Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

John Lucas - bending HSS rod

Posts

John Lucas - bending HSS rod

#1

John Lucas - bending HSS rod

John K Jordan

>John,

As per hour discussion following Drozda's demo, I heated a 1/4" HSS rod to cherry red with a Mapp gas torch and bent the end over nicely. (It certainly didn't act anything like mild steel.) I then grabbed the bent end in the vise and heated a bit further back to bend the other way to make the crook. The rod snapped in the middle of the first bend.

I don't know whether:

a) I put too much pressure on the rod before it was hot enough to bend properly,

b) if heating and cooling the first bend caused hardening which would require tempering (did you say the critical temperature should be much higher than cherry red?),

or c) whether several heating and cooling cycles did something to weaken the rod.

I will try again tomorrow. If it breaks again, I'll break out the oxy-acetylene torch and try a little more heat.

JKJ

Re: John Lucas - bending HSS rod

#2

Re: John Lucas - bending HSS rod

Ken

>See If I understand what you are trying.You are just trying to make a tool and getting bent to the desired shape,right? Don't cool it in beteen as you can cristalize the metal making it brittle.If so then get the bent to the exact shape you want(close as possible)then do your your heat treating thing,hardening or however you want to describe it. Hope I helped you out.

Re: John Lucas - bending HSS rod

#3

Re: John Lucas - bending HSS rod

Paul Waddle

>All high speed steel is not the same. Cherry red is good for bending and shaping carbon steel or low carbon steel,but hss needs higher temp generally. If you purchase a blank rod from a supplier,you can get what data you need. I suspect you had some air hardening steel-that would cause the break.

Cherry red is when carbon steel loses its magnetic properties,its at this temp that makes it plastic,unsure about hss. Incidentally,thats why you don't see champion turners groan when sharpening a hss tool it turns red,it can take it. pw

Re: John Lucas - bending HSS rod

#4

Steven Antonucci

answer is B

Steve Antonucci

>You'd have to reheat the bent section to avoid snapping it. If you look at the break, it probably looks a lot like a white metal fracture.

If I have to make multiple bends, I try to heat the whole thing over, even if I am not bending it. Once I have it to the right shape, I reheat it for the hardening.

Steve

P.S. If it's only 1/4", you can bend it in a metal vise by hand- no heat necessary!

Re: John Lucas - bending HSS rod

#5

Re: John Lucas - bending HSS rod

john lucas

>John I haven't had time to try and bend any HSS yet. It sounds like the metal might have hardened or you didn't heat the second bend enough or both. I didn't research that far into how to heat treat HSS since I knew I didn't have the tools to do it. I seem to remember that it had to be heated much hotter than cherry red.

Maybe I'll have time this weekend. I don't have any HSS rod so I'll have to look and see what else I have.

Re: John Lucas - bending HSS rod

#6

Re: answer is B

Dick Coers

>You can bend HSS cold? I think we need to know the alloy and it's hardness before making a general statement that you can bend HSS. Trying to bend hard steel has safety concerns. When steel snaps, shards can fly.

Re: John Lucas - bending HSS rod

#7

Steven Antonucci

The issue isn't whether it's HSS or not

Steve Antonucci

>It's whether or not it has been hardened. Once steel is hardened, that's when the snap/shard danger occurs. Until it is hardened, HSS should bend like any other steel.

Now if it came hardened, you need to anneal it first to be able to bend it. Once steel has been hardened, you can't bend it at all without it breaking (I've tried, and I get the same result every time...)

Steve

Re: John Lucas - bending HSS rod

#8

more info

John K Jordan

>Steve,

This rod is M2 HSS and is hardened. I was able to make a sharp bend (70 deg) after heating. I reheated and cooled several times to make a tighter bend, even pounding with a hammer on an anvil at one point. This indicated to me that simply heating and cooling in air did not affect the temper sufficiently. The rod snapped when trying to bend while the heat was concentrated in another spot an inch or so from the first bend. The second spot was bright cherry red at the time and the area of the first bend was a dull red.

I don't have a hardness tester, but by the "file test" the rod retained it's hardness even after be heated several times to bright cherry red and air cooled.

I understand working with carbon steel as concerns heating, annealing, and hardening. I have no experience with HSS and did not research before this experiment.

