Re: Wood from JKJ.... Gum box...
Michael Stafford
>Charlie, I will try to answer your questions as well as I can.
"The underside of the lid seems to bottom out on the top inner rim of the bottom of the box and the overlap seems pretty tall - increasing the gap between the look of the outer grain pattern. Any reason why so much overlap?"
The flange of the box body is not much longer than 1/4" even though it might look longer than that in the photo. It does not bottom out inside the lid. There is a slight step/rabbet on the box body upon which the lid sits. This is done intentionally to define the proportions of the box and to help disguise any grain mismatch plus it provides a shadow line.
"The lip around the lower rim of the box appears, in the Asian Ebony open picture, to have a short, small, step in it. The rim of the lid appears to be slanted slightly towards the inside."
As I stated in response to your first question above there is a step/rabbet upon which the lid sits. The little gap helps disguise the grain mismatch and creates a little shadow line. The bottom rim of the lid is definitely slanted slightly towards the inside. This ensures a nice clean edge on the outside and ensures a nice appearance when the box is closed.
"I can understand the "slant inward" rim of the lid - but the stepped rim of the bottom has me a bit confused. Is it there to intentionally leave a visual shadow line between the lid and the box - thus making slight grain misalignments less noticeable, or is there another reason."
You answered your own questions before I got to the third one and the answer to each part is "Yes". It is intentional and is done for all the reasons I have discussed plus it also provides a place for one to stick in a fingernail if the lid is too tight and hard to open so it can be pried open.
Thank you for your comments Charlie. A rather famous turner recently said to me and I'll quote "Simple never looks as difficult as it is does it? I think your shapes have that simplicity going for them which is why they're so successful." I much prefer simple shapes and I try to do them as well as I can. I want the lines to be clean and the wood finished so it is as beautiful as it can be. I much prefer, and this time I will quote you, "Just the wood - and the form."