Turning oak
Bob Henry
>I have been asked to make a set of salt and peppermills out of oak. I have never turned oak and was wondering how it turns. Also any grain problems in turning oak? Thanks for any help.
Bob
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Turning oak
Bob Henry
>I have been asked to make a set of salt and peppermills out of oak. I have never turned oak and was wondering how it turns. Also any grain problems in turning oak? Thanks for any help.
Bob
Re: Turning oak
Ric Taylor
>Bob,
I generally avoid oak because of the tendancy to warp and split. Others may have different experiences.
Ric
Re: Turning oak
john lucas
>I turn a lot of dry oak. I'm assuming your turning these from dry wood. Oak turns quite well wet or dry. I do find the green oak moves a lot and will certainly check if you don't take precautions. Dry oak on the other hand is kind of fun. I've made a bunch of mirrors and candlesticks out of it over the years.
Re: Turning oak
John K Jordan
>Bob,
I like turning oak and haven't had any problems with splitting unless I turned it green and left parts of it too thick. The T/R shrinkage ratio is rather high so roughed green wood will go quite oval. Peppermill blanks should behave nicely, but if they are green you might want to round and drill down the center to let it dry before final turning and final sizing the inside. Oak works easily with sharp tools with very little tearout.
Red oak does have a rather coarse grain. If you use a filler on the pores the final surface can be smoother. If you sand too much with coarse paper it can accentuate surface irregularity.
I just finished a 10" red oak bowl yesterday, roughed to about 1" from green right off the sawmill and let dry for a few months with an anchorseal coating. I finish-turned with a Hunter tool, touched up with cabinet scrapers, then wet sanded by hand with 400 and 600 paper and Watco oil to finish. I'll take a picture soon.
JKJ
Re: Turning oak
keith tompkins
>Hi Bob, Oak is a very traditional turning wood...I worked with so much oak in the 70's as a custom furniture maker that I don't care to turn too much of it anymore....my sinus's are completely ruined from it, even though I wore a mask as much as possible.
Re: Turning oak
Ken George
>I have turned some oak and have done a pair of salt and pepper mills. I rubbed acrylic paint into the tops, black and white, in an attempt to identify the salt from the pepper. The black took quite well the white not so well.
Re: Turning oak
Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN------WebKitFormBoundar
>To distinguish salt from pepper, I make my pepper shaker from dark wood (as walnut) and my salt shaker from light wood (as holly, magnolia, maple, etc.). Everyone seems to get the message. I also just drill one 1/8" hole.
Re: Turning oak
Brad Vietje
>Bob,
There are many different Oak species and variations, and you didn't specify which you were looking to turn, or green vs dry, etc...
I find White Oak turns very well for spindles and small projects like pepper mills and boxes -- haven't had any big enough to make a bowl yet. Red Oak and Black Oak are stringier, with an open pore structure. When green, there can be pulled fibers on the side grain, which doesn't tend to happen when it dries. All the Oak I've used would be too coarse for finials and fine detail work.
I like Red Oak a lot for natural-edge bowls, vases and goblets. If you get fresh wood and turn it green, the bark is thin and tough, and tends to stay on the piece better than some other woods.
Red Oak (Northern), and Black Oak also have a cool surprise when you turn something on the pith -- the pith is shaped like a tiny 5-pointed star!
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
Re: Turning oak
Bob Henry
>Had not made a choice of what oak I would use other than it would be dried. Just looking to see what would be best and how it turned.
Bob