Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

How long does it take you to turn a vessel

Posts

How long does it take you to turn a vessel

#1

How long does it take you to turn a vessel

john lucas

>I was reading Fine Woodworking and looking at the Gallery page. Winfield Crans has 2 beautiful vase like hollow vessels 9" diameter by 11" tall with a large neck opening. The text says it took 40 hours for each one. Congratulations Mr Crans on some great pieces.

I haven't turned a vessel that large in about a year but I'm guessing it would take about 2 to 3 hours to turn and sand, maybe longer since you would have to sand the inside really well because you can reach inside. Then about 3 more hours total of finishing time. I realize I am pretty fast at some things although I know the people who do hollow vessels all the time would do this in about an hour or a little more.

I guess I'm a little out of touch because I turn so much. I'm wondering how long it takes you all to turn a bowl or a hollow vessel? I know when people come over to my shop to turn a bowl it's not unusual for them to take 4 or more hours to do it. A hollow vessel that size would probably take a full day. So I could easily see it taking about 20 hours, but 40 seems awful long.

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

#2

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I don't do hollow forms, but I have done bowls in the past. A 6" diameter bowl takes me about 20-30 minutes to turn and sand, including blank preparation, and about 15 minutes to finish.

My first bowls took hours to turn and finish. My speed improved significantly after I'd turned a couple hundred bowls.

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

#3

Steven Antonucci

Bowls and vessels

Steve Antonucci

>Bowls- I can knock out a bowl in 10 minutes if I am "trying to knock out a bowl in 10 minutes". Usually, an hour sufficient, but not all contiguous.

If you account for the time in the field dragging a tree out of the woods, sectioning and stacking to dry, cutting a round and roughout, more drying, final turning, finish sanding and finishing- then I don't know if it's still an hour. But it's still not 40 hours either...

Hollowforms take 2-3 days, depending upon the size, opening and wall thickness. I rarely make them big enough to stick your hand into, so interior finishing is not an issue...

My best guess is that I can crank out an "almost done" bowl in 15 minutes, and a "pretty good" medium sized hollowform in an hour or two... but I usually take longer!

Steve

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

#4

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Bowls and vessels

Lyle Jamieson

>I can give some light on the subject. Alone in my shop I can hollow a christmas orniment in 41 seconds to 1/8 wall thickness. Thats a bit of bragging I know but I just did 100 of them and made a game out of it cause production work is not my thing. Using the supported boring bar and laser to guide me it was fast and easy...after 20 or 30 to get warmed up.

A standard size hollow form 7-8 inches tall with a 2 inch mouth should take less than an hour to hollow with the supported system and laser again. The bigger it is, the thinner it is, the smaller the entry hole is, the longer it would take.

Most of MY time and energy is on the outside of a hollow form. Getting the color, grain, flaws, natural edge and shape just where I want it can be quite time consuming. But 40 hours has to be a bit of a stretch. Five hours would be a stretch. I suspect thats what he tells prospective buyers at the craft shows to justify the price. If he really takes that long he could use some help with better tools and process. Some self taught people dont realize how much fun and how easy hollow form turning is nowadays. Lyle Jamieson

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

#5

Re: Bowls and vessels

john lucas

>I certainly agree with you. I built a system using the plans from your website and it certainly makes hollowing more relaxing. Using the captured bar I hollowed the center portion of my Cardiac lamp to 1/4" thickness in about an hour or less. This section was about 12" tall. Yea I know I've seen John Jordan hollow by hand and do vessels that large in about an hour but then he has a few years on me. I think I have about 20 hours in the whole cardiac lamp project, most of that time was in carving the heart and making the Electronic Defibrillator.

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

#6

Re: Bowls and vessels

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>If I'm turning a 4 x 4 HF with a small opening in a demo and have an hour and half, I can do it okay. The small opening means no sanding inside. I can even add a collar. That's providing that the wood gives me no problems. When I do it in a demo I sand the first couple of grits and that's more than enough dust. In my shop I'll take longer because I'm more particular about getting the form as perfect as I can. (The perfect form is very elusive).

I seldom do HF's that have a large enough opening that I have to reach inside to sand. That adds quite a bit of time.

Wally

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

#7

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

Barry Irby

>I saw that and thought about it, but made no comment. My son saw it and commented the guy must be really slow. I hope Lyle is right, he just says that to justify the price. Nice looking work, but way too much time.

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

#8

Re: Bowls and vessels

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>I've been doing lots of mini hollow forms in the 2 1/2" x 2" range and have gotten to a point where I can complete one in about an hour, hand held, including sanding, but without a finish. I've just gotten a new hollowing system and have found that I can do a 6 x 6 form with a 1" opening to about 1/4" in about two hours. That does not include finishing.

keithz

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

keith tompkins

>Hey John, I think I know that guy!!We have a club member named Win Crans...how many turners have that name? Was he from New York?

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

#10

Yes it says he's in Kingston NY

john lucas

>

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

#11

It doesn't matter how long it takes,

john lucas

>It only matters that you do it. We have a lot of discussions about using cutting tools vs scrapers, start sanding with 60 grit or 220 etc. What really matters is that you create something with your own hands that you are proud of. If you need to use refined techniques or you do with flint and steel it really only matters to you.

