Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

It�s a disappointment when �

Posts

It�s a disappointment when �

#1

It�s a disappointment when �

Rich Pearson in Mill Creek, WA

>A bowl �turns� on you! I made this segmented bowl (I�m a beginner .. it�s my 9th turned piece ) using standard procedures. About three weeks after completion, the base cracked. As you can see in the PICs, there are two radial cracks, joined by a crescent crack around the plug in the center. The cracks are thinner than a credit card.

The dry fit looked perfect .. no light was visible between any joints. I glued up the base in halves and flattened the diameters before gluing the two halves together. I bored a hole for the plug, turned the plug to fit and glued it in. I use Titebond II glue ( using the last of a gallon jug which was about 2 years old). My shop temperature is never below 58 degrees and is warmer when I am gluing and turning. I used Tried and True oil to finish the bowl.

My other bowls, made using the same materials, glue and techniques have held together just fine. The woods used have been in my dehumidified basement shop for over 6 months.

Any thoughts as to what�s going on??

I have trashed the glue and will part off the base and glue up another one but I�d like to avoid this problem!

Any input/experience you can share will be greatly appreciated.

Thanks


img

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

#4

Re: Bowl PIC3

Michael Stafford

>Rich, I am not a segmented expert but from the picture it appears your choice of grain direction caused the joints to fail.

It looks as if the segments in the bottom were cut across the grain instead of with the grain. This resulted in the the grain expanding along its width and tearing the glue joints apart.

Perhaps some of the segmented experts can help us....

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

#5

Re: Bowl PIC3

Mfoster

>I guess I have to take exception with Mike. The grain is oriented to run around the circle, which means wood fibers/length of fibers, should be stable and change minimally with changes in ambient humidity. However, these are some fairly large/wide segments and a couple of questions come to mind. Was the wood dry and acclimated to the shop humidity? If not, as the wood dries it could exhibit open joints as shown. The wider end of the segments move more (even if minimal) and is compounded by the math as the segment gets wider. So the wider part of the segments wants to move a lot more than the narrow, and does. The joint stays closed on the wider end, as the whole bowl is moving at the same rate, but it opens up on the narrower part of the segments because they are not moving as much here and the joint (weakest glue joint in wood) loses over the pressure from the wood and the joint opens up. This is my best guess as to what happened here.

The other possibility is that the joints weren't perfect when cut and clamped. If excessive force was used to clamp the ring, conceivably you could compress the larger radius to get the joints glued, but when the wood moved with changes in humidity, the joints popped open. I don't really think this is it, as enough of a crack shows in the pic that the open joint would have been evident during trial clamping.

Hope that wasn't clear as mud, but it is my best guess. Wood movement is something that has to be in the forefront of any segmenter's thinking during construction. I find it one of the real challenges in constructing a segmented piece.

I can sympathize with you, Rich, but all is not lost. I have remade baseds on segmented forms for much the same problems. It requires some thinking on how to hold the form by the rim and turn off the defective portion, then add a new base. It can be done as I've done it more than once.

Good luck

Mike

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

#6

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

john lucas

>Rich I used to make a lot of vessels similar in shape to what you are doing and had the same problem on some of them. The one pictured below was the same problem. I kept it after I repaired it to see how long the joints last. It is about 12 years old. It's about 14 to 16" tall and the inside base that cracked is 4" . What happened was it was in a show and they put it in a glass cabinet that had a light. It dried out much more than my house and the wood moved and broke the bottom just like yours.

The problem is wood movement. When you do pie shaped pieces on a flat bottom the wood will try to expand and contract making the overall circle larger and smaller. If you glue it into the bottom of a bowl it will eventually give way somewhere. Glue will not hold it. This isn't as big a problem on smaller pieces but when the bowls reach 6 to 8" things start to happen. It also depends on the species as well. Some wood simply moves more than others.

What I do now is to make the segments out of homemade plywood. I glue 5 or more layers together using cross grain glue ups. you can leave this solid or you can make a board and cut it into pie segments. These function just like plywood and don't expand or contract.

The other method I use is to leave the bottom floating. Turn a sort of outer tenon on the bottom or simply make the bottom kind of thin. Then turn a rabbit into the sides and insert the bottom. Turn a ring to cover the bottom gap and glue this in leaving the bottom without glue.


img

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

#7

Dick Hines

Re: Bowl PIC3

Dick Hines

>What has happed to Rich is the exact reson I don,t do segmented pieces. I think they look great, and there is a lot of talent and time put in to them but I would have a fit if I spent that much time and then have it split.

