Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Watco vs Waterlox???

Posts

Watco vs Waterlox???

#1

Watco vs Waterlox???

Tom Minehan

>I've been using Watco Teak Oil as a finish and notice many folks using Waterlox. I have never used it but I'm almost out of Watco and may consider trying Waterlox. Any opinions on how they compare? I find Waterlox is more expensive so I presume there is a difference.

Re: Watco vs Waterlox???

#2

Re: Watco vs Waterlox???

Mac

>Tom, I use Watco myself, but used to use Waterlox,the only difference I found was that the Waterlox builds a finish quicker and a bit glossier. You can of course rub it down to the sheen you want.Also,the Waterlox will congeal(sp) much sooner than the Watco will,in fact I have some Watco that is several years old that is still good,the Waterlox will sometimes thicken in a few weeks after opening..............both are good finishes.........

Re: Watco vs Waterlox???

#3

Re: Watco vs Waterlox???

Carole Valentine

>You can make your own home brew. Check out Russ's corner - he gives a recipe. I think it is equal parts pure tung oil, spar varnish and turpentine, but I am not sure. I am going to try it when I run out of Waterlox (which I much prefer to Watco, BTW)

Re: Watco vs Waterlox???

#4

Re: Watco vs Waterlox??? *LINK*

Greg Haugen

>Tom,

First of all, one of the best things about WC is that Russ Fairfield is on it. Below is a direct link to one of his pages on finishes. Not quite, half way down Russ compares various finishes available that he'd recommend, which both of these are mentioned. He also a little lower has a "home brew" recipe.

I've used both finishes and both are good. Waterlox will build faster and have a higher level of "sheen" but can be knocked back. Some turners use Waterlox for a couple of coats and then buff with just tripoli to knock it back a bit. The tripoli also provides an excellent "feel" to the finish. It will gel but if I had a can I didn't take care of, it would still take months with daily use. If I did take care of it, adding marbles, etc to take out the air it would last over a year easily. By putting some in a small jar and just use that you're limiting the "opening" of the can, thus limiting the air exposure.

Watco's Blue label finish, aka teak oil, is an excellent finish and is often a "kept secret." Nothing wrong with it at all.

One thing I'd consider is if only one is available locally that would be a big plus if you don't have to "order" your finish. For me, there's a local supplier for both so it goes by which side of town I'm on when I go buy it.

I also do like a home brew mix. It will go bad still but the ingredients have a much longer shelf life than "mixes". Mix what you want for a month or so, and if it goes bad you out a couple of ounces at most.

Check out Russ' info. He's the man when it comes to finishes. Period.

Greg H.


Russ' Oil Finishes Link

Re: Watco vs Waterlox???

#5

Dick Hines

Re: Watco vs Waterlox???

Dick Hines

>I use Watco in the brown and white can. I have been uesing it for years and get good results.

Re: Watco vs Waterlox???

#6

Re: Watco vs Waterlox???

Cyril Griesbach

>Tom, I like to use a Danish Oil and when you and others talk about Watco I'm assuming it's Danish Oil. I've used the Watco product but I now prefer the Danish Oil from Deft as it seems to build faster and last longer in the can. I've not used Waterlox because of the complaints of is gelling in the can and I'm too lazy to decant it, use marbles etc. While I don't use it much I've also had good experiences with Formby's Tung Oil Finish which I believe to be just another form of Danish Oil.

Re: Watco vs Waterlox???

#7

Re: Watco vs Waterlox???

Greg Haugen

>I agree with Cyril. I like Deft's danish oil a lot better than Watco's danish oil. I have a can in the shop and it's an excellent finish.

Greg H.

Re: Watco vs Waterlox???

#8

Waterlox for me

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>I have used both in my turnings and on my Shaker chairs. Early on Watco was my first choice, I guess because it seemed so easy to apply. And because I saw it advertised everywhere. But I always hated the bleed back factor. I was constantly going back to wipe off the spots on the piece.

I finally decided to try the Waterlox. The built was much better, and a lot less bleed back to deal with. I also feel that I can get the finish I want depending on how many coats I apply. For most of my turned work I apply between six and seven coats 24 hours apart. I then wait 30 days before buffing on the Beall system. It seems to give me a great finish... but.... YMMV :)

Best wishes,

Dave

Re: Watco vs Waterlox???

