Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Gouge Grind Angle

Posts

Gouge Grind Angle

#1

Gouge Grind Angle

Charlie Drake

>In my never ending effort to show my ignorance, I would like to ask a question about gouge grind angle. I recently attended a Stuart Batty demo and he was an advocate of a 40 degree angle on all cutting tools. This compares to a 50-60 degree angle recommendation on most bowl gouges. Before I regrind one of my Thompson gouges, can some of you experts tell me the pros and cons of this 40 degree angle? Thanks a lot!!!

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

#2

Re: Gouge Grind Angle *LINK*

Gordon Seto

>The 40 degree grind does cut through wood with less effort than the blunt angle.

A blunt angle helps to maintain bevel support on the interior of deeper bowls as explained by Dale Nish in the link below.


Dale Nish explanation on angle

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

#3

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

John K Jordan

>Charlie,

Angles: 40-50, what's the difference. When I started spinning wood I read expert advice and followed it, then read different expert advice and followed it, then...

I like the advice I heard last week, I think it was something Mark Mahoney said - the angle is what you make it. One is not inherently better than another, just different. You grind an angle and you get used to it. If you grind with a convex bevel or with a microbevel as Clewes often uses, how do you measure the angle anyway? Doug Thompson told me one reason he only rough-grinds his tools is he expects people will reshape and sharpen them to suit themselves. Thompson provides a lot of steel on his gouges so you should have plenty of room to experiment.

I ground some of my bowl gouges at two different angles, but I didn't measure them. One is sharper with swept-back wings. The other is much steeper with the wings ground more "conventionally". It is better for following the curve through to the bottom. That said, I like to keep several gouges ground identically so I can pick up a sharp one and continue working - having the identical grind avoids taking a few seconds to get used to a slightly different handling.

However, I'm certainly no expert. I do read a lot and keep my ears open. If n certified experts recommend n different grinds, it only makes sense to me to consider the grind angle arbitrary.

BTW, I have great respect for Stuart Batty, but IMO he seems just a tad inflexible in his opinions of the "right" way to do things. I lean more towards the "there is no right way" philosophy.

JKJ

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

#4

Bill Blasic

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

Bill Blasic

>I have been very happy with the grind that comes with the Thompson gouges. What is more important than angles is making sure your wheel is round and your techniques are giving you the sharpest tool you can get.

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

#5

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

john lucas

>Charlie Ever since I saw Stewart turn a winged bowl with his gouge and made it look like it was sanded to 600 grit I have been practicing with it. During that time I have also been practicing with my other gouges sharpened differently.

Here's a stab at what I've learned. First, you don't really cut with the tip of the tool which is blunt, 50 to 65 degrees for most people. Normally you have the flute tilted up just a little which means your cutting with the "corners" as the tip merges into the wings. The wings are often ground at a thinner angle than the tip depending on the shape of the wings and the shape of the flute. This means you may be cutting with an angle less than your tip angle.

So far in my playing I've found that cutting direction and cutting speed has been the largest factor. First try reducing the speed that you push the tool through the turning. Relax you grip and don't push on the bevel so hard and then try to feel the cut. You want to let the tool cut the wood not force it through the wood. Turning up the speed of the lathe will often help with this.

I have found on some woods the 40 degree angle actually cuts worse and tears out wood. Changing the cutting direction by coming at it from 180 degrees or reversing the lathe may help just as well as going to a blunter tool.

The direction the wood crosses the edge is also a strong factor in how clean it cuts. If the wood crosses the edge at a severe angle it often cuts cleaner although sometimes it can pull fibers out. A blunt angle cuts faster but is more likely to tear out the wood. Think of using a skew with the wood hitting the edge at 90 degrees like it was a parting tool. It cuts very fast but leaves a rough edge. If you tilt the blade so the wood comes across it at an angle it will cut much smoother but much slower. Now every time you use your bowl gouge look at how the wood crosses the cutting area and play with flute angles and see if you can move the cut so it crosses the edge at a more acute angle. You may get the same cut as if you had the edge ground to 40 degrees. This is just like skewing a hand plane to an angle. This effectively lower the cutting angle and often gives cleaner cuts.

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

#6

Excellent points!!

John K Jordan

>

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

#7

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

Donna Banfield

>John, you are one of the few people that can explain something that involves math, but leave out the complicated stuff so a person like me - who is math-impaired - can understand what you're saying.

