>I have been using a homemade vacuum adapter for vacuum chucking for quite a while. It works, but not as well as it could. I have used a design similar to various setups posted on the net with a bearing mounted on the outboard handwheel. I used a bearing and nipple that allowed me to disconnect the hose and use a knockout bar through the nipple to remove morse taper drives. I liked this setup, because I just popped on the vacuum hose and I was ready to go. Problem is that every bearing I have used leaks enough for me to lose a quater to half the vacuum that my pump draws and eventually the seal on the double sealed bearings goes. Seems I've remade this setup (or some version of it) at least 3 or 4 times. Last time I used 2 bearings (double sealed) but the seals (which are rubber) eventually self destructed.
I have been reluctant to go to the commercial versions because either you have to remove and install the chuck every time you want to use it, or you lose the ability to use a knockout bar to remove morse taper drives. I'm considering the Oneway setup, but wanted to see if anyone has an opinion on it, and a solution to the knockout bar problem. TIA
>I've made 3 of the couplers and just went to my local bearing supply house. I didn't order anything special. I guess I just got lucky but none of mine leak. I still get between 23 and 25 inches on everything. Are you sure it's the bearing. I had to put a foam seal between the bearing and my handwheel because it often leaked there.
I also have foam seals inside the nut on my vacuum chucks to stop the leaks. I have one wooden vacuum chuck. I covered the outside of it with clear packing tape because it leaked.
You asked about the Oneway Vacuum system. I have the Oneway Vacuum Adapter (with the special, non-threaded adapter for the Jet 1642), and I can give it a very strong, positive recommendation. I built my own valve/gauge/air-leak system, and use a Gast 0523 pump. I can say that the Oneway Vacuum Adapter performs very well, is quite smooth in operation, and does not leak (at least in my system). I generally like to build everything I can to save money, but I thought that simply buying the vacuum adapter would be worth it, given that I'd rather be turning than working on building and fine tuning a vacuum adapter. I've had my vacuum system in operation on the Jet 1642 for a few years, and it works flawlessly.
At the last AAW Symposium in Richmond, I actually bought a second Oneway Vacuum Adapter (this time with the 1" x 8tpi L/R threaded adapter) for use on a homebrewed "finishing" lathe I'm building around a reconditioned Delta Rockwell headstock and a treadmill DC motor. So if buying TWO of these units is any endorsement, I guess you have mine!
>I am with John. I just made a vauccum chuck system for my 3520 and I get 24 inches. Like John I have a gasket between the rotary adapter and the handwheel. I also put a gasket between the bearing and the rotary adapter to prevent leaks. There is an o ring around the insert that fits into the spindle so it fits snugly. It is no problem to pull it off for spindle work. I have a convenient holder on the wall about a foot from the headstock that I can store the rotary adpter in with the hose still fastened. You can see I have not even bothered to put a hose clamp on it but probably will.
Thanks for the feedback. John, I definitely isolated the leak to the bearings. I have done much of what you have done on the various adapters regarding O rings and gaskets. On the present bearing that I just put in, I can actually hear air hissing through the bearing. I have isolated each part of the system and I consistently pull 20 to 23 inches until I add the bearing. The last setup I had (with 2 bearings) worked pretty well until the rubber seals went and crumbled into the bearing causing it to almost seize.
I like the looks of the bearing that Galen posted a link to with metal seals, and the idea of using some grease to help with the seal as suggested by anonymous. Mike, my setup looks very similar to yours (although not as thick).
Guess I'll hunt for a better bearing and try again.
>I love trouble shooting vacuum leaks. You get to stick your thumb over that little hole and feels like it's going to suck you clear inside. I'm surprised I don't have little round Hickies all over my hand.
>Here's a few pics of mine. This was a test to see if the concept would work so I used some bearings that were spares and fit. The bearing are shielded, not sealed, so the first time I fired it up all the grease was sucked out. Solved the problem with a piece of inner tube from the local bicycle shop's scrap bin, cut to fit tight on the brass nipple and cover the shield (shown in the lower right pic).
>About seven years ago I had a bowl lathe I had bought second hand and I looked at making a vacuum adaptor. Fortunately I decided to buy the Oneway and had an insert custom threaded at a local machine shop. That lathe had a 1 1/4" x 7 TPI headstock. One of my best decisions ever. For the cost, at the time I figured it was great value and that proved out in the long run. The quality of the adaptor and their chucks lead me to a 2436 a couple of years later. All I had to do was pickup a new adaptor and I was in business in ten minutes.
>I took my 3520 handwheel to the machine shop instructor at the college where I work. I made him a wooden model of what I wanted to do. He cut a thread on the inside of the handwheel, and made an adapter with threads to match from solid aluminum. I supplied a sealed bearing and brass 1/4" NPT fitting. All the parts were press-fit and assembled. I put an O-ring between adapter and handwheel and there are no air leaks. I can screw on the adapter in about 10 seconds, and it works great.
>Instead of MDF I use threaded Trex decking scraps that have plastic incorporated. Trex doesn't leak air at the threads or the body. I do use a bead of silicone caulk on the joint between the trex and the PVC pipe, and I use a foam seal between the pvc pipe and the bowl I am turning. I get such a tight seal I have to crack a relief valve to avoid collapsing thin bowls. I use a small GAST vacuum pump. I'll try an post a couple of pictures if anyone is interested.