False accuracy (OT)
Alex Yeilding
>"what I call "false accuracy". Digital devices are especially problematic in this regard since they can display multi-decimal readings that exceed the significant digits constrained by the true precision of the measuring device."
Okay, you hit a pet peeve of mine! The one that really gets my goat is my bathroom scale that shows weight to 0.1 lbs, and shows exactly the same weight before and after I remove shoes and pants with pockets full of change and keys!! I haven't actually measured, but I think it is accurate to about 1KG.
"12-decimal accuracy from an electronic calculator which is based on input numbers with single-digit accuracy (significance) leads modern-day students to routinely overstate the precision of their results."
Oh, I don't think we can blame the electronic calculator for that! It might make it easier, but I still had a hard time learning that lesson with paper and pencil.
"Of course, most of the time overstating calculated or measured precision has no practical consequence"
I tried making that argument the first time I had a physics problem marked incorrect for showing the answer to four significant digits when one of my measurement devices was accurate only to two digits. I lost my appeal!
Now, don't you feel bad for raising my blood pressure to 148.7385/94.327?