Thanks for not making my eyes glaze over and my head explode :^)

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

#8

I am math impaired :)

john lucas

>

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

#9

Brad Vietje

Can someone post a pic of this grind?

Brad Vietje

>

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

#10

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

Russ Fairfield

>Donna may understand what you are saying, but I don't have a clue what John and John are talking about.

Gentlemen, pictures and diagrams please.

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

#11

Re: Gouge Grind Angle *LINK*

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Johannes Michelsen does the same thing on a V shape flute (45 degrees), Stu Batty uses a U shape flute at 40 degrees. This is measured from the flute and the angle doesn't need to be perfect.

Below is a link to pictures from an old post about the Michelsen grind.


Michelsen grind

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

#12

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

Bob Macgregor

>If I understand what you are saying, this is just the difference between chopping and slicing. Analogously, if you want to cut a steak into strips (or a tomato, for that matter), it works a lot better to slice rather than just apply straight downward pressure (a sort of slow-motion chopping). The same is true for wood, except on the lathe most of the movement for the slicing action comes from the wood, not the cutting tool.

BOB

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

#13

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I agree that the best nose angle to use is the one that you're used to. Many of the turners who use a 40 or 45 deg nose angle have a gouge ground with 2 nose angles. A 40 deg angle with an additional short grind of perhaps 60 deg. for cutting across the bottom of a bowl.

It seems that very few turners know about a different way of using a gouge in the inside bottom of a bowl. Start the cut in the usual way down to about the transition point to start across the bottom. Instead of swinging tha handle across the bed toward you, reverse it's direction and push the handle away from you, dropping the handle into a rainbow shaped cut to the center of the bowl. It's a cut that works very well in deep bowls to avoid bringing the handle against the rim. (A very good way to break the bowl in the event of a catch)

Another good cut to know is for making the final smoothing cuts on the inside of the bowl. It works best with a gouge ground in a short fingernail grind. With the flute facing up and cutting on the left side of the nose, make a a very light sweeping cut all the way to the center of the bowl.

In the early days of the bowl gouge, almost everyone used it ground straight across like a roughing gouge. I can still remember the article in Fine Woodworking mag. asking why not use a fingernail grind on your bowl gouge. There was photo showing the grind. I immediately reground my gouge and found a world of difference.

Henry Taylor didn't start marketing the bowl gouge in the US until around 1980. It took a few years for the turners to discover it. All of a sudden bowl turning became much easier

Wally

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

#14

I'll try to do some photos this weekend of cutting

john lucas

>angles. I don't have all the radiused edges but do have several different grinds that will show some of what we are talking about for finishing cuts.

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

#15

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

robo hippy

>The 40 degree gouge is fine for shallower bowls which have little transition area from the sides to the bottom. For a deeper bowl with more of a transition, you can't make that cut with a 40 degree gouge without coming totally off the bevel. A secondary bevel, or rounding off the sharp edge on the bottom of your gouge helps, or you can use a steeper grind (with the edges swept back slightly) in the 70 degree range. The angle on Dougs gouges matches almost exactly the angle on my first Ellsworth gouges, and my Glaser V gouge.

robo hippy

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

#16

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>When I started turning and bought my first tools, I new nothing about the different grinds and how they worked, so all my gouges were ground to the same angles as they came from the factory and, I learned how to use them in that way.

Well, I have been turning for a few years now and have learned that the factory isn't always right. I have settled on 45 degrees for my traditional spindle gouge and roughing gouge and have reground a bowl gouge and detail gouge to a Michaelson grind, which uses a 45 degree angle. Right now, my 1/2" and 5/8" bowl gouges are still at the factory angle of approx. 60 degrees, but I'm thinking seriously of changing that.

keithz

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

#17

Dick Hines

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

Dick Hines

>Doug these kind of look like the bowl gouges you sent me. :)

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

#18

Gouge Grind Angle Pictures

Texian

>Try www.woodcentral.com/newforum/grinds.shtml.

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

#19

Skew

Philip Duffy

>John, I think you are teaching all of us some very valuable info with that posting. I wholeheartedly agree that most of the effort with a bowl gouge should be almost effortless. Find that sweet spot for your gouge and let it work! Philip

Re: Gouge Grind Angle

#20

Gouge angle

Philip Duffy

>John, I think you are teaching all of us some very valuable info with that posting. I wholeheartedly agree that most of the effort with a bowl gouge should be almost effortless. Find that sweet spot for your gouge and let it work! Philip