Crative Element - Or Gimmick
charlie belden
>I�ve been playing around with holes, light and the fact that light travels in a straight line - in a given medium (OK - let�s skip Space -Time Warping).
If you made a square box with 1/4� thick sides, put a light inside it and drilled holes in the faces of the box, light would shine through the holes and you�d see circles of light on the face of the box - facing you. You wouldn�t see light on the other 5 faces. If you rotate the box, some dots of light will �go out� and other will �turn on�. Viewing an edge will show few, if any, dots of light since the holes in adjacent faces are a 90 degrees to each other - we�re talking small diameter holes, say a quarter to an eighth of the thickness of the walls of the box.
Using this idea, you could create different recognizable patterns of light on each face of the box and have what you see change from one to the other as you change your viewing angle.
Now imagine that, rather than a box, you start with a cylinder. Divide the circumference of the cylinder up into four quadrants, 90 degrees apart. Now drill holes parallel to the �central axis� of each quadrant - like so.
|
o---
|
If the hole patterns are placed in textured, and perhaps blackened areas of the surface of the piece - the holes won�t be obvious - until the light goes on- inside - the piece - and your head. A little hidden surprise! And as you rotate the piece - more little hidden surprises.
Little battery powered LEDs are relatively cheap and available. The on/off switch could be set up so when the piece is sitting on a surface the light is off and goes on only when the piece is lifted to be examined.
This is a fun idea, with a lot of possibilities. BUT - would it add a creative element to a piece - or merely be a gimmick - and is there a line between the two?
I imagine the first turner to do a pierced piece was thought to be using a gimmick - probably to hide a flaw in the piece. Early reactions to texturing, staining, inlaying, patina-ing, gold leafing and so on probably got a similar reaction from other turners. But turning has been changing for a while now, and each day someone comes up with something new and different - some gimmicks - and some others will emulate. Perhaps time determines what is a new creative element - and what�s a gimmick. Maybe it�s a matter of how a new idea or technique is used.
Got an opinion?



