Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

flat bevel, convex or concave

Posts

flat bevel, convex or concave

#1

flat bevel, convex or concave

john lucas

>I was reading somewhere today and the author said that he started using flat bevels on his tools and found them much easier to use. We also have some turners now using convex grinds on certain tools.

What do you prefer? I tried flat bevels because they do give you more control on hand chisels. At least they did for me. They didn't seem to help on turning tools and took a lot more time to sharpen.

I've tried convex grinds on skews and found them harder to use. I have not tried convex on gouges yet but have ground very short bevels and it does seem to help on some cuts on the interior of bowls.

Anyone else have an opinion. I'm still open to experimentation when I get the time.

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

#2

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

Fog Tanner

>I have tried convex grinds on a couple of gouges and didn't really care for them. They were too hard to control and made switching from one type to another more difficult. One had a long bevel (around 30 degrees) and the other was 40 degrees. I have gradually reshaped a narrow bevel which I prefer more. Most of my gouges have one or more secondary bevels. This includes my shallow and deep fluted gouges. On the deep fluted gouges it helps get around the bottom a bit easier.

For skews I use a concave bevel off a 10" stone, so it is much less hollow ground than a 6" - but still not flat. I have taken to softening the edge of the bevel where it meets the flat stock - mainly to keep from marking the wood. For planing cuts, I do use it long point down and leading - much like a hand plane, and this type of grind works best for me.

We have one club member that uses a belt sander system for sharpening and swears by the flat grind. But he does not use secondary bevels, so I am not sure if it would help in that type of grind.

Fog

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

#3

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

Michael Stafford

>I use concave bevels on all my tools.

To me having a heel and a point makes it easier to control a gouge since I can make contact on the wood with the heel and rock into the cut and establish how much wood I am going to remove before I "glide" behind the cut on the bevel.

I used to use flat bevels on my skew chisels because I had a jig that I used to sharpen them on a 12" disc sander. I did not really use a skew very much during that time and when I did it was more than likely as a negative rake scraper. Now that I am actually starting to use the skew as it was intended (thanks to Ed Moore and Alan Lacer's videos) I like the concave bevel.

I would guess those people who advocate using the Worksharp sharpening system and similar systems could speak better regarding flat bevels.

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

#4

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

John K Jordan

>I like concave bevels on skews, partly because that makes them very easy to hone between sharpenings, and partly because I like the way they cut. In fact, after multiple honings, the convex grind starts to turn into a flat grind. The skew then gets harder for me to use so I go back to the Tormek. I think it was Clewes last week who advocated a concave grind on skews, but besides waving one around, I never saw him use it!

I use convex grinds on spindle gouges, often with the heel radiused, both for clearance and to allow easy honing.

I use both concave and "sort of convex" bevels for bowl gouges. For those ground with a steep bevel for continuous cuts from the rim to the center of the bottom, I both round off the heel and grind a microbevel on the edge - the result is more-or-less convex.

Also, I find flat bevels difficult to grind and hone. To hone properly requires honing the entire flat which takes forever. Honing just the edge gives you a little convex bevel right at the edge which I find difficult to control on skews. I haven't tried this with gouges.

JKJ

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

#5

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

john lucas

>John I laughed about that also. Mike Mahoney said prying cored bowls apart was the best use of the skew and Jimmy didn't use one at all. He used a specially ground parting tool to do the bottom of a goblet, I would use the toe of a skew for this.

Bob Rosand on the other hand used one a lot for all sorts of cuts including shaping large radius cuts similar to the way Terry Scott does his winged vessels. I didn't get to see Cindy turn so I don't know if she uses one.

I learned to use the skew ala, Nick Cook so I prefer a flat cutting tip and concave grind.

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

#6

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

Donna Banfield

>John, I have sort of a 'convex' bevel on my bowl gouges. I say sort of, because the only real bevel that I care about is the approximately 1/8" edge that does the cutting. The rest of the gouge is multi-faceted, because you round over the back. If you were to look at a side-grind or Ellsworth grind, you're simply removing the heel, and blending that all in.