The discussion with JLucas concerned whether it was possible to heat a hardened HSS rod and bend it while retaining the hardness and without the need to anneal or reharden since the critical temperatures are much higher than that for carbon steels. Cindy Drozda showed me a tool with a specific shape that she found useful for small boxes and said she couldn't find another like it or find someone to make one. I traced the shape and thought it would be interesting to try.

I may give Doug Thompson a call for advice.

JKJ

Re: John Lucas - bending HSS rod

#9

Re: more info

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>I took a class with Cindy a few years back and like her finial boxes very much. But from what I know of her small boxes, I'm having trouble understanding why one would need much of a specialty tool for the inside of the box other than a simple curved or swan-neck tool. Can you describe what this special tool looks like?

Re: John Lucas - bending HSS rod

#10

Re: more info

John K Jordan

>It's a small swan neck, but with a tighter bend and a different alignment from any she could buy.

Re: John Lucas - bending HSS rod

#11

The key here is M2

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>You will not get it hot enough in the home shop. The hardening temp of M2 is in the neighborhood of 2200 degrees and normalizing is not recommended. If you are heating to cherry red that will only temper the steel to a Rockwell of about 55 which is hard enough not to bend and snap easily. As I recall heat treating M2 is a specialized process not normally done in the home shop. I would stick to drill rod for toolmaking in the home shop.

Ray

Re: John Lucas - bending HSS rod

#12

Re: John Lucas - bending HSS rod

john lucas

>John How about using drill rod or cold roll for the shank and HSS brazed or silver soldered to the tip. I can probably do that. I think I have some 3/16 or 1/4" hss in short lengths.

Re: John Lucas - bending HSS rod

#13

Re: John Lucas - bending HSS rod

Paul lWaddle

>John, I think you found the answer-M2 is not really manageable for home bending. Also,drill rod is great for your purpose and thats how I would go BUT that portion you silver solder will not be hard-don't think it needs to be. If so,find someone who has a tig and can weld a tool bit(here might be another problem) to the drill rod. Perish the very thought of buying a new tool! ha ha. pw.

Re: John Lucas - bending HSS rod

#14

silver solder

John K Jordan

>That's a great idea. Brazing can be as strong or stronger than welding and even a mild steel shaft should be strong enough for what Cindy is doing. I may try that myself but I'll be yours would be better. I you feel like making one to her specs I can post the tracing I made.

As for heating the M2, based on my initial bending success I suspect it might work fine if I avoided reheating and cooling - heat a larger area to a higher temp with the oxy-acet torch and quickly bend the crook in a pin fixture before it cooled.

JKJ

Re: John Lucas - bending HSS rod

#15

Tell us about the tool

James McClure

>John, can you please tell us more about this tool that Cindy Drozda has that you are trying to replicate. Inquiring minds want to know...

Re: John Lucas - bending HSS rod

#16

Re: Tell us about the tool

john lucas

>James It's just a minature ornament hollowing tool that has a double bend near the tip instead of a single 45 degree bend like most of them. Basically you bend the end of a straight piece to about 45 degrees. Then you bend the shaft below this bend so that the cutter is inline with the main shaft. Mine all have larger bends than hers because my ornaments are larger.

Re: John Lucas - bending HSS rod

#17

Very interesting!

James McClure

>

Re: John Lucas - bending HSS rod

#18

Re: Tell us about the tool

John K Jordan

>I'll try to take a photo of my tracing tomorrow.

Re: John Lucas - bending HSS rod

#19

tracing of Drozda tool

John K Jordan

>Here's the tracing and sketch I made of Cindy Drozda's tool. She pointed out the tip was to the right of the centerline instead of on center.

JKJ


img

Re: John Lucas - bending HSS rod

#20

Re: tracing of Drozda tool

paul waddle

>Hi John,might as well silver solder a pc of carbide on the cutting tip if going to all that effort. I think I would go with a minimum 5/16 shaft,seems a 1/4" anything is too flexible. pw

Re: John Lucas - bending HSS rod

#21

Re: tracing of Drozda tool

John K Jordan

>No, she said the shaft was OK.

Re: John Lucas - bending HSS rod

#22

Hey, I've got something like that!

Steven Kubien

>Courtesy of Secret-Santa-Steve-Antonucci. Hey Steve, did you teach Cindy how to make finials too? :)

Steve