I will sick with wet wood. I have most of it figured out and don't lose many pieces as they are drying.

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

keith tompkins

>Hi Rich, I suspect that even though your shop was dehumidified, the moisture content in the place where they were kept after completion was much dryer. If they are kept in a heated area, such as your home, they can dry out rapidly, with the results you see. The wood in the base had tangential shrinkage, pulling the glue joints apart. This is not a glue joint failure, simply wood movement. Any glue would have failed here.

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

#9

Re: Bowl PIC3

john lucas

>turning segmented wood is just like turning green wood. You simply have to learn how the wood movements affect the final product and adapt what you do. When I first started turning I didn't have a chainsaw or access to thick wood. I did have lots of thin wood a decent table saw. The results were segmented pieces.

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

#10

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

>Hi Rich, I would suspect the glue, you said it 2 years old. I was having glue faliures at random times and found that the problem was the glue getting old. I now buy only what I can use in 6 monhts. I also went back to origanil Tite Bond I feel that it gives more consistant results. Drop me an email, I live just over by Paine Field.

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

keith tompkins

>John is right on here....my most stable bases were cross-laminated shop-made plywood from veneers. I will be demonstrating my floating bases in Mesa; they work well too; especially if incorporated in a laminated base.

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

#12

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

Barry Elder

>Rich, this reminds me of the guy who got his driver's license at the ripe old age of 16 and then went out and bought a prototype Formula 1 car to learn to drive. It would behoove you to visit your local library to learn a bit about wood and wood behavior as it dries, as the prior advice from those who know has indicated, that wood's natural movement will defeat any glue. I have turned many pieces of wood cut from the same log and one will be stable and the piece next to it will warp, crack, and split no matter how it is treated. Such is life!

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

#13

Join the AAW

john lucas

>Hook up with the new segmented turning group. Unfortunately segmented turning is harder to understand than just learning about wood movement. When I had the problem with the chalice bottom I asked all sorts of knowledgeable people about what to do and didn't get any firm answers.

Polychromatic or segmented turning puts wood in so many different configurations that it's hard to understand what happens to the pieces as each piece moves. Ideally the grain should run in the same direction in all the pieces and Malcolm Tibbets stresses this in his book ( which is a must have in my opinion).

I found that reading all you can about how people assemble work and most importantly, talking with other segmented turners is the best approach.

You can use the best glue out there and it will still fall apart years later, if you don't assemble it correctly.

Here's how to fix what you have. Remount the bowl with the bottom out. I would use a jam chuck that fits in the lip and then put lots of masking tape around it to hold it in place.

Then ideally turn out the bottom and turn a new bottom and replace it. If you assembled it in such a way that you can't completely turn out the bottom,step in about3/4" and turn a hole with a step or rabbit. Then turn a new bottom out of laminated wood and insert it into this hole. That last one is what I did to fix the challice.

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

#14

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

Barry Irby

>Good Advice above.

I don't do many segmented turnings, but this made me wonder. I have built decks and installed wet 2X6's for railings. The corners were mitered. The joints always opened up on the inside corners. Draw a mitered corner and look at it closely. What would happen if the wood shrank in its width, but not in the length? The long tips can not move inward, because they remain touching each other. So, the short sides moves toward the long side. Since the short side stays the same length, the joint opens at the inside corner.

This is what happened to your bowl. The wood shrank in width but not in length. It pulled away from the center plug and some of the joints failed.

Wonder if it would work better if the bottom were more of a dome? As the wood shrank in width the dome would flatten and the circumference of the joint might change with the stress. Hmmm?

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

#15

Brad Vietje

Strategy ?

Brad Vietje

>Keith (& all the other segmented turners out there),

I'm no segmented turner, but I am curious. Is the best strategy to rough cut all the segments, then air dry them in a heated shop for a few more days before carefully sizing them and gluing up the different layers? Should each ring or half-ring be allowed to dry and move before being glued up to make the larger piece?

I'm sure end grain vs side grain and cross-grain movement enters into this, too. Can you suggest some ways Rich can avoid this outcome on the next one?

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

#16

Re: Strategy ?