This is the same grind that JoHannes Michelsen uses. A couple years ago, one of my turning clubs brought him in for a 2-day workshop. Day one was him demonstrating turning a full-sized range-rider hat. Day two was hands-on turning a mini-hat. I was first introduced to that grind during that workshop. I signed up for a 3-day workshop in his studio for a couple of months down the road. I didn't want to forget how to sharpen the tools between that time, so began using them on bowls as a way to keep it fresh.

I found that the grind was great for bowls, particularly the interior transition, when the side wall and bottom meet. In addition, I can turn very thin - translucent - just like the hats, on several shapes with that grind. I can roll the tool over on it's side, with the flute facing the wood surface that it is cutting, and not get a catch. I can do a shear cut with that grind as well on the interior, when I could never master that technique with a side grind, or swept back wing grind.

I still use jigs for spindle gouges, because the grind on all my spindle gouges resembles a detail gouge. For my skews, I have a concave bevel because I use an 8" bench grinder for sharpening.

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

#7

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

Mfoster

>I have used a convex grind on skews for a while but didn't like it and went back to a concave grind. Maybe it was because I was used to the concave grind and knew what to expect with it and I just didn't give it enough of a try. As they say, use what works for you.

David Elsworth describes a convex grind on spindle gouges and uses it for detail work. I intend to give this a try

Mike

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

#8

Brad Vietje

Oh Gosh, John, you're brave!

Brad Vietje

>Golly, John -- you GO, boy!

I have seldom seen a topic that gets turners as riled up and defensive than flat vs concave; Tormek vs dry grinding, etc... I waded into a couple of these battles on other forums, and I didn't enjoy the mud-slinging. Thank goodness this is a much more civil group!

I started with all concave, sharpened on my dad's old 6" grinder with a worn wheel (~5"). This results in a very aggressive tool, which is a hard way to learn. I then started sharpening on a 12" disk sander, and went to all flat bevels, even with the swept-back bowl grinds. This made an immediate improvement in tool handling, and made sharpening very fast and very repeatable. Once tools were shaped on a coarse disk, they were maintained on a 150 or 220 grit disk, which results in a very smooth bevel.

As I got more into honing tools, I went to an 8" grinder with a friable wheel. This allows honing maybe 20 - 30 times between trips to the grinder to renew the hollow on the bevel. If done with a light hand, you can grind away the widening flats and not screw up the sharp edge.

Currently, I use flat bevels on some tools, and hollow grinds on most.

There's a lot to discuss here. In theory, concave would be better for convex shapes (spindles and outside bowls), and convex would be better for concave shapes (inside bowls), and if you only had one of each tool, a flat bevel would be the best overall compromise. I could usually hone a flat bevel 6-8 times before touching up on the disk sander, which only took off a few sparks, and was incredibly quick.

I still think using hollow grinds on the inside of bowls is problematic, but like most, I do it all the time! I have only one convex bowl gouge, one flat-bevel 1/4" bowl gouge for finish cuts and small details, and the others are hollow ground on the 8" wheel. I haven't had the time to really study convex bevels in detail. One problem is that sharpening a convex shape that stays consistent in shape isn't easy. Hand-holding the tool on a worn fine grit belt sander without a platen (running away from the cutting edge!) can refresh this edge maybe 20 times (a lot like honing), and then it can be renewed with a little grinding on the flat disk (leaving the convex edge and heel) to help maintain the overall shape.

Once my house is complete, and I have a heated shop, I'll have to do some more research!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

#9

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

Russ Fairfield

>I see this a much adoo about nothing. Claims made about concave, convex, or flat bevels are no different from those made about the angles and profiles of the tool. We learn to use what bevel we can grind, and profiles we can duplicate, with whatever grinder or sander we have; and then we stand around arguing that what we use is the only way to do it.

They all cut wood, and when sharp and properly presented to the wood, they will all cut well. Which one we use is a personal preference or dictated by what we use to grind the tool. If we use a belt sander, the bevels are flat. If we use a wheel, the bevels are concave. If we use a 6" wheel, the concavity is pronounced. If we were to use a 10" wheel, it would be almost flat. We learn to use what we have.

We can make an argument the the convex bevel should cut better because it is a better fit to the inside curve of a bowl. A true convex bevel is a difficult thing to grind. Some of us get really fussy about and make the rounded bevel with and unsupported sanding belt. Some of us will make it in a series of little flat or concave steps. Most of us will just grind away the heal of the bevel to remove the hard edge because someone said that was the thing to do. Sometimes I think this helps. Most of the time I can't tell the difference, and I don't think the wood can either.

