Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Bonnie Klein threading jig

Posts

Bonnie Klein threading jig

#1

Bonnie Klein threading jig

terry quiram

>A fellow turning club member spent a day in my shop and we set up and played with his threading jig. His jig is mounted to a dedicated Jet mini. It seemed to be the cat's meow for threading lidded boxes. Bill left the jig with me to play with. I watched Bonnie's dvd and saw how effertless she was able to make the jig work. This one was stiff and hard to use so I dis-assembled it, cleaned it, put lube where needed and put it back together. Much better, but in order to keep the movements smooth and realitive effertless some of the adjustments had to be loose resulting in non parallel presentation of the work piece to the cutter. I eventually made a couple boxes with decent threads but all the fiddleing around was just way too much for me.

For those of you that own a Klein jig did you have the same problems? How did you overcome them?

Re: Bonnie Klein threading jig

#2

Re: Bonnie Klein threading jig

john lucas

>That's part of why I bought the Bestwoodtools Baxter jig. It is so much smoother and more accurate. More money of course. The bestwoodtools jig will also let you change thread pitch and Vic will make them to fit any lathe.

Re: Bonnie Klein threading jig

#3

Re: Bonnie Klein threading jig

robo hippy

>I recently got the Bonnie Klein jig after taking a 3 day workshop with her. I did have a problem with it. For some reason it seemed to cut the threads deeper on one side than the other. No matter how many adjustments I made to it, I could not fix it. I took it apart, and found that the main shaft for advancing the piece into the cutter had a slight bend to it. I contacted Bonnie about it and she said she didn't think that was the problem, but would find one in the shop and replace the one I had. She contacted me the next day and told me that all the ones in the shop had the bend. She had used a new source for the all thread. She got another one made for me, and after I installed it, it worked perfectly. It is designed to have some slack in it, which wouldn't be approiate for metal work, but is fine for wood. If you tighten the jibs too much, it will be hard to move, and if you experiment around with it, you can get smooth easy opperation. Some times I think the 16 tpi is too fine, but it is easier to adjust for getting the grain to line up than a coarser thread would be. Some times I think about trying to power up the main shaft to speed things up a bit, but don't think it would work for the fine adjustments. I have never tried the other system.

robo hippy

Re: Bonnie Klein threading jig

#4

Re: Bonnie Klein threading jig

john lucas

>Robo I built a sort of homemade mini lathe using a router for the headstock. I installed my threader on this and use the high speed router to cut the threads this works better but not as much as you might think. I am able to cut threads in woods that would be totally unsuitable for hand chasing.

I'm going to be running a test on the next batch to see if sealing the wood with thin CA is better than just lubricating the wood for a clean cut. I know the CA will harden the threads and used it in the past but it's expensive and burns your eyes so I'm going to try an oil or wax lubricant and then use the CA as the last step to harden the threads if needed.

Re: Bonnie Klein threading jig

#5

Re: Bonnie Klein threading jig

Robin L

>For those that have these threading jigs,what would be a source for replacement cutters besides a metal working supply company? I have looked on Bonnie's site and others but could not find a seperate listing for just the cutters.

Robin

Re: Bonnie Klein threading jig

#6

Re: Bonnie Klein threading jig

John K Jordan

>Robin,

I have the Baxter. You might call Best Wood Tools. I see they have a variety of thread cutters in their catalog, some carbide.

JKJ

Re: Bonnie Klein threading jig

#7

Re: Bonnie Klein threading jig

Jim Pugh, Elyria, OH

>John, Mark St. Leger used a 'secret ingredient' when threading - mineral oil.

Re: Bonnie Klein threading jig

#8

Re: Bonnie Klein threading jig

Paul Waddle

>I made my own thread jig,wish I could post pictures-tried,but old brain just won't function.Email me if you like.

I took some boxes I made and an 8x10 picture of my jig to the recent LAW club and about 10 ten people said they were going to make one similar.

I think you got it right,if the thread shaft is bent,it will make excentric threads.. No question! Line up the cutter,insure centers align,keep the chuck(part to be threaded) run out less than .005, and you'll get good threads.(Might have to experiment with two dimensions: amt extra to leave on the male part and how deep to cut the threads. For 16 tpi-leave ~.090 larger on male part, and experiment in the .035-.040 depth of cutter. This is an art after all. Besure to bevel both male and female theads. Oh by the way,don't over tighten the gibs on the jig,snug is what is called for.

I'm sure Baxter jig is great,but I cannot afford a 90$ carbide cutter.When I asked for a price on HS cutter,got no response-guess I'm stuck with making my own. PW

Re: Bonnie Klein threading jig

#9

gave up on emailing Best Wood *LINK*

John K Jordan

>Best Wood Tools offers several HSS cutters in their catalog for much less. If you emailed them and didn't get an answer, I'm not surprised. They have great products but they always ignore my emails. You might try calling.

If you email your pictures to me, I'll be glad to resize and post them for you.

JKJ


http://lib.store.yahoo.net/lib/bestwoodtools/CatF2

Re: Bonnie Klein threading jig

#10

Re: Bonnie Klein threading jig *LINK*

GalenV

>You do not have to buy a carbide cutter as you should be able to order from a lot of machine tool suppliers. The cutter is not anything special.


http://www.whitney-tool.com/html/chamfer_double_hss.html

Re: Bonnie Klein threading jig

#11

Re: Bonnie Klein threading jig

john lucas

>I did get my cutter from Vic but can order them from metal supply houses. I did grind off the front of the bit so I could run the threads closer to the shoulder of the box.

I can't remember who had the threading jig at the AAW symposium. I think it was someone from New Zealand or Australia but I'm having a senior moment. It used a single point cutter similar to what machinist use to cut threads. These are also available in the metal catalogs. I'm going to try one and see how it does when I have time to place an order. The cutters Bestwoodtools sells have about 6 cutters and I would think would leave a cleaner cut than the single point cutter but then you never really know because these cutters were designed to cut metal not wood.

Re: Bonnie Klein threading jig

#12

Re: Bonnie Klein threading jig

Paul Waddle

>I made a single point tool,but it vibrated badly. I haven't tried it since I got a speed control. I too,wanted to cut close to the shoulder. Keep me in mind when you do find out. Thks,pw

Re: Bonnie Klein threading jig

#13

Re: Bonnie Klein threading jig

Fog Tanner

>I have used one of Bonnie's several times with no problems with the jig. There were some issues with the faceplates that were used and the difference in the thread tolerance in the Jet mini and Bonnie's jig. The Jet was a lot looser and allowed the faceplate to tilt slightly, where the Klein jig did not. But, I was able to work around this.

The adjustments should have only a thousandths of clearence to operate smoothly. If it is more than that, there is a burr or machining mark that is causing problems. The lead screw has two adjustments to take out play and don't need a lot of adjustment. The crossfeed on the one I used was polished from use and operated very smooth. If this isn't smooth, then some 400-600 grit on something flat should cure that problem. Also a dry film teflon will work better than an oil or grease as it does not attract dust.

Fog

Re: Bonnie Klein threading jig

#14

Re: Bonnie Klein threading jig

Karl Rinehart

>Enco has double-angle high speed steel cutters which appear to be identical to the Baxter cutters.