Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

OT: tree fell in backyard

Posts

OT: tree fell in backyard

#1

OT: tree fell in backyard

ILYA ZAVORIN

>Happy New Year to everyone!

I just talked to my friend who lives in suburban Maryland. He had several tall pine trees (or some sort of pine-looking coniferous trees) in his back yard. The wind has been blowing really hard for last several hours so one of the trees fell. I have two questions:

1. He wants to remove all of the pines from the property, not just the one that fell. This will be pretty expensive if he goes the "regular" tree service company route. I've heard that in some areas there are small mills that actually collect fallen trees from suburban areas and turn them into lumber. Would that be a viable option to keep the cost down in this case? Do you know any mills like that near DC?

2. The tree caused some cosmetic damage to a neighbor's house. My friend was told by a tree service company that came to make an estimate that although the pine was on his property, it's the neighbor's insurance that is supposed to cover the damages. Is this true? What would be a standard way of handling such a situation that would be fair to both parties?

Thanks much.

Re: OT: tree fell in backyard

#2

Re: OT: tree fell in backyard

arkie

>1. Pines don't generally have much value. Your friend would be lucky to find someone to take it off his hands at all, The local craigslist free section is always worth a try.

2. Your friend should contact his homeowners insurance company immediately. They'll have the particulars, and he may be covered.

Re: OT: tree fell in backyard

#3

Re: OT: tree fell in backyard

Carole Valentine

>Here in VA, if I have a tree that damages a neighbor's property I am not liable. In fact, I am not even responsible for removal of the tree from their property.

Re: OT: tree fell in backyard

#4

Also

Bill Howatt

>Lots of mills won't touch them from non-wild areas since there is a fair chance somebody has driven nails and hooks into them. Some people with bandsaw mills will cut them into lumber but if they damage their blade you buy them a new one.

Bill

Re: OT: tree fell in backyard

#5

Re: OT: tree fell in backyard

Sean Troy

>Here in my town in Kentucky, the neighbors insurance would have to cover it. I had a sweetgum branch go down in a big wind storm that went through my neighbors garage roof and with all the rain that followed, a lot of other damage followed also. I offered to pay but he had his insurance cover it anyway. Yep, we are still good friends and neighbors. If you can score some of that pine, they make perfect jamb chucks of all kinds while they are green. .

Re: OT: tree fell in backyard

#6

Re: OT: tree fell in backyard

John K Jordan

>Ilya,

You can certainly get the pines cut into boards, but you won't make enough money to make it worth while. It might be worth while if you have a fair number of quality trees and can use pine boards for something. For example, when building a horse stall I lined it with 10"-12" boards I cut on my own sawmill and it saved a bundle over having to go buy them. If you have someone come to the site and mill them, you will have to pay them. If you haul the logs to a mill, you will pay less but you have to deal with manhandling the logs which can be difficult. Often a small mill owner will saw your logs in exchange for a portion of the lumber, typically half.

You might check the exact type of tree - "some sort of pine-looking coniferous tree" is pretty vague. Get a tree ID book and grab a handful of needles and some seed cones if possible. Some conifers are better than others for different purposes. For example, most of the southern pine varieties are strong and tough, while the white pine has been too soft for horse stalls but perfect for beehives.

There is a book Harvesting Urban Timber by Sam Sherrill which you might find educational. I believe he lists some resources.

If you want to locate small mills in your area, call Woodmizer. They keep a list of Woodmizer owners willing to mill for others.

As for the insurance, my experience was a neighbor's insurance would NOT pay for damage his tree did to my property (a fence) but my own insurance did pay for my fence. I was told the neighbor's insurance would have paid if we had discussed that particular tree in advance and agreed that it was a potential hazard, but he failed to have it removed. A good neighbor will offer pay for any damage regardless and remove the tree.

JKJ

Re: OT: tree fell in backyard

#7

Same in Georgia (last time I checked)

Gil Jones

>

Re: OT: tree fell in backyard

#8

jim miles

Re: OT: tree fell in backyard

Jim Miles

>Ilya

1. A normal insurance practice is that you can't insure something that you don't own. Otherwise I could insure my neighbor's house with 10 companies and collect when it mysteriously burns down.

Your insurance will not likey cover your neighbor's loss, his company should cover it.

2. It is very unlikey that you will find anyone ( responsible ) that will cut down the Pine trees for no cost. Especially if there has been a storm and are plenty of trees down. As someone suggested you might try to find a portable saw mill operator that you pay to cut up logs and leave you with lumber to use or sell, Suggest checking with local AAW club.

PS I used to live in Rockville Md

Re: OT: tree fell in backyard

#9

I actually had ex con's living next to me

john lucas

>When I was renting a house I had some ex cons who moved in next door. They tended to stay up late and party and I'm an early nighter. One night I decided I had had enough and went over there to confront them fully expecting a fight. As I reached up to knock on the door it opened. The guy looked surprised and then said OH I'm sorry were we too loud, we'll keep it down. Boy was I relieved.