When it's all said and done 50 or 100 years from now and someone sees the vessel, the only thing that will matter is what it looks like then, not how you got there.

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: It doesn't matter how long it takes,

keith tompkins

>Yep, He's the one!! I agree with you John, it's great to be able to turn pieces out quickly, but far too many turners focus on quantity rather than quality. I've taught a class titled "Turn a Masterpiece" several times now; the idea was to completely focus on just ONE piece...combining good design with good technique to complete the best piece the student ever turned. A couple of the students initially balked about the idea, but one turner finally admitted he turned over a hundred bowls in the previous year, and wasn't happy with a single one.

I get to hang out with a few members of the FWW staff when I teach in Connecticut; according to them, the odds of having your work published in the magazine are slim to none...as I remember, about 1 in 10,000 photos is selected! It seems that Win may have taken too much time to complete the pieces, but he's got some serious braggin' rights now!

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

#13

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

John Jordan

>As I tell people when I doing demos and they ask how long it would take me in my shop-"You've just seen me do it, just take that time and subtract the BS" It usually comes out to about ten minutes.

A 6-7 inch piece, an hour, a 11-12 inch piece 3 hours. Really big pieces have a LOT of wood, become a bit slower for a lot of reasons, but still within an easy day. Like Lyle, I spend as much time as needed on the outside, the inside is pretty quick. Simple tools, simple techniques. Anyone that has ever watched me knows that I don't ever get in a hurry, the lathe never even gets over 900 rpm. I finish fairly quickly because each cut that I make, or each step accomplishes something. It's a DELIBERATE process. :-)

Those simple hollow pieces, (which I rarely do), will require an hour or two after turning if they are simply sanded, just to sand, detail, finish etc. My carved pieces often take a LOOOOONG time, but not always.

What slows most people down is using too many different tools instead of learning one, crappy wood, and lack of a step by step approach. A modest sized piece should not seem like a career move, even for a beginner.

I turned an 8 inch walnut piece today for Woodturning Mag. in about half a day, screwing around with photographing the process, and trying some new photo techniques for live shots. I took at least 200 photos and went through some of them on the computer.

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

#14

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>John, One of the things that is still burned in my mind after taking your class at ACC is how relaxed you are when you're hollowing. Something that many of us white knuckle. It's a very conscious effort at first, I think, to learn to relax while hollowing, then the process becomes much more efficient and quicker. I'm not sure hollowing will ever be a pleasurable thing for me. Making the hollow vessel is fun, but the actual hollowing is not something I dream about and look forward to. Like Clay says, there's a reason they call it a boring bar.

Jen

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

#15

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

Chip in Plano

>I estimate my fastest was about 20 hrs of chuck time from log to finish skipping the time in the DNA bucket and the extra days afterwards for final drying. My longest is about 2.5 yrs and counting. Until I got a captive HF setup, I hated hollowing. I'm still a white knuckler but it's getting better as I use the laser more effectively. More time effecient, too. But I still make dumb mistakes so I always turn slower than I like.

....close enough to Krum the Republic of Texas to remember Clay's famous line and the accent to go with it. Happy New Year.

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

#16

jim miles

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

Jim Miles

>I saw that and wondered about it. I suspect part of the picture is that most of the pieces of furniture take many hours to make, If a beautiful vessel only took 3 hours to make FWW might not take it seriously. I have watched for several years the turnings that FWW selects and they probably are not the ones that experienced woodturners would pick. And besides, they haven't picked anything I have sent in.

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

#17

Re: Damn, you guys are fast.

Russ Fairfield

>Everything I turn in 20 minutes looks like that was about how long it took.

You make me think of the pen turning ads of 10 years ago that said -"Turn a pen in a minute and a half". I couldn't do that either.

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

#18

Lyle Jamieson

Re: It doesn't matter how long it takes,

Lyle Jamieson

>I like your take on it John L. It does not matter how you get there. I met a student out in California a few years back that was doing these large platters shaping them with a heavy duty auto body disk sander with 17 grit sanding disks. The finished product was wonderful...no undelations. Its all about the fun. If you are having fun for 40 hours, thats OK. Its critical to pay attention to the details and not rush the process. But I stand by my statement that getting some help and having good tools, good tool control, and an efficient process, will translate to a lot MORE fun. Lyle Jamieson

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

#19

Ditto:

john lucas

>

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

#20

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

Clay Foster

>When people ask me how long it took me to make something, my standard answer is "55 years." I'll soon have to change that to 56.

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

#21

Keith Tompkins

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

keith tompkins

>Hey Clay, I'll be 56 in January as well! It's gonna be a good year!

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

#22

jim miles

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

Jim Miles

>I just made 55 at Christmas time

My standard answer at shows is " it took several hours to make and 20 years to learn how to do it" That usually get a laugh and ends it.

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

#23

You guys are young wipper snappers -60 in Sept.

john lucas

>

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

#24

Ha!...Buncha Kids......

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>

Re: How long does it take you to turn a vessel

#25

Re: Ha!...Buncha Kids......

Don in Ellensburg,WA,

>Walley It has gotten so bad around here I don't start any long term

series of turnings as do not want mrs to have to clean that much more out of shop. Have make sure list of tools is utd for resale

so she not get ripped off. Neighbors get the chainsaws and left over logs.Am planning to shut things down in another 20 years.

or just turn pens after that.

Don