Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Newbie safety question

Posts

Newbie safety question

#1

Newbie safety question

Alex Yeilding

>I see lots of breathing equipment used by turners, and I want to make sure I am being appropriately cautious. I recognize the need for dust protection while sanding, as I do when doing flat work. But using a gouge or skew seems like a relatively dust-free operation, just like hand planing, so I would think a face shield alone would be enough. Am I wrong here?

P.S., I am a "weekend woodbutcher" and am learning to turn as an adjunct to my primary woodworking hobby (although I already recognize that I am on a slippery slope ;-) ) My exposure and resources are too small to justify an expensive forced air rig, but I do want to be prudent where my health is concerned.

Re: Newbie safety question

#2

Re: Newbie safety question

GaryG in MD

>Alex,

I'm sure you'll get a good response here. I'll mention just one aspect that comes to mind...

If you're turning green wood, using good technique, you'll be making ribbons, not dust. In that case, I don't wear a mask under my face shield (note: this is the important part -- wear a full face shield!). If I'm turning dry wood, regardless of my technique, I can't seem to stop the generation of some dust along with short curls. In that case, I do wear a mask too.

Be particularly careful with toxic woods -- you can Google various lists online -- AAW has one, and you will also find several in the September 2007 Montgomery County Woodturners Newsletter. If I'm doing any of those, I wear a mask and long sleeves and nitrile gloves. [You will hear a disagreement about the gloves -- they are a safety hazard themselves -- some people wear gloves, and some won't. I'm on the fence.]

Be safe, Gary

Re: Newbie safety question

#3

Re: Newbie safety question

Curly Smith

>I wear a dust mask (3M #8511, if you're interested) because even the small amount of dust isn't helpful to my respiratory system. I could be wrong but I think dust exposure tends to be a cumulative issue so the less exposure the less likely that you'll develop problems.

BTW, when you say "so I would think a face shield alone would be enough protection" are you really saying "so I would think a face shield PLUS SAFETY GLASSES would be enough protection"? A face shield is not a replacement for safety glasses.

Re: Newbie safety question

#4

Re: Newbie safety question

john lucas

>I guess I'm a stick in the mud but I've been turning for over 20 years and don't wear a mask. I do run a dust collector right next to the work and before I had that I had a fan off to the side of the lathe to blow the dust away.

I do think you should use your own judgement and wear a mask if at all possible but the vast majority of turners I know don't wear one except when sanding.

Re: Newbie safety question

#5

Not stuck in the mud----grin---

Gil Jones

>I wear a Trend Air Shield for just about everything (except turning wet wood), including tool grinding and tablesaw work. Yes, I would prefer not to wear the mask/respirator/faceshield, but I also would rather extend my life a bit by not sucking in all the wood, stone, and metal dust. Just my opinion, and of course, my lungs.

Re: Newbie safety question

#6

JL

Re: Newbie safety question

JL

>I wear a mask when sanding. I also have my DC on. If the wood is dry and produces a lot of powder, I'll wear a mask.

I've had too many "productive" sneezes.

Re: Newbie safety question

#7

Re: Newbie safety question

Bill Howatt

>As a rule I always wear a mask under my face shield while turning without my Triton powered respirator. You may be pulling ribbons off the wood based on what you can see but there is probably a lot of stuff you can't see although I think that risk is minimal with wet wood. Cutting the bark and outer layers is a different issue. There can be various nasty mold spores which are not good for your lungs and IMO as mask should definitely be used here as well as for any spalted wood.

People vary widely in their sensitivity to various things and it appears to be possible to develop sensitivity as we age or perhaps accummulate the agents in our bodies.

The other advantage of wearing a dust mask is that it acts as a nose cushion/protector when you bounce something off your face shield. You do wear a face shield don't you? If not, you should.

Bill

Re: Newbie safety question

#8

North *LINK*

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I wear a North 7700 series half face respirator with pancake dust filters. It is not expensive, comfortable and as efficient as the expensive heavy units that require batteries. It fits just fine under a face shield. 3M makes something similar.


Respirator

Re: Newbie safety question

#9

Re: North - which cartridges?

Carol - now back in Dubuque, IA

>I noticed that cartridges are not included. Which to have experience with and recommend?

I also liked the backpack model. More money though. Anybody using one of these?

Re: Newbie safety question

#10

Re: North - which cartridges? *LINK*

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I use these in the shop because of the low profile. You can Google North and do some price shopping.


pancake filters

Re: Newbie safety question

#11

Re: North - which cartridges? Thanks!

Carol - now back in Dubuque, IA

>

Re: Newbie safety question

#12

Re: Newbie safety question

John K Jordan

>I mostly do small spindle turnings which would not maim or kill if they flew off the lathe (unlikely anyway) so I do not wear a face shield for those things. I wear safety glasses when the lathe or bandsaw is turned on.

Most of my sanding is by hand with the lathe off which distributes very little dust, but when power sanding or sanding with the lathe running I wear either a Trend powered helmet or a quality industrial respirator. The little paper masks are not good.

Some very dry and brittle woods make dust even when turning with a gouge.

I run a Jet air cleaner suspended from the ceiling when making dust.

JKJ

Re: Newbie safety question

#13

Thanks, all, for your responses

Alex Yeilding

>Glad I found this resource.

Curly, your post, given your email address, brought a smile to my face. Assuming I do NOT have Moe to contend with, though, why would I need safety glasses as well as a face shield?

Gary, the nitrile gloves sound like a good idea with toxic woods. The "no gloves with power tools' admonition I've always heard was because of the danger of the glove getting caught and pulling your hand in. Nitrile gloves tear too easily for that to be a problem, I would think.

Bill, thanks for the pointer about mole spores (and maybe other nasties) in bark and in spalted wood. Not something I have dealt with in flatwork; I wouldn't have thought of that.

Barbara, thanks for the pointer to the North mask. I have a similar mask I use when spraying, and I'll have to see if they make dust filters for it. If not, the North is certainly a reasonably-priced alternative.

Re: Newbie safety question

#14

Carol......

Barry Irby

>On Barbara's recommendation I bought a North half mask and I like it. I use the "physical" filters most of the time and sometimes I switch to the combination that includes the activated charcoal. With those, I can't even smell things like lacquer or some of the stinky woods. (Nothing like the smell of elm in the morning to remind you to clean out the litter box.) When using the charcoal filters I change them when I can start to smell stuff. I like the mask, comfortable and does not interfere with the face shield. It actually helps when you get whacked in the face. DAMHIKT.