Sanding problem
Bob Henry
>Was sanding a walnut spindle and I could not get the sanding lines out. I sanded at about 1800 rpm and from 120 to 600 grit. Thanks for any help in this problem.
Bob
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Sanding problem
Bob Henry
>Was sanding a walnut spindle and I could not get the sanding lines out. I sanded at about 1800 rpm and from 120 to 600 grit. Thanks for any help in this problem.
Bob
Re: Sanding problem
Richard Allen
>Sand with the grain to 180.
I find walnut to "hold" sanding scratches of grits below 150. So I now start sanding walnut with 220 paper. I will often go through several sheets of 220 sandpaper (or discs) to remove tool marks. This avoids using coarser grits which I have had a problem with on walnut in the past.
Re: Sanding problem
john lucas
>Did you sand with the grain. I always stop the lathe and sand with the grain on spindles. It's very difficult to get all the lines out if you don't.
The trick to keeping the lines out in the first place is to keep the sandpaper moving. 150 grit sandpaper isn't 150 grit. It's something like 140 to 160 depending on the quality of the paper. If yo hold the paper still or move is slowly the larger grits make lines. If you move if fast it sort of makes close together lines that are easier to sand out with the next grit.
Re: Sanding problem
Dick Hines
>I agree with John. I would also slow the speed to less than 500RPM.
Re: Sanding problem *LINK*
John K Jordan
>Bob,
Are the scratches in the side grain or in the end grain of coves and such?
I find walnut is one of the worst for showing scratches, especially on end grain. I believe one problem with end grain is sub-surface deformation. Besides the problem of fibers pulled out on end grain by the tools, a large grit particle will not only plow a grove (a scratch) but press down and deform and even pull out some fibers under the deepest part of the grove. Even if you remove the visible scratches that deformation underneath may show up after finer grits. As mentioned, this is worse on end grain and walnut give me more trouble than anything. (BTW, I used to run a small metallography lab and when sanding and polishing metals for etching and microscopy, subsurface deformation was a serious problem.
With spindles, I do sand with the lathe turning, but slowly, rotating the lathe first in one direction then the other, and often sanding with oil. I stop and sand WITH THE GRAIN after every grit until all the rotational scratches from that grit are gone. 150 sounds a little coarse to me - seems like 220 should get almost everything. I tend to turn the lathe a little faster for finer grits, but that depends on the wood.
Besides sanding with the grain and perhaps with oil, I often find it helpful to smooth with cabinet scrapers instead of sandpaper for bowls, boxes, and end grain on large spindles. I will often use small flat and curved (and well-sharpened) cabinet scrapers when the lathe is turning slowly, and on trouble spots with the lathe off. I recently made a red oak bowl using this method with the goal of using no sandpaper and it came out fine, although I did have to finish up with 400. The cabinet scrapers take off a fine shaving without pulling fibers. The scrapers are also nice to finish wood that tends to clog the sandpaper, like lignum vitae.
Re: Sanding problem
Dick Coers
>This is my favorite trick to reduce sanding time. After initial sanding, usually 180 for me, I use a damp rag to raise the grain and swell scratches. The lathe is shut off, and the rag is used to dampen, not wet, the wood. Let in dry in just a minute or so, then do the rest of the sanding. I also do this on cherry as it shows the scratches really easily as well.
Re: I get very nervous when I hear....
Jamie D
>...that someone is using scrapers inside a bowl, so I hope you're not going there John!? Sanding at high speeds means the wood acts like a cam, and the sandpaper skips from high spot to high spot like a cam follower. Slow down the RPM's as already mentioned, and do some sanding in all directions with the lathe off. Walnut is one of the worst woods for showing scratches!
that's unnecessary
John K Jordan
>Your nervousness is unfounded. I use small cabinet scrapers at various times inside and outside, on edges and end grain, on bowls, boxes and spindles. They do not grab. They are impossible to catch. They are less dangerous than sandpaper since there is no dust.
I also use occasionally use conventional scrapers hand-held off the tool rest in the same way, sometimes just the steel without the handles - they are also impossible to catch. When I started using these maybe 8 years ago people looked at me like I was crazy. Some of them are now using the same techniques. Stop by sometime when you're in the area and I'll be glad to demonstrate.
Now, putting your hand into a narrow opening with a steel scraper is something else entirely, but for an entirely different reason.
JKJ, IMHO
Re: I get very nervous when I hear....
Mfoster
>I also use cabinet scrapers (the flat hand held kind)on turned forms. Not only do they do the job of sandpaper, but will also help to fiar the curve. Sharpen and burnish the scraper often just as you would for flatwork and you will find they work really nicely. I have the wood spinning slowly for this as I do for sanding.
Mike in snowy VT