Re: Watco vs Waterlox??? *LINK*
Greg Haugen
>Tom,
First of all, one of the best things about WC is that Russ Fairfield is on it. Below is a direct link to one of his pages on finishes. Not quite, half way down Russ compares various finishes available that he'd recommend, which both of these are mentioned. He also a little lower has a "home brew" recipe.
I've used both finishes and both are good. Waterlox will build faster and have a higher level of "sheen" but can be knocked back. Some turners use Waterlox for a couple of coats and then buff with just tripoli to knock it back a bit. The tripoli also provides an excellent "feel" to the finish. It will gel but if I had a can I didn't take care of, it would still take months with daily use. If I did take care of it, adding marbles, etc to take out the air it would last over a year easily. By putting some in a small jar and just use that you're limiting the "opening" of the can, thus limiting the air exposure.
Watco's Blue label finish, aka teak oil, is an excellent finish and is often a "kept secret." Nothing wrong with it at all.
One thing I'd consider is if only one is available locally that would be a big plus if you don't have to "order" your finish. For me, there's a local supplier for both so it goes by which side of town I'm on when I go buy it.
I also do like a home brew mix. It will go bad still but the ingredients have a much longer shelf life than "mixes". Mix what you want for a month or so, and if it goes bad you out a couple of ounces at most.
Check out Russ' info. He's the man when it comes to finishes. Period.
Greg H.
Russ' Oil Finishes Link