[AD] The New Bowl Saw! [AD] *LINK*
#1
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: [AD] The New Bowl Saw! [AD]
Ralph
>ok, I gota say I thought it was a joke, then, well... After reading the endorsements and recognizing several names, maybe not.
But that doesn't mean I ready to buy one
limitations
John K Jordan
>Ralph,
This thing works and works reasonably well. However, it has limitation in the shape of the resulting bowl. The bottom made with this type of saw will always be flat unless you make very thick cores and turn to a new shape. (To cut a curved bottom with such a saw, the blade would have to dynamically change it's angle and radius as it went deeper.)
However, when you look at other types of coring tools, they all have a similar geometric limitation. I bought a McNaughton set and just watched the Mahoney video last night. All the bowls made from this coring system have the same profile - radiused sides. The shapes of all of the nested bowl sets in the Mahoney gallery looked basically the same. If you want an ogee or anything other than a radius on the profile, you will have to make very thick cores to give you some room to reshape.
JKJ
Re: limitations -- Yes, and NO
Brad Vietje
>JKJ,
I agree that the Bowl Saw has some limitations, and isn't going to be the right tool for everyone.
However, while the McNaughton coring tools also have their limitations, spherical bowls are simply not one of them. One of the best selling points for the McNaughton tools is that you are NOT limited to spherical "hub cap" shapes, a common complaint with most other coring tools.
While Mike Mahoney makes series of nested bowls with very little waste, they don't have to be spherical. The McNaughton set can be used to create tall tulip shapes, "V"- shaped blanks, and even wide, nearly flat platter shapes. As you explore the tool further, you'll see the different shapes you can get by changing the knives, and the location of the entry cut, and the path of the cut, you can get a number of alternate outcomes -- even funnels.... um, aah,.... DAMHIKT. ;~{
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
Re: limitations -- Yes, and NO
Bill Blasic
>Thanks Brad!
limitations -- radiused vs spherical
John K Jordan
>Brad, good points.
Note that I carefully did not use the word "spherical" but "radiused." (is that a word?)
Whether wide hubcaps, perfect hemispheres, tall vases, or cones, the sides will either have to conform to the shape of the tool OR the kerf will have to be widened enough to allow varying the profile with the same or another tool. (Mahoney does this several times on his video.) With a significantly wide kerf and "wasted" wood a variety of profiles should be possible. But at some point a thick coring should effect the same result (with the help of a bowl gouge afterwards.) Did you see the photo I posted once of how Lisi Oland cores large blanks - with a chainsaw!
I think I'll go to the shop and invent a flexible corer that will follow a programmable path through the wood. I want a spinning tip with a vacuum system to eat the wood so the blank could be turned very slowly. The details may be tricky, of course. :)
While dreaming, another thing would seem useful - a way to mount a bowl-saw on the end of the McNaughton to eliminate the breakout Mahoney warned against.
BTW, I bought the mini+standard combo package. It seems for that many hundreds of dollars they could provide more than a single b&w sheet of instructions (and with nary a photo or even a diagram). I'm surprised they don't bundle Mahoney's video with the package - I think that would be a smart marketing move.
JKJ
Re: limitations -- radiused vs spherical
john lucas
>John The medical industry has tools that will cut around a corner and are adjustable. So it shouldn't be too hard to make something that has a cutter on the end and flexible joints that can be adjusted. Then you might as well hook this up to one of the robotic systems so you can sit in the next room and watch it on a monitor.
Re: [AD] The New Bowl Saw! [AD] Ralph
Barbara Gill, Remlik VA
>I you search the messages you will find lengthy and numerous threads on the Bowl Saw.
Laproscopic Coring System ???
Brad Vietje
>Hmmm,
Just imagine the shop set-up costs for a coring system based on a video-guided, laproscopic bowl saw system, complete with $25M dendritic malpractice insurance! Sure would be cool to use it, though.
I hope someday to feel flush enough to get the small and medium knife sets for the McNaughton system. I only have the larger set, and could make use of the medium set a lot more often.
Be well, stay warm, and safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
Re: limitations -- radiused vs spherical
John K Jordan
>John, the thought occurred to me after I posted that all I'd have to do would be steer the tip. I had envisioned a flexible shaft made of vertical links (a bit like a series of hinges) and had first imagined all the links would need to be steered. But if the tip could be steered (perhaps by way of differential tension on a pair of strong embedded steel ribbons or cables?) and the links constructed such that they could float in the kerf with minimal binding, (perhaps with roller bearings to minimize friction?) AND if some means could be devised to remove the chips (compressed air and vacuum?), I'll bet the thing could actually work!
Speaking of cutting in unusual ways, did you ever see the hand saw that could cut a perfect 90 deg corner half way through a board? I saw a picture once, I think in a book of old tools. Amazing.
JKJ
Re: limitations -- radiused vs spherical
Bob Macgregor
>Well working from a video monitor in the next room would certainly keep you out of the line of fire in case anything blew up. Maybe that extra margin of safety would cut down on the woodturner's malpractice insurance bill.
BOB
Re: Laproscopic Coring System ???
Coyne
>Oil well drillers have guidable drills that let them drill under occup[ied or developed land. Could their guidable drill be miniaturized (there's a new word for me)?
All these high tech ideas sound wonderful for the production turner, but the higher the tech, the less the fun, and for me (because of limitations of skill, time, artistic talent, etc.) woodturning will always have to be about fun.
Coyne