside a "hollow form", especially if you're working through a relatively small opening, things get a bit tricker for two reasons.

First, most of the cuts will be done where you can't see the cutter of the tool. That means you have to work just by feel rather feel and sight and you can easily turn through the side of the piece.

Second, IF you get a catch, the tool is trapped INSIDE the spinning wood. A catch on the outside of a piece is "interesting". A catch on the INSIDE of a piece can be VERY interesting, the larger the diameter of the piece the more VERY interesting the consequences of a catch will be. So the scale of hollow forms you have in mind should play a role in your tool selection. Little things like Christmas ornamanets and little bird houses can be done with simple tools, some you can make yourself say from an L-shape allen wrench.

There are a ton of "hollowing tools" out there, many "captured systems" that usually include a "laser option". The "laser option" will let you know WHERE the cutter is cutting even though you can't see it. Set the laser a fixed distance from the cutter and while you're turning you'll see it shining on the outside of the piece. When it "falls off" the piece you've turned to your preset wall thickness.

I put together a compendium of captured hollowing systems when I was looking to get one. You may find this info useful.

I have a JET mini lathe so some of the bigger systems wouldn't work on my lathe. I went with the MiniMonster because, for me, it had the best Bang for the Buck.

I've since loaned it to a turning club member to play with, in return for him writing up a review of the system. Since he has no vested interest in the tool (ie - he got to use it for a month without having to fork over any dough) and has given it a work out, my hope is his review will be more objective than any I, as the guy who paid for it, might write (no Owner Bias). I've asked him to evaluate the system with a very critical eye. As a former wooden boat builder I'm sure if there's a shortcoming or two - he'll find it.


Compendium of Hollowing Systems

Re: hollowing tools

#24

Lyle Jamieson

Re:I would add to Wally's good advise....

Lyle Jamieson

>Keith, you are one of many that learned that way...over many years of standing at the lathe, and many failed vessels. There is an easier way now. I dont know how to ride a horse but I can drive a car just fine. Im not going back to blind hand held tools. Lyle Jamieson