Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Not clear on the Hunter Tool pricing - or which to *LINK*

Posts

Not clear on the Hunter Tool pricing - or which to *LINK*

#1

JL

Not clear on the Hunter Tool pricing - or which to *LINK*

JL

>get. I see the Hunter #5 at $119.99. I also see the Hunter #6 at $109.99.

The Hunter #6 is thicker (3/4" vs. 5/8"). I also see the replacement tips for the #6 available separately. I realize that the #5 takes a #3 tip (which are slightly more expensive).

So - why would I get a #5? The #6 is beefier and less expensive. If there is a reason to get the #5, I'll get it. But if I could be better served by getting the #6...

TIA


Hunter tools

Re: Not clear on the Hunter Tool pricing - or which to *LINK*

#2

Re: Not clear on the Hunter Tool pricing - or whic

mfoster

>The end on the #5 tapers down to a smaller size which allows you to get into tighter places yet still has the same rigidity. If that is not an issue, go with the bigger one. I just got a #5 and really like it. Give Mike a call. He couldn't be nicer and will give you all the scoop.

Re: Not clear on the Hunter Tool pricing - or which to *LINK*

#3

Re: I prefer the versatility of the #5 .....

Jamie D

>....for most frequently turned sizes, and the #6 is a brute for large hollowings with reversed edges that need to be hogged out. I do have both, and the larger 3/4" shaft of the #6 can be hung way off the tool rest, and fits both my Stewart handle and Jamieson D handled captured hollowing system.

Re: Not clear on the Hunter Tool pricing - or which to *LINK*

#4

Not sure why the #6 cutter is cheaper than the #4 *LINK*

Don in Northern Arizona

>The #6 doesn't appear on Mike's site, and though it seems to use the same sized 1/2" cutter as the #4, the pricing of the #6 cutter is cheaper. I wonder if it is made exclusively for Woodcraft as no one else seems to have it. Below is Mike's description of the #5 for "small but deep vessels". BTW he is a pleasure to do business with.

Don


Mike's #5 page

Re: Not clear on the Hunter Tool pricing - or which to *LINK*

#5

Re: Not clear on the Hunter Tool pricing - or whic

Michael Stafford

>Jerome, I think your decision will be dependent on how you intend to use the tool.

I have not used a #6 so all my comments regarding it are hearsay. My understanding is that the #6 was developed for turning bowls as an alternative to using bowl scrapers and whatnot. It can be used to great effect in hollowing a bowl I believe also. Now, like I said, I have not used the #6 but it seems to me the cutter could be too large for hollowing on the inside of turnings. The Hunter works so well because only a small portion of the diameter of the extremely sharp carbide cutter is in contact with the wood at a time. Thus the larger #6 would work well in a bowl type situation where you can control the cut visually.

When I am hollowing on the inside of an object I am not able to control how much of the cutter diameter is in contact with the wood at all times. If the Hunter has a large amount of its diameter in contact with the wood at one time it chatters and cutting performance decreases. So a smaller cutter is more forgiving and does not create the huge amounts of torque that a larger cutter would create when the cutter is cutting over a large part of its diameter. In other words the big cutter yields big dig ins when too much of its surface is cutting at one time.

The #5 uses a smaller cutter (3/8") and is mounted on a tapered shaft so you get the benefit of extended reach over the tool rest without tool chatter and better control because the smaller cutter takes a smaller "bite". It works very well on the inside of smaller objects.

If anyone has a different explanation or a better explanation please jump in and help me explain.

Mike Hunter, where are you when I need you, buddy? 8-)

Re: Not clear on the Hunter Tool pricing - or which to *LINK*

#6

Re: Not clear on the Hunter Tool pricing - or whic

Greg Haugen

>Depends on what you what to do. For versatility, the #5 is the best option. Like Mike, I haven't used a #6. I was recently at a Woodcraft and put both into my hands. The #6 is ALOT of tool. I do not know about the pricing, but from seeing them both in person the #5's circular taper is different than the milling on the #6, which may effect the price. I can definately see that the #6 being made with bowls or larger object that would require some serious "hang over" from the tool rest. Or as Jamie D. mentioned it fits in 3/4" hollowing handles and captured systems. I also agree with Mike about the tip, I can take another pass easier than I can glue some wood back on. I use my #5 for final cuts on bowls, just like John Lucas uses the #4 on the youtube video. I like a smaller tip for final cuts, but I also like the heft of the shaft of the #5 for hollowing end grain. Heck, I've turned pens with my #5 and then hollow a fairly good sized end grain box with it.

If the majority of your work is bowls and vessels in excess of 14" and you're not planning on doing end grain work under 6" in diameter, the #6 would work. If you're turning bowls and vessels under 16" mostly and would like to make boxes, etc. I'd recommend the #5 still.

These are just my opinions.

Greg H.

Re: Not clear on the Hunter Tool pricing - or which to *LINK*

#7

JL

From the maker's mouth

JL

>"Congratulations on winning a gift certificate to Woodcraft. As wood turners, Woodcraft is a favorite place to shop.

Sales volume generally dictates what other woodturners are buying ... they are clearly purchasing the # 5 tool. This is a relatively new tool on the market and was actually suggested by Jimmy Clewes. In his new DVD, Turning Las Vegas, Jimmy Clewes uses this tool in the DVD hollowing out a large vessel.

Myself, I prefer the # 5 tool. It is useful, general purpose, all around tool for boxes, bowls, and spindle work. My latest spindle work was a pepper mill and it worked great.

Thank you for your email.

Mike Hunter"

He responded very quickly. A #5 it is. I'll have to order an extra #3 tip while I'm at it.

Re: Not clear on the Hunter Tool pricing - or which to *LINK*

#8

Mike Hunter

Mike . your explanation is perfect and "right on"

Mike Hunter

>