Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

keeping holly white

Posts

keeping holly white

#1

keeping holly white

John K Jordan

>Got some large sections of holly log today (14"+) from a tree cut Saturday. I'm cutting it into turning squares for boxes, finials, etc. and coating the end grain. In the past, I had good luck (beginners luck perhaps) in keeping some holly white as it dried. However, I got some from another person and it was streaked with gray.

Any advice on keeping it white as it dries? So far I've heard to keep air moving across well-stickered wood stacks.

JKJ

Re: keeping holly white

#2

Re: keeping holly white

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I think part of the staining problem with Holly is where it grows. The reason I say that is I have never had any stain unless I left it out in the weather. Years ago a cutter brought me a pick-up load of holly in the summer when I was terribly busy at the sawmill. I cut the small logs into slabs and stickered the chunks in the old indoor racetrack. There is a good flow of air in there but not enough to keep fresh cut stickered pine from molding overnight with fans blowing on the stack. Summer can be very hot and humid. The wood stayed white.

Several years ago I had the good luck to custom saw the largest holly I have ever seen. It had some really huge branches which he was not interested in. I cut the branch wood into bowl blanks (18"), immediately rough turned them and did the alcohol soak. The Holly did not blue at all. So rough turn the blanks ASAP and do the alcohol soak protocol.

This subject has fascinated me. I hope many people with a wide geographic distribution respond.

Re: keeping holly white

#3

Re: keeping holly white

john lucas

>I haven't had very much holly but my feeling are that you need to cut it up and store it immediately. The wood that I did this to seemed to stay white and the wood that sat for a very short while had grays. I can't say for sure that it was there before hand but it since the rest of the log that I put in my shop stayed white that is my assumption.

Re: keeping holly white

#4

Re: keeping holly white

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>In your first sentence you refer to cutting it up and storing it. You mean you cut it into turning blocks and keep it in the shop?

The wood that "sat for a very short while had grays". Sat where? In log form, outside?

So the log that you put into your shop stayed white? Is your shop heated? What time of year was it?

The way of handling Holly is very interesting to me. It seems to sometimes be very difficult to keep white and sometimes not.

Re: keeping holly white

#5

Re: keeping holly white

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>I think you are proceeding in the right direction, John.

Getting it cut and stacked somewhere dry with air flow is the best approach. You've got the temperature working in your favor at the moment. Not much fungal growth when the temps are below 50.

My understanding is that the most important factor in keeping holly white is to get the surface moisture down as quickly as possible. If I remember the numbers correctly, there is not much fungal growth below 40% MC. I could be off by several percent, though. Of course, you want to watch for checks and not dry the stack too quickly once you get the surface moisture down.

Gary

Re: keeping holly white

#6

Re: keeping holly white

john lucas

>Barbara This was not large holly so I cut it up into 4x4 or 3x4 lengths and stored them in the shop with the ends sealed. The shop at that time was a basement that I only heated when I was there and it was very moist.

The other wood ended up on the ground our stacked on other logs outside. That was a disastrous method. I now store my wood on concrete blocks off the ground and in the shade. I still get some discoloration and checks but not anywhere near as bad as in direct sun setting on the ground.

My new method that is so new I don't have any results is to cut the wood into lengths or bowl blanks and coat the ends with wax instead of endgrain sealer. For bowl blanks that i want to keep green I coat the whole thing with wax. I'm using an electric skillet to hold the wax which limits me to 11". I plan on playing with this and endgrain sealer for the next year in a somewhat loosly controled test. I'm going to try to coat one half with wax and the other half with endgrain sealer and see how it goes. I'll do the same on pieces that are cut into squares. I'll coat the ends of some with wax and some with sealer.

Re: keeping holly white

#7

Re: keeping holly white

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Thanks for the clarification John.

Re: keeping holly white

#8

fungus

John K Jordan

>If fungal growth is the big issue, and if fungal growth starts on the surface, perhaps applying some kind of anti-fungal agent to the surface would help. Nip it in the bud, so to speak.

JKJ

Re: keeping holly white

#9

Re: I have somewhat limited experience.....

Jamie D

>... with holly, white dogwood, and a few other white woods over the years, and I found that roughing to size and a quick dip in a mild Clorox solution (maybe 5~10%- I use the glubb glubb measuring method!)really reduced the fungus/spalting that discolores the wood as it continues drying.

Re: keeping holly white

#10

It Only Seems That Way

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I have done that with pine in the summer. I used to use a fairly expensive product that kept the surface nice and bright. The only problem is that the stain does not only develop on the surface. That nice bright pine was blue under the surface past the penetration of the product.

Re: keeping holly white

#11

What have you found successful?

john lucas

>Barbara you probably have far more experience at this that I do. What have you found that works? Storage of wood has always been a problem for me. If I cut the wood into bowl blanks and Staves I don't really have the place to store them or the time to turn them. The bowl blanks often fail or at least I lose an inch or so. I've been pretty successful with the square staves (probably the wrong word) but I have very limited space to store those.

