Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

I have had it !!!!!!!!1

Posts

I have had it !!!!!!!!1

#1

I have had it !!!!!!!!1

Barry ......... on Saltspring

>Ths is it. I have had it, the dust control in my shop is out of control. My cheapo dust collector doesnt, and sounds like 747 to boot. My cheapo rigid air filtration is quiet, but dust is in one end and outthe other ! I hate my north rubber over the nose respirator, particularly in the warm summer months, so out the door they are going. My shop is small, so noise is a issue. My wife tells me not to be so damned cheap where my lungs are concerned, she writes the cheques, so here we go!! I am thinking of the general 1 hp dust collector, noise rating 52-62 DB filters down to 1 micron. I am thinking of the jds 750 air filtration unit, 3 spd, remote control, filters to 1 micron. I am thinking of either the TrendPro powered respirator, which is about half the priceof the 3m airstream. I understand the 3m model is better, and should be for half the price!! Sadly I have to buy these with Canadian dollars which are current 84 cents American. So are there other options, do any of you use these products, am I heading in the right direction ?? All comments greatly appreciated.Tia

Barry

Re: I have had it !!!!!!!!1

#2

JL

Re: I have had it !!!!!!!!1

JL

>OK - I'm not familiar with General's Dust Collectors. I wasn't aware of any that had that low of a DB rating. Anyway - to get that sort of filtration with a DC, you probably have to have a canister unit.

Generally speaking if you are going to be utilizing any sort of duct work, you'll want a more powerful unit. I use a 2 hp cyclone, but I've got ~65 ft. or more of ducting and I'm collecting from several locations (not all at once). If you are willing to put up with the noise (70-80 dB), you can get a small single stage unit to tow from machine to machine. If you want to have the ability to put the DC in a sound deadening enclosure, you'll need a more powerful machine that can pull on a bit of ducting (1.5 hp or better).

As far as the JDS, that's a good unit and may serve you well.

I don't use the Trend or the Airstream. I rely on my dust mask and my cyclone. My cyclone is powerful enough to grab just about anything. I just use my mask as a backup.

Re: I have had it !!!!!!!!1

#3

Re: I have had it !!!!!!!!1

Norm Smith

>JL, I have a 2 hp. King which does not do the job that I thought it would. Busy Bee has come out with a new 2 hp. cyclone model # C139 that appears to be a good machine. I talked with them and they told me that they have sold about 10 so far but I couldnt get the name of someone that has one. However, I believe that a Cyclone is the answer.

Norm

Re: I have had it !!!!!!!!1

#4

Busy Bee Link for Cyclone

Norm Smith

>http://busybeetools.ca/cgi-bin/picture10?NTITEM=CT139

Re: I have had it !!!!!!!!1

#5

Grrrr. link didnt work, Google Busy Bee Tools

Norm Smith

>

Re: I have had it !!!!!!!!1

#6

Re: I have had it !!!!!!!!1

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

>Go for at least a 1500 cfm collector with a large canister filter. If you have the cfm, duct work looses won't be a bother. The rest of your list looks good. Penn State Industries has a nice unit for around $450.00 and they have a silencer for $80. that cuts 40 DB of noise. I just take out my hearing aids and don't worry

Good luck

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

Re: I have had it !!!!!!!!1

#7

Re: Grrrr. link didnt work, Google Busy Bee Tools

Ken

>I have the trend and love it,one of the best investments I made.As for dust collecter, I got a 1 hp delta at lowes two yrs ago and it was the 2nd best investment I made,I am not sure about the specs on it,but it does a fantastic job.Its around 270.00

Re: I have had it !!!!!!!!1

#8

Re: I have had it !!!!!!!!1

Barry Irby

>I built a little closet outside my garage workshop and putt he DC and Air Compressor in there. That was a great move. My son says getting them out of the shop was the best thing I ever did to the shop. Now they are so quiet I have to listen for them to be sure they are running. an advantage is you can sue a cheap coarse filter that allows for better air flow and the crap is gone, out doors. (The dirty secret about canisters is that when they get dirty they seriously restrict air flow. They get dirty in minutes if you are sanding.) I have a Delta 1 1/2hp unit and paid about $270 for it. Not sorry I went for the bigger one. Would rather have a cyclone, but did not have the bucks.

It's the really fine stuff that will kill you. I'm working on a down draft table for sanding.

Go to Bill Pentz site for Info than you want. I lost all my bookmarks so just google bill pentz.

Re: I have had it !!!!!!!!1

#9

Re: I have had it !!!!!!!!1

Ralph

>Barry

You've gotten some good advise so far, here is my additions, for what ever they are worth.

A good DC only helps with sanding (for lathe work), it really doesn't help with turning. That being said, they can be a good thing.

As to King, Busy Bee, General, etc. I dono, I have a Delta that is no longer made.

To really protect my lungs, I have layered protection: 1) I were a Trend Face mask 2) I have a whole shop air-filter (in my case 1 micron from ShopFox) and 3) the DC

Between them I not only keep my lungs clear, but my shop doesn't get as dusty either!!

