Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Vicmarc Lathe

Posts

Vicmarc Lathe

#1

Vicmarc Lathe

Steve Harris

>I would like to see a review on the Vicmarc 300 Long-bed lathe, and perhaps a comparison with some of the other top-of-the-line lathes.

Thanks,

Steve

Re: Vicmarc Lathe

#2

Re: Vicmarc Lathe

JohnKyler

>My brother has one and is happy with it. But For the money and if he had the choice today, he says he would buy a PM 3520b. The PM was not available to him when he bought the VM. But looking at both machine and the fit and finish, I too would take the PM.

I have the PM 4224 and it is the smoothest lath I have ever run.

Also I hear that PM is throwing in the 18" bed extension with new 3520b lathes sold this quarter.

JMHO

John

Re: Vicmarc Lathe

#3

Re: Vicmarc Lathe

Brent English

>Steve, if you have your heart set on a big FIXED headstock lathe, the Vicmarc 300 is an excellent choice. I'd choose it over the PM 4224 or the Oneway 2436. Look at the spec points and the prices, and it will be an easy choice. Both the Craft Supply and authentic Australian version of the Vicmarc will work well for you. Get the 3HP while you're at it - you'll like the extra power and it will increase your resale value

If you want a sliding headstock lathe, which is my personal preference, then you have another whole discussion....

Re: Vicmarc Lathe

#4

Re:An what would that be Brent?(;-D)

Jamie D

>

Re: Vicmarc Lathe

#5

Re: Vicmarc Lathe

Fog Tanner

>I have had a Vic 300 long bed lathe for several years now. I looked at the PM 3520, 4224, and Oneways before going with Vic. One of the things I did was contact a number of professional turners and asked their opinion. Only one used a Oneway, none used a PM and the rest all used Vics. This is the machine they depended on to make a living.

I have the Australian Vic, not the CS version. There are a number of differnces. I have used both and prefer the Aussie version. The tool post is 30mm (about 1 3/16") and is rock solid, the CS version is 1". I like the stand much better than the CS version. One of the reason I don't like using a Oneway is the splayed legs, which is what is on the CS Vic. I have also used a PM and didn't care for working around the headstock either. The bed on the Vic allows you to work around the headstock with no problem. It has a 2 foot foot print, but only a 5 degree slope in the front and about 15 degree in the back. There is also a built in "chip chute" on mine, which directs shavings out the back instead of piling up on the bed. The lathe also rests on top of the bed and does not have the legs bolted to it. This helps quite a bit in the solidness of the machine.

The motor and drive on mine are a bit better than the CS version. My drive came programmed like Raffan's, it does not break. Raffan had some input on the design and he stops everything by hand. After using it, I much prefer that method vs the electronic brake of my other lathe. It can be programmed for electronic brkaing if you really want that.

I have not stalled mine yet but have seen the CS version stall. I have a McNaughton coring system and have no problems at all on my Vic. I have cored 22"-23" blanks with no problems, plenty of power and I have the 2hp version. In talking with Mike Mahoney, 3hp isn't enough for him. He had Vic build him a 300 with a 5hp motor in it. He doesn't really need to change pulley settings. Mine has 3 "ranges", with the lowest being a 3:1 ration. That is what I use for coreing and larger bowls. But, I have forgotten and cored several 22" bowls on the high setting. So instead of coring at what I though was 600rpm, was more like 1200...but the shaving really flew out - must be what Mike uses, looked a lot like his video.

The one thing I don't care for on the Vics being imported now is the "remote" or moveable switch box. Mine has the controls in a fixed location (same as you see on the Vic website), so starting and stopping is instinctive. After having the emergency stop bar, which is the red bar across the front, and having to use it a couple of time - I wouldn't want a lathe without one.

My longbed weighs right at 1000lbs and had no problem with vibration. I do quite a bit of eccentric and offcenter turning these days, some of it with larger pieces of wood. The weight helps quite a bit in that department. I also found that my tool work improved just by changing the lathe. I can see now why all the pro videos show them using something like a Vic or Woodfast.

Vicmarc uses tapered roller bearings, the same as you find on a truck. There is an adjustment ring that allows you to loosen or tighten the play. As the bearings wear you can take the play out rather than having to change them. My van weighs 5500lbs and rides on front bearings smaller than what is in my Vic, so I should be able to put on any piece of wood and not worry about the bearings.

I do have a 16" sliding headstock lathe and for what I do now, I would not attempt it on a machince with a movable headstock. I have unlatched the headstock twice while coring. While it was an interesting experience, it is not one I would want to repeat. But, if I were going to get a movable headstock, it would be a Robust. That is the best sliding headtsock lathe going today. There is also the Sweet 16 from Robust as well. I have seen one and it is a very well made machine which will do larger pieces, as well as longer work.I learned from buying my Vic that it is worth spending a little extra and getting a good machine, you will be much happier in the long run.

Overall, I am extremly happy with my Vic and only regret not getting it a couple of years earlier. There really isn't anything I would change on it, it does everything I ask of it. Good luck with your decision.

Fog

Re: Vicmarc Lathe

#6

Re: Vicmarc Lathe

Steve Harris

>Thanks to all who responded.

Steve