Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

big disasters with captive hollowing rigs?

Posts

big disasters with captive hollowing rigs?

#1

big disasters with captive hollowing rigs?

phil in NJ

>Hi,

Curious if anyone has had an big disasters with captive hollowing systems? That is, bigger than just a blown up hollowform :)

Bent/Broken tools, tool rests, etc.? Anyone ever actually have a failure in the hollowing rig itself to restrain tool movement?

Thanks!

-Phil

Re: big disasters with captive hollowing rigs?

#2

Re: big disasters with captive hollowing rigs?

Sean Troy

>Never. The safe part is your standing out of the line of fire if the big bang happens

Re: big disasters with captive hollowing rigs?

#3

Re: big disasters with captive hollowing rigs?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>If someone had tools bend, tool rests bend or break or any other such disaster in my opinion the operator would be grossly negligent.

Re: big disasters with captive hollowing rigs?

#4

Re: big disasters with captive hollowing rigs?

john lucas

>Cut through the sides yes, cut the lip off yes. Blow up, just one and I think the wood had a crack I didn't see.

If a captured rig is set up correctly the cutter in on the center line and there isn't any real torque. When I built my first one I made the captured arms fairly wide because I thought this is what stabilizes the whole system. My last rig only has 4" between the arms because you aren't really trying to arrest the torque. The secondary tool rest keeps the bar parallels and centered on the piece. This is what arrest much of the torque. I probably didn't explain that very well but I hope you understand. You also always know exactly the angle of the cutter since this doesn't change.

If you are using a curved bar, the tip should be in line with the main part of the shaft. You set the tool rest so it is setting on this straight part and it eliminates any torque.

You are also turning very relaxed outside the the line of fire if it does explode.

I went to the captured bar system after almost breaking my wrist on a very bad catch using an arm brace. I still hollow with it on smaller work because I think it's a good skill to have. On large work it's just so much more relaxing using a captured bar system.

Re: big disasters with captive hollowing rigs?

#5

Re: big disasters with captive hollowing rigs?

A. C.

>During our "test to destruction" phase of development, we managed to break a 3/16 HSS toolbit using the most agressive techniques you can imagine. There was absolutly no damage to the unit. Other than a poorly designed and constructed home made rig, I imagine that most units will fair well. Vibration will be your first clue. When you feel vibration and hear harmonics in the bar, you are nearing the limits.

Re: big disasters with captive hollowing rigs?

#6

Just remember Murpheys Law.

Norm Smith

>

Re: big disasters with captive hollowing rigs?

#7

Re: big disasters with captive hollowing rigs?

Texian

>A friend of mine bent a boring bar, about 1/2" diameter. Not sure of the details or which hollowing rig was being used, as he seems to have at least one of everything.

Re: big disasters with captive hollowing rigs?

#8

Re: big disasters with captive hollowing rigs?

paul waddle

>Could you elaborate a little more on the last hf tool you made-ie;shortening the holderpocket(?) I call it the back anti turning part. part. ha ha. pw

Re: big disasters with captive hollowing rigs?

#9

I broke a banjo and was definitely negligent!

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>

Re: big disasters with captive hollowing rigs?

#10

Dick Hines

Re: big disasters with captive hollowing rigs?

Dick Hines

>The only disasters I have had is blowing up a few hollow froms. I had a big cherry burl come apart last summer. I am still finding small pieces.

Re: big disasters with captive hollowing rigs?

#11

thoughts on 1/2" bar

john lucas

>I find a 1/2" boring bar is only good for around 8" deep. you start getting chatter around there depending on the cutter. If you try to go further you can get a catch. If you force the cut aggressively after about 6" you can get in trouble. Larger diameter cutters will also cause a problem earlier on and require a lighter touch.

At least that's what I find.

Re: big disasters with captive hollowing rigs?

#12

Re: thoughts on 1/2" bar

Sean Troy

>I use a 1 1/4" cold rolled steel bar for the larger forms and a 1/4" cutter tip with it. 15" is as deep as I've gone so far.

Re: big disasters with captive hollowing rigs?

#13

Re: big disasters with captive hollowing rigs? *LINK*

Steven Kubien

>I've gone through the sides a couple of times but that's it. Then again, I learned to hollow from Lyle Jamieson, in person and afterward by watching his dvd. Follow what is in the dvd and it is HIGHLY UNLIKELY that you will ever have too much excitement.

Steve Kubien

Usual disclaimer...no affiliation, just a happy dude


Hollow Forms the Easy Way

Re: big disasters with captive hollowing rigs?

#14

Brad Vietje

I Agree.

Brad Vietje

>I think Barbara and John Lucas summed it up pretty well.

When properly set up, there should be only a moderate, downward force on the tip and to a lesser extent, the toolrest. The trick is to NEVER let that cutting tip go below center, as well as not pushing too hard. These are cool tools, but they don't change the fundamentals of wood turning -- the cutting edge moves through a path, cutting wood or air as the shape of the wood dictates, so our job is to control the arc the tool takes, and not push on the wood.

The other trick is to turn the lathe off when entering or exiting the smaller openings with the boring bar -- it's pretty easy to nick the mouth of a vessel and create a design opportunity.

The forces I've experienced are very light, except in finish turning the inside of a hollow form that was turned green, and has now air-dried (and hardened quite a bit). The trick there is to make tiny cuts till it's round inside again. Blow-ups can occur if there are cracks in the wood that are subjected to the pulses and vibrations that come from re-rounding a thinner form.

Because the forces are so well contained and limited by the hardware (when set up correctly), the operator can relax and concentrate on the forms more than the forces. This can lead to a certain carelessness, so cutting through a vessel can happen -- measure often, and be sure to adjust the laser for each part of the curve.

As Sean points out (I think it was Sean) one big safety factor is that the operator can work very comfortably toward the tailstock end, well away from the line of fire, and escape the dangers of exploding wood.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT