Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

Posts

Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

#1

Steven Antonucci

Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

Steve Antonucci

>I had an epiphany while walking the Magic Kingdom last week. I thought that placing my Kutzall 1" ball mill in a chuck and powering it with my 1.5 HP lathe would be the answer to my dreams. It wasn't.

Even running at 3000+ RPMs, it wouldn't cut all that well. Can an air powered die grinder be spinning that ball all that much faster?

I'm trying to overcome the constant running of the compressor noise issue, and the lathe is much quieter, but nowhere near as effective...

Trying again later tonight...

Steve

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

#2

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

Dick Coers

>Some air die grinders run 25,000 rpm. Same reason the guys that pierce the work use dental drills. Higher rpms produce smaller chip size for each tooth, so it is less grabby. Put the air compressor outside if you can, or make an insulated box for the compressor. One of the greatest pleasures I have at work is having a building air supply. The compressor is down the hall and I absolutely never hear it. AHHHHHH!

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

#3

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

Greg Haugen

>Great thoughts that weren't so great...oh yeah I've had plenty. More along the line of "what the ______ was I thinking?!?!"

Die grinders are more in the 15,000 to 20,000 rpm range.

Good Luck.

Greg H.

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

#4

Here's what you need to do....

David Walser

>First, get a flexible shaft that'll hold your 1" ball mill.

2. Rig up a pulley that will mount in your drill chuck.

3. Mount the drill chuck & pulley in the headstock of your lathe.

4. Rig up another pulley that will attach to and drive the flexible shaft that holds your 1" ball mill. The size of this pulley needs to be carefully calculated such that, when driven by a belt attached to the wheel that's mounted in the headstock of your lathe, gives you the proper RPM. Some suggested 25k. Pikers! Go for 50,000 RPM. I'll leave the math up to you. (I don't know what size wheel you've got mounted in your headstock, do I?)

5. Attach a belt between the two wheels...

Wait! What was the topic of this thread? Something about having what you thought was a great idea...

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

#5

Richard Allen

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great? *LINK*

Richard Allen

>There are electric die grinders. These can even be mounted in the Oneway "Drill Wizard". A 1" ball mill will bog down low power units.


One example of an eletric die grinder

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

#6

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

charlie belden

>Walt Akers, in the usenet news group rec.woodworking had a great

Thanks Giving Day story. His cigar smoking wife, Helga, gave him the assignment to whip the cream to make whip cream for the pumpkin pie. After a few minutes with the electric egg beater, he became impatient. So he went out to the shop, got a router, installed a 1/4" collet, chucked up a beater and attacked the whipping cream with a REAL beater.

The story ends with him missing the meal because he spent that time cleaning whipping cream - off the ceiling, walls, floor, cabinets and drawers. The curtains went into the washing machine and drier - before being ironed and rehung.

Some Great Ideas are sometimes recognized as not being such good ideas BEFORE an actual Proof Of Concept. Others involved a great deal of clean up - and occassionaly - a trip to the emergency room - or to a divorce lawyer.

General rule of thumb - keep body parts out of the path a grinding burr will travel - if anything goes wrong. Don't ask how I know this.

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

#7

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

John K Jordan

>Speaking of ball mills, Ralph Watts showed us how he mounts one (smaller than yours) in a handle and uses it to hollow.

JKJ

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

#8

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

Mike Nelson

>I'm not so sure that I'm irritated by not knowing what you guys are talking about.

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

#9

My great breakfast idea

Mike Jones, Redding, CA

>The idea: a couple of soft boiled eggs on buttered toast...yummm. The Procedure: I put two eggs (yes, still in the shell) in a couple of cups of water in a four cup pirex measuring cup, put that into the microwave, set the time for 3 minutes, and then to the toaster part of the plan. The Result: about two minutes, thirty seconds into it and the eggs exploded! The microwave door blew open, and pieces of eggs, water, pirex and the bottom plate of the oven were scattered from floor to ceiling!

Good idea gone bad!!!!

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

#10

My good idea's usually start-Hey bubba watch this

john lucas

>

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

#11

Re: Here's what you need to do....

