>To err is human - so most of us - occassionaly - make mistakes. I prefer the term OOPS! And when they happen - it's what you do then can be interesting. Attached is an example - somewhat tongue in cheek.
>My example comes from a walnut HF that I cracked. I was impatient withdrawing my tool from the HF inside before the lathe stopped spinning. Thwack !!....and a vertical crack formed 3 inches long. The piece had already given me plenty of trouble from the start but I decided I wasn't going to scrap it. So, I scribed a line around the HF at the bottom of the crack, got out my Dremel and spent 45 minutes dimpling the top of the HF....then I gilded it in copper. I had never gilded anything and needed the practice. I still need to patina the copper.
>Charlie I'm working on saving an OOPs right now. Fortunately it turned out to be more of a modification than a total oops but it made me reconsider what I was doing with the piece. I added a lot of texture to it after the carving. Now I'm trying to decide on the colors. It will have some color and some natural wood.
>OK - so we've got some OOPS examples and some ways to hide the OOPS - carving, texturing, piercing, coloring. gilding and patination (which sounds more refined than patinaing).
Turning an OOPS! into a feature is relatively easy - in turnings - less so with solid wood furniture. Not much pyrography used on furniture and carving is pretty much limited to shells and scrolls, acorns and maybe a flower. So far I haven't seen any epoxy and crushed stone inlay, texturing or much piercing either.
But turning - there are a million ways to hide things. So recovering from an OOPS! - assuming the piece didn't disintegrate - is wide open. Hell, even a piece that disintegrated can be reassembled, preferably in some unrecognizable way, and be considered a feature.
The key to making an OOPS! into a Feature and the results transformed into a Piece (of ART) is to imply intent - "I MEANT to do that - and here's why.". THAT is where the Title and Artist's Statement come in. I think this is where THE ART comes in.
Think in terms of inductive logic vs deductive logic.
With the former, you start with the conclusion and then go find data to support your conclusion. In the case of turning a PIECE, you start with the concept you want to convey to the subsequent viewers, then find techniques and wood that will translate that concept into a wooden object. Here the idea is to translate your concept into wood - with or without Post Lathe work. This approach can start with the Artist Statement - "What do I want this Piece to convey?", or the Title of The Piece - Moon Rise (over ____, pick a place), Tranquility, Visceral #4, Ritual Vessel (leaving What Kind Of Ritual? up to the viewer's imagination), Fall In Vermont, etc.
With the deductive approach you work the other way - you start with data and conclude their relationship. You start with turning something, fix any mistakes - or hide them, maybe do a some additional embellishments to hide the "fixes" - and then come up with the "I MEANT to do that" - the concept for the finished object. And this is where The Title and The Artist's Statement come in, used to explain, preferably by implication, just WHY you did what you did - intentionaly.
Either approach can turn a turned piece of wood into a PIECE. But the Deductive Approach leaves you a lot more "creative" room - AND - doesn't necessarily require that you spend a lot of time developing the turning skills and techniques required by the Inductive Approach.
So where are the titles and the artist's statements to go with the OOPS fixes / transformation to a FEATURE?
>I'm gonna stop sniffing CA 'cuz I'm not following you Charlie but I'll dive into the deep end with you. In reference to my copper top piece, is it your assertion that I should have assigned it a Title and provided an Artist's Statement? By your definition of inductive vs deductive, my piece follows the deductive definition. I never started out with 'I'm gonna make this a piece of art' when I mounted the raw log on the lathe. But when I cracked it, I was pissed for about 10 seconds...but I was immediately flushed with ideas. I dang sure wasn't going scrap it even though I felt the wood was possessed with an evil spirit given the number of problems I encountered. The crack wasn't even the last problem. Even trying to sell it was chaotic.
I had never carved nor gilded a piece up to that point. I had bought a gilding kit several months earlier but hadn't worked up the courage to try it out on a piece. I didn't know what I was doing. I just did it. What was gonna be a pudgy wild-grain Texas walnut HF completely transformed.
I could give it Title. The artist statement would be more difficult because I don't feel like I'm at the artisan level, yet. Clay Foster has wonderful Titles and Artist's statements.