#9

Re: Watco vs Waterlox??? You get what you pay for

Russ Fairfield

>The differences is in the oils and the resins that are added to the product.

In order of their qualities as a finish: hardness, chemical resistance, or their color change with age.

Tung Oil

Linseed Oil

Vegetable Oils (Soybean)

In order of their cost:

Tung Oil - $20.00 per quart

Linseed Oil - $10.00 per quart

Soybean Oil - $2.00 per quart

Which Product uses which Oils

Waterlox - Tung Oil

Watco Teak Oil - Linseed Oil

Watco Danish - Soybean Oil and Linseed Oil

Resins:

Waterlox uses a Phenolic resin which has a fast build to a higher gloss, a harder finish, and costs more than other resins.

Both Watco products use alkyd resins, which are less expensive, don't build as quickly, and are not as hard as the Phenolics in the Waterlox.

You get what you pay for

Re: Watco vs Waterlox???

#10

Re: DeftOil finishes

Russ Fairfield

>The Deft Oil compares to the Watco Teak Oil, and not the Watco Danish Oil. The Deft Oil and the Watco Teak Oil both use Linseed Oil, where the Watco Danish Oil is Soybean Oil and some unknown quantity of Linseed.

For me, Linseed Oil has proven to be a better finish than Soybean Oil.

Re: Watco vs Waterlox???

#11

I prefer Waterlox too

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>I just gave away a can of Watco Teak Oil. I just didn't like the way to looked. I use Waterlox mainly because it truly contains tung oil. I used to use tung oil back in the days when I used to restore antique furniture. Of course, back then, I had to contend with long drying times. With Waterlox, I don't have that issue. BTW, I decant Waterlox into 2oz jars, which helps it last longer.

This is my purely subjective opinion only. Comparing my opinion to a quarter will leave you with about $.20, so take it for what it is.

keithz

Re: Watco vs Waterlox???

#12

Thanks & Note to Russ

Tom Minehan

>Thanks to all for your responses. Russ your little tutorial was very enlightening. When I first started turning a few years ago I looked in "Russ's Corner" for tips on finishing. I think it was tip #7 that led me to Watco Teak Oil. Your suggestion was to try it if you didn't like Waterlox. Since I didn't know about either one, and wasn't sure how much turning I would do, I went with the cheaper. Maybe I will try the Waterlox although the shelf life bothers me.

I will add if anyone hasn't looked in "Russ's Corner" you owe it to yourself to do so.

Re: Watco vs Waterlox???

#13

Re: Watco vs Waterlox???

Mike Brazeau

>I recently tried an experiment on two 12" hard maple salad bowls with Watco Danish Oil. On one I applied, waited 30 minutes and applied again and then wiped off as directed after 15 minutes. At 24 hour intervals after a light rub with 0000 and a tack cloth I then applied and wiped each time for 3 more coats. The other I just did the primary applications. At guild show & tell I told people what I had done and asked them to identify the correct bowl. 4 out 5 failed. I had not buffed at that point. Both bowls were sanded prgressively to 400, but were from different trees. I buffed with white diiamond last week and waxed with LV Conservator's Wax. The bowl with only two applications to me looked just as good as the one with 5. The finish did not highly color the maple and neither had much of a build. I was very pleased with both. I have used Waterlox, but not for salad bowls. If I want a finish with build, I'll go to the General Finishes Salad Bowl finish. Do like Waterlox for build when I want a really shiney look, but never use it up fast enough. Some of you may know of Eugen Schlaak in Niagara Falls. He has been using Watco for 35 years and virtually nothing else. I was using home brew for a umber of years, but now really like the Watco. If you can get your hands on some Bush Oil, it dries quickly and is much like the General Salad Bowl in final finish and will build faster than the Watco.

Re: Watco vs Waterlox???

#14

Re: Watco vs Waterlox???

Jerry McCaffrey

>I've used both on bowls and both seem fine. However, I am refinishing the hardwood floors in my home and using Waterlox. It wears like iron, builds fast, and smooths well. Yes it does gel in opened containers faster than Watco. I love Waterlox where I need high wear & durability. These are not characteristics I generally need on my bowls. I currently have a bowl in Waterlox Gloss because I had some left from a floor. It has a high gloss without buffing, but needs some buffing for final smoothing.

Jerry