Brodie Brickey

>Instead, hook it up to a router, especially variable speed.

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

#12

Rob Wallace

Re: My good idea's usually start-Hey bubba watch t

Rob Wallace

>I don't know John, I thought it was, "Hey Bubba, hold my beer while I....."

R.

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

#13

Steven Antonucci

Threw a party with a "blown up" theme in college

Steve Antonucci

>Probably 1987 or so, and we had an "old" microwave that was on it's last legs, so we decided to blow things up in the backyard of the Frat house with a live video feed (20 pound handicam camera, full size VHS tapes) on a tripod.

Eggs definitely explode in a microwave, but if you ever want to have a bit of fun, try a coconut :-) (Just don't be near it when it happens!)

Steve

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

#14

The difference equals Wisdom.......

Barry Irby

>My son asked me how something that seems so good one minute could be so bad the next and you couldn't tell the difference up front. Wisdom might be the thing that separates that one second from the others.

My great idea was to attach my router to the lathe in such a way I could use it as a huge milling head to round blanks and save me the thumping I take when roughing big bowl blanks. Simple, just put a big cutter in the router and route off everything that sticks out. As a Proof on Concept I decided to put a guide collar in the router (1/2" 2 1/2hp) and a big carbide cutter and rest it on the tool rest while turning the lathe on. So, one hand on the screaming router and the other on the lathe switch. After a second or two of confusion and terror that seemed to go on for hours I had a ruined bit and collar and a big divot in the tool rest. Perhaps I should have rigged up something sturdier to hold the router, but I will leave that for the rest of you to figure out. I continue to rough my blanks the old fashioned way. Wonder where I can find a machinist to mill my tool rest? Not all wisdom is acquired through pleasant experiences.

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

#15

The only great idea that counted

wilbur

>"I should take up woodworking. Think of all the money I'll save by making things instead of buying them."

:@)

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

#16

Re: Grandpa always said that "if....

Jamie D

>...you never make a mistake then you never learn anything!"

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

#17

Steven Antonucci

Wisdom usually acquired 5 minutes after needed!

Steve Antonucci

>

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

#18

Steven Antonucci

Reprise: not dangerous, just not effective

Steve Antonucci

>Don't get me wrong, I've don't my share of short-changing shop activities, but this wasn't one of them. There wasn't anything dangerous or scary about the procedure, it just didn't work very well.

Now if I thought about chucking that 1" ball mill in my router and having at it, I'm betting I might be able to hurt myself...but I'd have the noise again, so maybe not...

Steve

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

#19

Re: My great breakfast idea

bill Crommett

>That egg in the microwave taught me that microwaving eggs in the shell costs $100.00 each.

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

#20

Dick Hines

Re: My good idea's usually start-Hey bubba watch t

Dick Hines

>John, those "Hey guys watch this" ideas usely come with alcohol included.

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

#21

Dick Hines

Re: Grandpa always said that "if....

Dick Hines

>Jamie, my dad used to say that . Then he would add, just don't make the same mistake twice.

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

#22

If that's true I would be a genius :).

john lucas

>

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

#23

Re: My great breakfast idea

Barry Turner

>Eggs in the shell don't micowave well. Hard boiled eggs don't microwave well, either. If you are very, very careful, you can use the microwave to cook scrambled eggs. In fact, all microwaves are pre-programmed to turn any egg into scrambled eggs. Some, more scrambled than others, as you have discovered. :-)

Re: Ever have a great idea that wasn't so great?

#24

A known technique

Ellis Walentine, Host

>When I was getting started in the custom business in the late 70s, a friend who was studying at the School for American Craftsmen at R.I.T. showed me a technique using a ball mill (about 1"�, IIRC) in a router to carve contours in some drawer fronts. He took the base off a 1-hp P-C router and hand held the barrel of the router to do the carving. I'm not endorsing or recommending this technique, just mentioning that it's been done successfully by others for many years. It didn't seem scary to me, although it is definitely a potentially risky procedure. (Ask Carol Reed about her runaway router story sometime.) Just remember that you're responsible for your own safety, and don't blame me if you wreck something or injure yourself. :-)

Ellis