Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

New Vessel

Posts

New Vessel

#1

New Vessel

Randy G

>I think I like this new piece I just finished, but I'm still trying to decide. It might be a touch top heavy visually. What are your thoughts... Thanks

Approx 8" high, 4" wide, from Aspen


img

Re: New Vessel

#2

Re: New Vessel

Ray Binnicker

>Hey Randy

First; Don't get me mixed up with most of the folks on this forum whose opinion you can take to the bank !! I am only in the early stages of understanding "form". However, I do like the overall shape of the vase. It does look a bit top heavy, but not so much to be un-attractive. One consideration; if you wanted to take away some of the "top heavienest" would be to take the foot off and let the sides go down to the table.

Still a nice piece as it is.

My 2cents

Ray Binnicker

Re: New Vessel

#3

Re: New Vessel

john lucas

>I'm with Ray. I wouldn't consider it unattractive. It's very nice looking. I thought maybe the bottom was too small rather than the top being too big. I suppose they go together. If you made a smaller rim it might offset the small foot or vice/versa. That's just my feeling though. Well done piece and certainly one to be proud of.

Re: New Vessel

#4

Re: New Vessel

Don Tewell in Central Illinois

>I'm think it is a tad to top heavy. I took a piece of paper and covered up the 'collar' area and it looked better, to me anyway. Nice piece and one to be proud of.

Re: New Vessel

#5

Re: New Vessel

Adrien

>With handles on the side, it would resemble an antique Greek olive oil jar, the narrow base of which was inserted into the ground to keep it upright.

Re: New Vessel

#6

Re: New Vessel

Eduardo sarmiento-hall

>Hi real nice vessel ,but in my opinion the neck should have been a bit smaller to let the shape flow my 2cents

Re: New Vessel

#7

Re: New Vessel

arkie

>I think the top is fine, although we're used to seeing smaller, non-functional openings. It's hard to tell in this photo, with the hard shadow and all, but it looks like the sides are pretty straight. If they were curved and fuller, it would look less top heavy.

Still, I wish I could do as good.

Re: New Vessel

#8

John and Ray

Randy G

>Thank you... Appreciate the comments. I think I am going to try it again maybe with a slightly bigger foot, if that doesn't work, I'll try making the Neck smaller.

Re: New Vessel

#9

Thank you

Randy G

>Thanks... had forgot to cover aspects with the piece of paper to help isolate what's got me on this one.

Re: New Vessel

#10

Re: New Vessel

Randy G

>Hmm... handles. I might have to mess with that. They attach just below the neck, or into the neck?

Re: New Vessel

#11

Re: New Vessel

Randy G

>Thank you, Yea, I'm starting to get the feeling I need to mess with the neck and foot. Find a happy medium in there. Might be a problem of a bit of a straight line on the sides too that's influencing it.

Re: New Vessel

#12

Re: New Vessel

Randy G

>The more I looked at it, the more I saw that too. Will definitely have to work on curving the sides more. Thanks for the compliments.