Anyway, that's my opinion.

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

#10

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

Michael Stafford

>Interesting that you mentioned grinding away the heel, Russ.

I have one tool that I do grind away the heel and that is a gouge I use for hollowing boxes. It seems that since I started doing that I am able to make a less pronounced "cone" in the center of the box as I hollow by sweeping from inside out. I don't know if this is because I have shortened the length of the bevel or what but it does seem to work. And as you said that is ultimately what matters.

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

#11

I grind the heel off all of my gouges.

john lucas

>

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

#12

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

robo hippy

>I have skews that are ground concave and convex. I find the convex one to be more user friendly for cutting gently flowing shapes and beads and coves. The concave one seems to work better for getting some thing totally straight/flat. For gouges, I round over the heel for the inside bowl cut. This makes a huge difference on getting a smooth cut with no ripples on the inside of a bowl, but not as much on the outside. It got rid of one sanding grit for me and it also eliminates bruising the wood.

robo hippy

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

#13

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>I use mostly flat or convex, but still use concave on my larger bowl gouges. I have mostly switched to the Sorby ProEdge, which is a belt sander. My skews and traditional spindle gouges are all flat ground. I grind/sand my version of the Michaelson grind on everything else except the two bowl gouges mentioned above. Those gouges haven't been changed yet because I haven't gotten up the guts to regrind them.

keithz

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

#14

I must have been drunk

John K Jordan

>But probably it was just too early in the morning for me to see straight! I got my convex and concaves all mixed up. I'll see if I can get it straight this time:

I like concave bevels on skews, partly because that makes them very easy to hone between sharpenings, and partly because I like the way they cut. In fact, after multiple honings, the concave grind starts to turn into a flat grind. The skew then gets harder for me to use so I go back to the Tormek. I think it was Clewes last week who advocated a convex grind on skews, but besides waving one around, I never saw him use it!

I use concave grinds on spindle gouges, often with the heel radiused, both for clearance and to allow easy honing.

I use both concave and "sort of convex" bevels for bowl gouges. For those ground with a steep bevel for continuous cuts from the rim to the center of the bottom, I both round off the heel and grind a microbevel on the edge - the result is more-or-less convex.

Also, I find flat bevels difficult to grind and hone. To hone properly requires honing the entire flat which takes forever. Honing just the edge gives you a little convex bevel right at the edge which I find difficult to control on skews. I haven't tried this with gouges.

JKJ

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

#15

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave *LINK*

Fred Holder

>Well Said Russ. A sharp tool is what cuts wood, no matter how it is shaped or ground.

I personally use the Tormek on most of my tools. A bowl gouge ground with the Ellsworth grind on a Tormek is an excellent tool in my opinion. I adopted the Ellsworth grind on bowl gouges several years ago after watching a bowl turning demonstration by David. At first, I used his jig on an 8 inch dry grinder. I commented in More Woodturning that I couldn't achieve that grind on my Tormek. Tormek sent me information on how to grind the Ellswroth Grind on the Tormek and I've used the Tormek for this grind since then. It is a grind that is hard to beat.


More Woodturning Website

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

#16

Tormek Elsworth grind

John K Jordan

>Fred,

Can you share that Elsworth grind info from Tormek? I fooled with the set up and got something real close on my Elseworth gouge but I'd love to see what Tormek recommends.

BTW, I also use the Tormek on most of my tools. It's horrible for creating a new shape but quick to regrind the same shape and the edge just can't be beat (IMHO)

JKJ

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

#17

Re: Tormek Elsworth grind *LINK*

Fred Holder

>I covered the method that Tormek supplied to me in a two page article in the July 2005 issue of More Woodturning. I've just placed those pages in a PDF file at my web site. The link below should take you there. If you have any further questions on this you can e-mail me.


Ellsworth Grind on Tormek

Re: flat bevel, convex or concave

#18

Re: Tormek Elsworth grind *LINK*

Fred Holder

>Sorry, the link didn't work without adding spaces. Hopefully this one will work.


http://www.morewoodturning.net/Ellsworth%20Grind%20on%20Tormek.pdf