Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

yikes, the Woodsmith podcast #7 *LINK*

Posts

yikes, the Woodsmith podcast #7 *LINK*

#1

yikes, the Woodsmith podcast #7 *LINK*

John K Jordan

>After watching the sharpening video by Brian Simmons (mentioned earlier), I decided to watch his earlier bowl turning video.

Almost immediately, he teaches a very dangerous technique - how to cut a small log on the bandsaw CROSSWISE, starting by cutting through the unsupported round leading edge of the log section. Cutting unsupported wood with a bandsaw is a disaster waiting to happen and can result in bent blade, damaged bandsaw, and missing fingers. I was surprised to see this in a training video for beginners. Ack!

I'm sure an observer can point out unsafe things in my practices as well (and perhaps yours), but this one seems blatant to me.

For those unfamiliar with the hazard, the blade can catch the front of the rounded edge and force it downward, rotating the log section forward and forcing wood violently into the blade. If you want to experience this for yourself, do it on someone else's bandsaw (not mine) and keep your hands well out of the way!

In the case of the video, the mass (and inertia) of the relatively long log section doubtlessly worked in Brian's favor, as did the slowness of his cut and the softness of the wood. A v-block, but while this works great to cut through a dowel or small blank turned round (say for a box), but this is not always reasonable for a large or uneven log section. It can be done safely by wedging the log section in the front AND the back. Some people hot glue wedges to the log, but I find it sufficient to jam appropriate wedges under the log. I can usually find suitable wedges in the scrap box, but I'll cut them to fit if needed.

A few minutes after the bandsaw segment he describes getting long shavings from "shear scraping", defining the term, it appears, creatively. I think I'll wait and watch the rest tomorrow.

JKJ


Podcast #7

Re: yikes, the Woodsmith podcast #7 *LINK*

#2

Another Good Example

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>of why we need to be very careful about getting advice from forums and the internet in general. Anyone can answer our questions and make a video. I know anyone can also write a book but that takes more time and money. :-)

The computer is a wonderful thing. I have received the blessing of making many friends and obtaining a wealth of good information. Thanks for posting the warning about the dangerous practice. I hope no one gets hurt after watching the video.

Re: yikes, the Woodsmith podcast #7 *LINK*

#3

Re: Another Good Example

Dennis Barley

>While exploring the Woodsmith podcast collection, I stumbled upon a gentleman demonstrating picture frame construction where is cuts rabbets in VERY small pieces of wood on a table saw with his fingers riding the piece all the way over the blade. I'd guess there was about a half inch between his fingers and the blade. Not a push stick or fingerboard in sight. Yikes.

Re: yikes, the Woodsmith podcast #7 *LINK*

#4

Re: yikes, the Woodsmith podcast #7

JohnKyler

>You would also hope he would wear safety glasses...

None were worn on his corrected part of the video.

Having been involved in some videos too, things do get forgotten.

Although I would hope safety items would not be overlooked.

John

Re: yikes, the Woodsmith podcast #7 *LINK*

#5

Re: yikes, the Woodsmith podcast #7

JohnKyler

>Also want to add, the video is otherwise well done, and informative, and he is a good presenter.

Re: yikes, the Woodsmith podcast #7 *LINK*

#6

Liability?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>John,

I took a peek at the video and totally agree, yikes indeed. I also agree that we all are guilty of bad habits but the difference is that we do not make educational videos and represent ourselves as "experts" as was the case in the podcast.

I wonder if somebody made an educational video and represented it as expert advice (as Woodsmith did) if they would have any liability issues? Seems to me if somebody watched that video and followed those methods and got hurt they might have a course of action? I dislike our litigious prone society but it seems like teaching dangerous methods with power tools would be an invitation for trouble.

Tom

Re: yikes, the Woodsmith podcast #7 *LINK*

#7

Re: Another Good Example

Peter Hyde

>After watching the first 10 minutes I gave up. Not only bad safety issues but a lot of bad information in general. Obviously not a "professional" There is nothing worse than a self taught amateur spreading the word. I would think if someone got hurt using this bad info there could be some big legal fees for a good lawyer.

Re: yikes, the Woodsmith podcast #7 *LINK*

#8

Re: Liability?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I too watched par of the video; I quit when he started putting the log through the bandsaw. There were at least two other pieces of poor information before that point. Contrary to what he said, Anchorseal does not prevent moisture loss; it slows it down. He also suggested leaving the logs out in the rain which is something I would never recommend unless the end result desired was rot or at the best spalt. I know it is not piratical to bring logs under shelter but actually suggesting this is good is asking for trouble.

Teachers have been held responsible in the courts before for teaching dangerous practices. The editor repeatedly says Brian is an expert. He also says that they are "presenting the best woodworking information on the web". Additionally he says that it is "the kind of information found in Woodsmith.".

I don't approve of all the litigation our sue happy society has taken into the courts. However if that video is an example of what Woodsmith is presenting then I am very surprised no one has sued them yet.

Re: yikes, the Woodsmith podcast #7 *LINK*

#9

Re: yikes, the Woodsmith podcast #7

Robert Lalonde

>Yikes is right. I learned this one the hard way some years ago.

Having said that, let me offer a safer way of using a band saw to crosscut a log.

1). Make a "sled" like a table saw crosscut sled from two pieces of 3/4" plywood about six inches in height and 14" long screwed together at 90 degrees along their long edges.

2). Mount a runner underneath it perendicular to the long edge to fit slugly in the slot on the table. Leave it an inch or so longer than the distance from the slot to the blade. Run the jig through the saw to size it properly.

3). Use at least two hardened 3" to 4" drywall screws to screw the log to the verticle section of the jig leaving a length of the log off the base to the left equal to the diameter of the log.

4). Push the sled with the log secured in place slowly through the saw holding the jig and log far to the right of the blade.

4). You can make a corresponding jig to rip the sectioned log in half or to re-saw logs for lumber. Do this by mounting the runner along the length of the sled instead of across it.

This works in most cases and seems safe to me but I don't know why anyone would use a jig like this one over a chain saw unless the turner did not own one.

Re: yikes, the Woodsmith podcast #7 *LINK*

#10

Dick Hines

Re: yikes, the Woodsmith podcast #7

Dick Hines

>I di not put a sound card in my new computer and I am glad I did not. If this guy cuts his hand off I don't want to hear the screams.

I did not watch the whole thing but as far as I am conserned this is bad information. Some one is going to get hurt if they follow this information.