Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

One more strike and I'm out

Posts

One more strike and I'm out

#1

One more strike and I'm out

GalenV

>For the second time in my life a face shield saved my day.

About 41 years ago I worked in a foundry as a casting finisher. I had a 1 1/2" diameter by 2" long steel cutter break on a pnumatic grinder doing 10,000 rpm and it hit me square on a face shield.

Today I had a rough turned bowl about 9" diameter by 5" deep with 3/4" wall come out of the chuck at 580 rpm and it too hit me square in the face shield.

I hope it will be another 41 years before I make strike three!

Both cases, other than scaring the ------out of me I had no injury.

For those of you who only wear safety glasses I hope you got good health insurance! It may not happen often but now twice is enough for me.

Galen

Re: One more strike and I'm out

#2

Re: Glad you are ok, but the question now is WHY.

!

>Trusting safety equipment is not the best way to forestall strike 3. Can you tell us WHY the bowl left the chuck? What went wrong? You need to know why, so it won't happen again. Tell us so we can profit from your misfortune.

Re: One more strike and I'm out

#3

Re: One more strike and I'm out

Norm Smith

>Galen, You are a smart guy for wearing the face shield. Lots of guys don`t bother or , like me sometimes forget to put it on.

Norm

Re: One more strike and I'm out

#4

Re: One more strike and I'm out

Bruce McElhaney, Spring Lake, Michigan

>I feel your pain. I got smacked hard in the face shield when a segmented bowl broke apart. . .

Re: One more strike and I'm out

#5

Re: WHY!

GalenV

>Honey locust bowl seems to get rock hard when dry. The interior was like a wash board with different shrink rate of porous wood and dense. Making first cut into bowl about 1� in and it just looks like it tore out going across a porous ring to dense. Using a sharp Thompson bowl gouge and trying to rub bevel. I think I was trying to force a cut on hard wood and since bowl was out of round from drying and wash board I just dug in.

Lesson learned? Don�t force a cut and especially on out of round rough rock hard wood.

Galen

Re: One more strike and I'm out

#6

There are two types of turners...

Steven Kubien

>...those who have been smacked in the face by flying wood and those are about to be. Glad you were wearing your shield.

Steve

Re: One more strike and I'm out

#7

Re: There are two types of turners...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I'll have admit that I'm one of those who almost never wears a face shield. I hate 'em. Safety glasses? Always. After many hundreds of bowls and hollowforms I do manage to stay out of the line of fire. I can't say that I've never sent one flying but it's been a long time. But who knows, maybe the next one?

I do urge my students to wear face shields but I don't require it. I probably should.

Wally

Re: One more strike and I'm out

#8

Re: There are two types of turners...

Cyril Griesbach

>Steve, there are actually three types...those who have, those who will and those who will again.

"live is hard but it harder if you're stupid."

John Wayne

Re: One more strike and I'm out

#9

Staying Out of The Line of Fire.....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>On every lathe I've had since sometime in the 70's, I've done my hollowing on the outboard side of the lathe. This means that I'm facing the piece and am never in the line of fire. When I'm shaping the outside I'm usually facing the headstock or away from it so I'm seldom in the line of fire then either.

The advent of the sliding headstock (a great invention) enables the turner to hollow while facing the piece, with the toolrest between you and the blank. A much safer and better way to turn.

Wally

Re: One more strike and I'm out

#10

Re: There are two types of turners...

Russ Fairfield

>Wally, I think a couple things that come with experience are the ability to recognize what is about to happen before it happens, and learning a few safer working habits to keep them from happening again. Explosions and flying bowls never just happen instantaneously or without cause. There is always a warning, and there is always something we could have done to prevent it.

Re: One more strike and I'm out

#11

Re: There are two types of turners...

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN------WebKitFormBoundar

>I have a honey locust bowl drying on the lathe tonight. When I return to that quick drying wood tomorrow I will be especially careful. Thanks.

Re: One more strike and I'm out

#12

Re: There are two types of turners...

Carole Valentine

>I have always thought that too, Russ. A funny vibration, a very slight change in sound, an in-round piece that all of a sudden doesn't seem quite round...anything like that always puts me on full alert and I shut off the lathe to investigate. Of course it goes without saying that funky wood or stuff with inclusions and cracks or very thin pieces deserve a heap of respect and a moment of inattention can cause a big explosion. I think the key is to pay attention and be aware - listen to all of your senses as well as that "little voice." And stay out of the line of fire whenever possible just in case.

Re: One more strike and I'm out

#13

Re: There are two types of turners...

GalenV

>"And stay out of the line of fire whenever possible just in case"

Yes, being new to turning I had my head too far forward trying to watch the cut inside the bowl at the start.

Believe me there was no time to react. The bowl was there and then gone. No time to even think "oh shi$" till after the fact.

Think I will go back to pens that are trapped on a mandrel.

OR

Make lathe safety video on what NOT to do when turning. I should be good at that! :>)

Galen

Re: One more strike and I'm out

#14

Re: There are two types of turners...

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Unfortunately there are quite a few of those videos out there except the people who made them didn't have a clue.

Re: One more strike and I'm out

#15

Re: There are two types of turners...

Russ Fairfield

>I am wondering if there is any correlation between loud music in the shop and having sudden instant explosions and flying bowls. The wood could be giving a warning, but it is lost in the noise. You can't react to what you can't hear.

Re: One more strike and I'm out

#16

Re: There are two types of turners...

Carole Valentine

>I'd be willing to bet there is a correlation, either between not being able to hear changes in the sound because of extraneous noise, or not having enough experience to pick up very subtle changes in sound as a warning. In my very early turning days, I had two pieces leave the lathe. One broke, and was preceded by a very faint little "different" sound for perhaps 5-10 seconds. The other came out of the chuck. It was preceded by a sort of faint low rumble and seemed to go out of round, very quickly followed by the piece flying out of the chuck jaws. I doubt either of those sounds would have been heard above music or even a loud dust collector. My ears remember both of those incidents very clearly! The one other time I had a piece explode, I was having my first go at turning a thinner vessel. There is definitely a very distinct sound as the thickness of the wood diminishes - especially right before the inside becomes bigger than the outside! Ones ears can serve as a crude set of calipers.

Re: One more strike and I'm out

#17

That is the best defense.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Stay out of harm's way.

When a piece leaves the lathe, you can step back and watch the piece fly and bounce harmlessly in front of you.

Unfortunately, that is hard to do with spindles. Maybe that's why I don't like spindle turning as much as bowl turning.

Re: One more strike and I'm out

#18

Re: There are two types of turners...

Bill Howatt

>I agree, I have detected loose chucks by the clunk-clunk sound when there was no visible or tactile feedback. The classic one of course is hearing the difference in sound when the bowl has a crack in it even though the crack may not be visible.

FWIW, I also find that sound provides a lot of information when cutting on a tablesaw or any saw for that matter. I might was well expand it to "any cutting tool"! Combined with the tactile feedback sound tells you way more about the cutting action than vision.

Bill

Re: One more strike and I'm out

#19

Re: There are two types of turners...

GalenV

>No loud music in my shop just the little voices in my head! :>)

I know now what thin wood sounds like from when I was finishing the foot on a bowl and just after this change in sound I had a funnel and not a bowl.

Glad to hear stories from the more experienced turner's beginning and things that did not always go as expected. I don't feel quite so bad.

Hum!

I wonder if there is a market for a wood turner's CD on Sounds of Pending Disasters - for the new turners listening pleasure?

Or a safety video "In Harms Way" OOPS think that line has been used.

Galen

Re: One more strike and I'm out

#20

Brad Vietje

Re: Staying Out of The Line of Fire.....

Brad Vietje

>Galen,

If you are using the 1236, once you rough the bowl out between centers, you can sometimes rotate the headstock a little (I'm guessing 1/2 way to the 45-degree detent, so ~22.5 degrees), and work a little further away from the line of fire. This can be very helpful for using hollowing tools or scrapers, and keeps you out of the path of flying wood. Whatever you do, completely ignore the instructions that come with that lathe about turning the headstock 90 degrees, and using the tool rest banjo extension. Don't rotate the headstock so far that you can't reach the piece with the standard toolrest, unless you invest in a better tool rest/banjo/floor stand, etc...

I would strongly advise you -- and I ain't kiddin' -- to throw away the extension, which is as poorly conceived, designed, and manufactured as any piece of cast metal crap I have ever seen. It is frightfully dangerous, and ought to have been banned years ago.

There are numerous problems with this cast metal thing, but it can cause vibrations, or snap in two with bad catches. It is far better suited to breaking ice off your auto's wheel wells, or serving as a screen door counterweight. Avoid Accident #3 -- don't use it.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: One more strike and I'm out

#21

Re: Lathe is 1220.

GalenV

>I have seen some video where they turned the lathe head at about 45 degree to turn but nothing much was said as to what potential problems or advantages. Guess for right shape it would improve swing capacity.

Maybe someday a bigger lathe but for now this 1220 has done all I have ask of it. Well I did not ASk it to hit me in the face shield with the bowl, it just did - guess it was with my help though.