Michael Stafford

>The strategy is to design your segmented project with wood movement taken into consideration. I have done a few segmented pieces following the advice of experienced segmented turners and to date I have not had any joint failures.

The piece Rich has pictured was almost certainly doomed to failure because he used wood that was going to contract and expand across the width of the bottom of the bowl and was joined end grain to end grain along the joints. Wood contracts and expands a lot across the grain and very little along the grain. Gluing wood end grain to end grain is one of the poorest methods of construction for strength in that area. That is why the overlap of side grain, running bond-type construction is required for the body of bowls to have sufficient strength. If left entirely to end grain glue joints the bowl has little or no strength.

Rich, I would strongly recommend reading Malcolm Tibbett's book "The Art of Segmented Wood Turning: A Step-by-Step Guide". In it he goes to great lengths to explain wood movement and the strategies that the segmented turner should use to account for that movement. And I don't think there are many segmented turners who equal his success either in design or complexity of construction.

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

#17

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

john lucas

>Barry It works extremely well as a dome. I learned this fact from another turner many years ago. He showed me that if you turn a green goblet and make the wood flat across the base it will most likely crack unless it is dried very carefully. If you leave the bottom cone shaped the wood will still move but the large ring contracts and moves in. The cone gets longer instead of breaking because the wood is allowed to move. Thin wood is also more likely to move instead of crack so if you make it cone or dome shaped and thin you greatly increase your success rate.

consequently I played with this in my early segmented turning and had less failures. Wood moves differently in 3 different planes, and to complicate matters further different species move at different rates. then you add to this glue joints that are short grain vs long grain and you can quickly see why it can be difficult to make segmented work that lasts.

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

#18

Keith Tompkins

Re: Strategy ?

keith tompkins

>Hey Brad, one way would be to use a piece of 1/8" plywood that has segments glued to either side. It would still have the same appearance, but would be more stable after being turned to proper thickness. Nobody would guess there is a plywood core.

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

#19

Ditto what Mike and Keith have said.

john lucas

>BAck when I couldn't cut segments accurately I did glue up half rings and then flatten them and join them together. Now I just try to be more careful and cut them accurately enough that I glue them up in one setting.

If there is a big differential between your shop and your house I would consider letting the glued up vessel sit in the house for few days to lose a little moisture. I don't think letting just the segments sit would work because your adding moisture to the wood when you glue them up.

One thing Malcolm suggests is to wait as long as possible between gluing and turning and then possible let it set for a few more days before final sanding. He goes into detail why in his book but basically it's to let the pieces dry completely after gluing so you don't get little bumps in the joints after a few months of drying.

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

#20

Grain Direction

Ed in Leaside

>Don't ask me I'm not a segmenter, but just for fun I shrunk some pixels in Illustrator. ;)

It looks like ...the grain direction will have a major impact on "how" your glue-up reacts to moisture changes. The segments in the 2 pics on the left have been shrunk to 90% across the grain. The long and short grain glue-ups can not change in diameter so something will have to give. The 3rd pic, with the grain at 45* to the axis, I shrunk to 80%. There's a very small gap at the outer edge which should disappear if the angle was changed to ... maybe 40*.


img

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

#21

Thank You All!

Rich Pearson in Mill Creek, WA

>Your experience, suggestions and willingness to help is outstanding. I will do a lot of reading and re-reading before I salvage this bowl.

Your help is greatly appreciated.

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

#22

Re: Thank You All!

Brian Simmons, Heflin, AL

>I have made several 12-segment segmented pieces like the 16-segment piece you have here in diameters to 24" but I have never had the problem. I have used air dried wood with shop RH varying 40%-60% and had the in the house with RH as low as 15% and as high as probably 70%. What comes to mind for me is the grain direction is correct but the plug in the center probably caused the break. It looks to large for the glue joints to overcome the stress of this piece of wood expanding perpendicular to the grain direction. Had the plywood plug been used as suggested or a much smaller plug I think success might have been had.

I don't know if it matters but when cutting the segments I always used pieces from the same edge of the board. I would cut my angles flipping the board over but I would end up with enough pieces for 2 bottoms and always use the pieces that shared a common edge. I also kept the pieces in sequence.

I will also point out that it is entirely possible that I have been lucky and I prefer being lucky to good any day of the week.

Re: It�s a disappointment when �

#23

Very interesting idea

Rich Pearson in Mill Creek, WA

>I will explore this avenue as well.

Thank you!!