Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Crative Element - Or Gimmick

Posts

Crative Element - Or Gimmick

#1

Crative Element - Or Gimmick

charlie belden

>I�ve been playing around with holes, light and the fact that light travels in a straight line - in a given medium (OK - let�s skip Space -Time Warping).

If you made a square box with 1/4� thick sides, put a light inside it and drilled holes in the faces of the box, light would shine through the holes and you�d see circles of light on the face of the box - facing you. You wouldn�t see light on the other 5 faces. If you rotate the box, some dots of light will �go out� and other will �turn on�. Viewing an edge will show few, if any, dots of light since the holes in adjacent faces are a 90 degrees to each other - we�re talking small diameter holes, say a quarter to an eighth of the thickness of the walls of the box.

Using this idea, you could create different recognizable patterns of light on each face of the box and have what you see change from one to the other as you change your viewing angle.

Now imagine that, rather than a box, you start with a cylinder. Divide the circumference of the cylinder up into four quadrants, 90 degrees apart. Now drill holes parallel to the �central axis� of each quadrant - like so.

|

o---

|

If the hole patterns are placed in textured, and perhaps blackened areas of the surface of the piece - the holes won�t be obvious - until the light goes on- inside - the piece - and your head. A little hidden surprise! And as you rotate the piece - more little hidden surprises.

Little battery powered LEDs are relatively cheap and available. The on/off switch could be set up so when the piece is sitting on a surface the light is off and goes on only when the piece is lifted to be examined.

This is a fun idea, with a lot of possibilities. BUT - would it add a creative element to a piece - or merely be a gimmick - and is there a line between the two?

I imagine the first turner to do a pierced piece was thought to be using a gimmick - probably to hide a flaw in the piece. Early reactions to texturing, staining, inlaying, patina-ing, gold leafing and so on probably got a similar reaction from other turners. But turning has been changing for a while now, and each day someone comes up with something new and different - some gimmicks - and some others will emulate. Perhaps time determines what is a new creative element - and what�s a gimmick. Maybe it�s a matter of how a new idea or technique is used.

Got an opinion?

Re: Crative Element - Or Gimmick

#2

Re: Crative Element - Or Gimmick

Fog Tanner

>Actually there is a straight line in theory only. Light, being matter and having mass, really travels in a curve which we perceive as straight since the comparison is also curved to match.

The shortest distance between two points - it is the distance between them, which of course will be a curve.

Fog

Re: Crative Element - Or Gimmick

#3

Dick Hines

Re: Crative Element - Or Gimmick

Dick Hines

>Now my brain hurts. Thanks guys.

Re: Crative Element - Or Gimmick

#4

Re: Crative Element - Or Gimmick

john lucas

>I picked up some fiber optics many years ago when I took my son to the circus. I've been trying to figure out some turning to use it in. I thought I would do a hollow lamp where the interior lookes like a cave. Then insert fiber optics in such a way that the cave sparkes when you turn the lamp on. Haven't figured out exactly how to do it yet.

I'm drawing a blank on what the early motion images were called. It was a drum with slots cut in it. It had drawings on the inside and as you spun it the slits showed the drawings and they appeared to move. That would be somewhat similar to your idea.

Re: Crative Element - Or Gimmick

#5

Re: CrEative Element - Or Gimmick

charlie belden

>Another forest for the trees case - lock onto a detail - and miss the point?

The question was - when does a "gimmick" become a Creative Element.

Now one of the definitions of gimmick is:

"An innovative stratagem or scheme employed especially to promote a project: an advertising gimmick."

If you sell your turnings, or want to get them noticed - by a show, or a collector - don't you need a strategem or scheme - just to make your work stand out from the crowd? Since all the Perfect Forms have been done - over and over and over again, The Perfect Piece of Wood isn't plentiful (or inexpensive) and pioneers of Post Lathe Enhancemnets have already staked out their territory, how do you make YOUR work stand out?

Turning is a very dynamic, intereactive process. Why should the results be static? For that matter, why should it rely on reflected light? Those are areas I like exploring - movement and now internal light.

Gimmick or Creative Element?

Re: Crative Element - Or Gimmick

#6

Re: CrEative Element - Or Gimmick

Fog Tanner

>In a discussion one eveing with Richard Raffan, the topic of selling pieces came up. He sold most of his work through galleries in Australia. There were other turners with work in the galleries, but Richard sold more. He said that only 5% of his sales are on his name, most people don't know what a Richard Raffan is. It is only within the woodturning circles that he has the rockstar type status.

He said that he sold more because he made a better bowl and it was priced reasonable. If you look at his work, a lot of the forms are simple yet elegant - they have a feel about them when you pick one up, it just feels right. His boxes have a near perfect fit, and even the simplest ones look "right". His work is noticed by the buying public because he pays attention to the small details that make a well executed piece.

We have an artist in our club who deals primarily in negative space. He does very few solid pieces, and almost no small pieces. He does not have a gimmic, it is just his view or expression on what he sees. He has several series or themes that he has done, and is always exploring. But, it is what interests him and not doing something that he thinks will catch someone's eye.

If what you are doing is satisfying to you and pleasing, then that is all the really matters. If you do something to make someone else happy with it, then you will never really be satisfied and it will show in the end result. Either way will get your work noticed, one way is positive and the other no so much.

And the light and straight line has nothing to do with space-time warp, and everything to do with Relativity...

Fog

Re: Crative Element - Or Gimmick

#7

It's creative, but what's the motive?

Ellis Walentine, Host

>Interesting question, Charlie. I don't think the two elements are mutually exclusive. Some gimmicks are very creative and some creative efforts are gimmicky. It's all about the intended purpose of your creativity. I think what you're asking is whether your "points-of-light" idea is artistic or gimmicky. It is unquestionably creative.

Ellis

Re: Crative Element - Or Gimmick

#8

Re: Crative Element - Or Gimmick *LINK*

Bob Macgregor

>You may be thinking of the Zoetrope.


Early animation

Re: Crative Element - Or Gimmick

#9

Re: It's creative, but what's the motive?

charlie belden

>The motive?

I guess its wanting to encourage physical interaction with, and exploration of, a piece. The use of internal light and holes open up some possibilities to explore. And for me, exploration is probably the underlying reason why I turn wood. Even dead ends are valuable, and the path to them often open up other possibilities to explore.

Like other apaths I've explored, this idea may be a dead end - for me. Maybe someone else will take it further and use it artistically - or not. And as you suggested - it's how ideas are used that may make what starts as an off the wall idea into yet another color for the turner's pallet.

(Now IF the Proof Of Concept piece works - I wonder how I'll photograph it? ANOTHER avenue to explore!)