But looks like you have a ferry ride in your future; I would suggest

KMS over in the lower main land, House of Tools, Island Woodturning, and maybe a quick trip south to Grizzly.

Been a long time since I was on Saltspring, even though I go up to Namino about monthly

Re: I have had it !!!!!!!!1

#10

Re: I have had it !!!!!!!!1

Fog Tanner

>I have a bag unit that I bought for some hand sanding - which is about all its good for - moves the dust from where I am at and dumps it in another area of the room. I have a 2hp Onedia cyclone unit for the powered equipment. I have metal ductwork run to everything, including the lathe. It is submicron (.3), which is what you need for you lungs. If you go with a cyclone, do a lot of reading - they are not all the same. Some measure airflow with no restrictions so their CFM ratings are higher. But put some pipe on them and they will drop about half. This is typical for most of the cheaper bag units. There are also some cyclone units that do this, so best to do some reading first.

I also have a Powervisor, which is similar to the Trend or the Trend is similr to the Powervisor since the Powervisor came first. Neither is good for the dust that is harmful, both are for nusance dust - which is also the same dust that your body will filter out. I replaced the Powervisor with an Airstream. It cost more but is good for .3 microns and my lungs are a lot happier. I can turn woods which I am allergic to, like Cedar, Oak, and Elm, with no problems now.

If money is tight, go with the Airstream. I use both the Airstream and Onedia when turning - except for wet woods, then I leave the cyclone off. When turning dry wood, I can see the stream of dust coming off the gouge or scraper going into my collector hood. What it missed is caught by the Airstream. You are likely closer to the source of dust than your dust collector hood, so it is best to protect yourself first. The Airstream has the air pickup at the back of the helmet and away from the source. The Powervisor and Trend are up front and personal with it. While the Airstream is more expensive, it is much less than a lung transplant.

Good luck with your problem, I went through the same thing before my wife told me to just buy the equipment. I was loosing three days at a time from sinus headaches after turning. Over a year's time that easily paid for all the equipment - plus I am not in pain for three days as before.

Fog

Re: I have had it !!!!!!!!1

#11

Re: I have had it !!!!!!!!1

Fog Tanner

>Forgot to mention, I am only 8 feet away from my Onedia and can still hear my music -which is 12-15 feet away. When I get time I am making a simple muffler for it to make it even quiter, just haven't needed it so it is low on the priority list. But it is no where near what my bag unit is in sound levels or frequency. Sounds like air moveing and not a vacum cleaner...

Fog

Re: I have had it !!!!!!!!1

#12

Re: I have had it !!!!!!!!1 *LINK*

charlie belden

>Might want to look into ClearVue's cyclone line

www.clearvuecyclones.com

They're making Bill Pentz's cyclone design in clear, shatterproof plastic. Bill knows a LOT about dust and dust collection and came at the design from an engineering/science perspective - with an eye on practicality. He had a lung problem that kept him from woodworking - or even visiting his mom in LA. So he was motivated to come up with something that would let him return to woodworking - and he's also working on getting the air in California cleaned up enough to allow a visit to LA.


Plenty of info on dust collection

Re: I have had it !!!!!!!!1

#13

Re: I have had it !!!!!!!!1

bowlman

>You may want to check out the 2HP dust collector from Steel City. I purchased one a couple of years ago while demoing at the annual Woodworking show that tours the country. Paid for it on Friday with the understanding that I would get a pretty good discount (they save on shipping it back, etc.). Waited until Sunday just before closing to pick it up. It is a bag type, but it is a 1 micron or less bag. I whack it with a strong dowel each day just after I turn it on to knock off some of the "cake" on the inside of the bag. The noise level is still there, but I am looking into building a muffler. Putting it outside the shop is not an option since the shop (my garage) faces a residential street and SWMBO has vetoed that plan anyway.

PS. Get a remote control and place the pendant on your lathe with a strong rare earth magnet. That way you can turn the DC on when you need it (while sanding) and off when not. Also, the 3M Airstream is the single best investment you can make for your lungs ... just remember to WEAR IT!

Re: I have had it !!!!!!!!1

#14

Steel City..

Ralph

>There is actually a dealer in Victoria

Re: I have had it !!!!!!!!1

#15

Re: I have had it !!!!!!!!1

Fog Tanner

>If you have a good dust collector that has good airflow and a working collection hood, it will help with both turning and sanding. When I use a gouge, I can see a stream of fine dust coming off the tip into the collection hood. The same when I am using a scraper and taking fine cuts. This is on both spindle and facegrain work.

With the sinus issues I have, I run the cyclone anytime I am turning dry wood. Facegrain or endgrain, both produce dust. Especially Walnut and Cedar, either one will give me a three day sinus headache without any filtration.

Fog

Re: I have had it !!!!!!!!1

#16

Re: I have had it !!!!!!!!1

Barry ... on SaltSpring

>My thanks to all who responded to my post, I will breath easier by the end of the month !!!!!!!

Barry