My wood is currently stored on pressure treated lumber on top of blocks in the corner of the yard that only gets sun in the late afternoon. That seems to be working 100 times better than the old location in my driveway on the ground with at least 1/2 day of sun and probably more wind. I've been sealing the ends with endgrain sealer and if I have time I split them through the heart.

Re: keeping holly white

#12

Re: keeping holly white

Carole Valentine

>Barb, as you know, this fascinates me as well. I have tried a lot of different things: cutting into billets and soaking in a Clorox solution before putting in storage; freezing; boiling; etc. The Clorox kept the outside white but there was blue staining inside, which indicates to me that it is not surface thing. Freezing kept it white, but it checked when it thawed - I think a very slow thaw is necessary. Boiling worked well on some small billets, but not on the larger ones which says to me that the heat did not get high enough in the center of the wood to kill fungal spores (or whatever it is that causes blue stain.) Since the stain appears throughout the wood, not just on the outer layers, and on Holly harvested in some areas and not others, I am almost convinced that it is caused by something the tree absorbs through the soil.

Re: keeping holly white

#13

different stains? *LINK*

John K Jordan

>>That nice bright pine was blue under the surface

>past the penetration of the product.

With spalting, the fungal spores start on the surface, usually at the end grain, and "grow" down the cellular structure, while "sticker stain" starts on the surface at the side grain where too damp and works its way into the wood.

If you applied a fungicide to the surface of the pine and the interior still changed color, I wonder if that means spores were already throughout the wood, say, put there by some growth process. Or is there a type of stain that is not based on fungus, more like the blue or black perhaps caused by ions from embedded metal?

I just searched and found this on the Wood Web concerning holly stain (also in link below):

http://www.woodweb.com/knowledge_base/Holly_Staining_Fungus_or_Pigment.html

Read the last comment.

I saw other entries in the Knowledgebase about holly, one indicating some stain may be from minerals. That might explain why holly from one area may discolor while another may stay white. And if there are indeed multiple causes for staining in holly (fungus A, fungus B, injury, minerals, etc.), I can understand why experiences vary so much. (And why pure white holly is so expensive.)

BTW, the Knowledgebase has lots of information on staining, search for stain.

http://www.woodweb.com/KnowledgeBase/KBPP.html

JKJ


Holly staining

Re: keeping holly white

#14

Re: What have you found successful?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>If I have something that is really good I will cut it up into blocks, put two coats of AnchorSeal on the ends and one on all of the other cut surfaces and put them in one of the stalls with sticks in between. They will not stay good forever. I will sell, give away or turn if I have time. If they stay a long time they will crack. Then I have to decide if I should throw them away or keep until the cracks make using them impossible.

I often will leave large logs or logs that I hope will spalt outside. I don't have storage for logs.

Holly I rough out as soon as possible and soak in alcohol, especially large and or cut in warm weather.

Re: keeping holly white

#15

Re: keeping holly white

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>It seems as I remember that some type of gray is allowed by the hardwood grading rules. This is different from blue stain and appears in the center of some logs. I have seen very little of this.

Re: keeping holly white

#16

Re: different stains?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I have also had pine treated with the fungicide sticker stain under the treated surface. It didn't show up until the wood was planed. The surface looked just fine.

Re: keeping holly white

#17

Dick Hines

Re: keeping holly white

Dick Hines

>Carole that holly log you gave last year lay in the drive way months before I did anything with it. There was very little staining. I did seal the ends.

I guess if it is going to stain it is going to stain. I don't care what is done to it.

Re: keeping holly white

#18

Re: keeping holly white

Carole Valentine

>Dick, as I recall, that chunk of holly came from another area...closer to Richmond I believe.

Re: keeping holly white

#19

Re: keeping holly white

mike smith

>Guys, I have sawed holly for over 10 years and my take is that if you are lucky enough to get it to stay white---you are just lucky. I have air dried outside, under shelters, frozen in self-defrosting freezers, had it dipped in fungicide at commercial mills, and I do not remember what else I might have tried. Some pieces come out white and some have blue or gray stain on the surface and/or on the inside.A lot of the commercially available comes from Pa and is cut and vacumn kilned the same day and I have seen it and sometimes there is stain in it. I am convinced that it is fungus related. After all, when I saw wood I am seeding fungus spores on the wood as all these spores are in the air. Here in eastern NC, I do not even try to mess with it unless it is Dec, Jan, or Feb. There are just too many days of 70+ to make it work. And just one other thing, my white may not be your white. We all probably have different views about how white white is. Lightly stained may look pure white beside blackwood but the light staining would show up more beside a piece of , say, grey stained maple. From everything I have read and experienced, nobody really knows but the first to develop a sure fire process will be one rich dude.