With the help of George Van Beynen in Wisconsin, I have finally removed the "beating" part of the McNaughton coring tool from it's use! It's amazing what an 1/8" here, slight angle there, and a little bit more speed can do...
Steve
BTW- I found a new definition of the word IRONY:
Take a beating working out the kinks of the McNaughton and finally get a 6" core out. Finish turn the inside and outside to 1/8" and reverse the bowl in my Cole Jaws. Freshly sharpened gouge for turning the chuck tenon off, and notice that the tool rest could be slightly higher then BLLLLLAAAAAMMM! Notice that the nice thin bowl is now at least 10 pieces (still haven't found them all)
So much for saving that core...
Re: Two Bowls from one blank (Sorry Richard, couldn't
Re: Two Bowls from one blank (Sorry Richard, could
Barry Irby
>Steve, I posted a response to your troubles with the coring system, mostly commiserating and griping about my experience. Let me see if I can actually be helpful.
I found the thing to be somewhat intimidating and slightly scary. So I was trying to go real slow. That was a mistake. The lathe needs to be turning faster than I thought. Maybe 800 to 1000 RPM (maybe faster). I'm turning on a Nova DVR and that speed gets up into the sweet spot where it has more power, you get some momentum from the blank itself and it seems to help clear the chips better.
The blade needs to be nearly perfectly level. And the tip needs to come right to the center for the shaft. Yow can set it up using a drive spur and run the knife in so that the butter comes right to the point.
In spite of what they said, my knives were not properly shaped. They MUST be a section of a circle. I drew a set of concentric circles on a piece of heavy card board and laid my knives on them. The middle sized one was fairly close, but the others were way off. They may have been ellipses, but they were not even close to being circles.
Think about what the knives are doing. They are cutting a kerf and the blade is followign in the kerf. If they are not a circle they can not follow in their own kerf unless you wallow it out enough to make room and that defeats the purpose of coring.
After my friend and I rebent them to conform to a circle, they worked MUCH better. I am still no Mike or Bill. I would like to compare the ones they have to mine. Mine were so out of round that they would start burning the walls of the cut and if you were not careful they would cook and crack the blank.
My other problem is that my tendency is to hold down on the handle. You really should let the system do the work and if anything hold slight upward pressure on the handle.
I also labeled mine with the inner and outer diameter after I got them cprrected. That helps a lot.
The blades are soft steel and bend easily.
Re: Two Bowls from one blank (Sorry Richard, couldn't
>I use a piece of plexiglass that is about twelve by six. (as large as you larger blanks.)
Mark the center of one of the long edges and clamp it between the jaws of the chuck. Put the center mark at the centre of the chuck/shaft.
Using a dry erase marker, mark off you bowl. Just the large diameter and the depth. Draw on the profile of the bowl if you want. Now, choose your cutter and slide it right under the clear plexi. You can watch almost exactly how the cutter will move. Lock the tool rest. Install the actual blank and have at it. Gives me a huge amount of confidence.
Re: Two Bowls from one blank (Sorry Richard, couldn't
>I think most of what you said mirrors what George and I dicussed. I'll core a few more tomorrow just so that I am sure that I have the procedure down, but it took an hour to do the first one, and about 5 minutes to do the last one... so I think I'm on to something!
S
Re: Two Bowls from one blank (Sorry Richard, couldn't
>Sounds better. I think I can coire an 8 or 10 inch core out of a ten or twelve inch blank in about five minutes cutting time after setup.
Part of my problem is I was going for the max. Wanted four or five core out of twelve inch blank. Much less stressful to go for two or three until you get the geometry down pat. Good luck.
Re: Two Bowls from one blank (Sorry Richard, couldn't
I've also found that widening the kerf a bit helps a lot. This is another version of not pushing the limits of the tools. maybe if mine were bent to true circular arcs this would be less of an ittue?
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
Re: Two Bowls from one blank (Sorry Richard, couldn't
>is your best bet, dry wood is a lot harder, and always a sharp tool, as Brad said, widen the kerf and withdraw often, that clears the shavings and lets the tools dissipate heat, lots of heat generated, coring a locust blank for a nested bowl commission, it got so hot as to make the tool blue, ended squirting water in there...
You'll get it, your bowl production will remain more or less at the same level, but slowly and surely cores will accumulate and then you will wander why you made them in the first place, they burn well!