Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Photo help

Posts

Photo help

#1

Photo help

Paul Zerjay

>This piece of red bud is very shiny. How do I get rid of the two hot spots, and the reflections from the front of my photo tent?


img

Re: Photo help

#2

Re: Photo help

Steve Worcester

>Are you using a tent or something to diffuse the light?

Re: Photo help

#3

Re: Photo help

John K Jordan

>Paul,

Soften the light. Sometimes you can use a layer of two of tissue or white cloth between the light and the subject. Another thing is to aim the lights away from the subject and bounce it back with a white surface. If the lights are to the side of the photo tent, moving them back can help. The object is to diffuse the light and spread it out more.

BTW, I generally don't mind a highlight on a shiny piece, but I don't care for two highlights evenly spaced. But regardless, it's quite an elegant piece!

JKJ

Re: Photo help

#4

Re: Photo help

Texian

>Agree with John K. One highlight shows that you have a glossy finish and may give you a little shadow which can add depth to the photo. Just turn off one of the lights and see if that helps.

Re: Photo help

#5

Re: This is an excellent example of .....

Jamie D

>.... why I advocate the use of a single light source, resulting in a single highlight rather than these headlights. A single highlight is necessary to show that the surfaces are shiny. Shining multiple lights thru the sides of an enclosure is more problematic than bouncing a single light around inside an enclosure, and all the other room lights outside the enclosure must be off.

Re: Photo help

#6

Thanks Jamie

Paul Zerjay

>I was hoping you would respond. I'll try your technique tomorrow and post the results.

Re: Photo help

#7

Re: Have you checked out the......

Jamie D

>...Phrugal Photo info posted here on WC- I've forgotten exactly how it's filed, but it's also on my website at JamieDonaldsonWoodturner.com under the tips menu.

Re: Photo help

#8

Re: Photo help

John Jordan

>I'm surprised no suggested a circular polarizer. It allows you to dial most of the reflections out-you would probably have one softer highlight on that piece. You can see the result in the viewfinder/screen as you turn it for best results. If you don't have a threaded lens, you can rig it on.

I always use it. :-)

John

Re: Photo help

#9

Re: Photo help Pic

Bruce McElhaney, Spring Lake, Michigan

>Circular polarizers can also degrade the image and and distort colors. IMO, A better solution would be to use one diffused frontal light source and position it for miminual reflection. And, as previously mentioned one soft highlight is less objectionable than two or more. It is also easier to remove in photoshop if desired. See example below on one frontal softbox light and one overhead accent light. . .unretouched.


img

Re: Photo help

#10

Re: retry on photo

Bruce McElhaney, Spring Lake, Michigan

>Sorry 'bout the photo


img

Re: Photo help

#11

Re:A circular polarizer can only .....

Jamie D

>....be used on an SLR and costs well over $100 for a good one. To be most effective, both light source and lens filters must be used together, and you also lose about 2 f stops of light. They're more trouble and costly than the possible benefits to be gained.

Re: Photo help

#12

Re:A circular polarizer can only .....

john lucas

>Everyone is somewhat right and somewhat wrong. Jamie is correct in that a circular polarizer is easier to use on an SLR but it can work on a point and shoot if you have a way to hold the filter in front of the lens.

A good quality polarizer will not degrade the image. You can get flare if you don't have a good lens hood or way to block the light off the filter.

A polarizer will sometimes work on glossy subjects and sometimes it won't. It depends on how the light is reflected off the subject. It will sometimes work if the lights are at the side or the rear of the piece. It's always worth picking it up and rotating it to see if it does do any good. If it doesn't do use it.

Polarizing the light source works great if you are using direct light and a polarizer on the lens. If you are shooting through a light box it might not because the light is no longer polarized. The same is true for bounce light. However it is worth trying. Sometimes it will fool your. The large polarizing filters from Porters.com are kind of expensive as well as the Glass filters.

I have a PDF file that I can send anyone interested in how to shoot really glossy turnings. It is sort of a short study in problem solving and is good reading even if you don't make really glossy things. Just send an e-mail to above address and remind me what I was going to send.

Re: Photo help

#13

Re:A circular polarizer can only .....

John Jordan

>I would disagree with every point there, Jamie. :-) It would take care of the problem he asked about, particularly with the suggestions about softening the light.

But then I'm not a photographer, but it makes a big difference for me, including the heavily textured pieces. I wouldn't use it if it didn't do what I want.

John

Re: Photo help

#14

Re:A circular polarizer can only .....

john lucas

>Heavily textured pieces need a harder (smaller) light source to create tiny shadows that show off the texture. There are different types of light. A large soft box light that's far away will produce the same light that a small reflector light will do up close, both would create a highlight the same size but the edges of the reflector light might appear sharper. The reflector light will bounce off the subject differently than a diffused light. This is why the polarizer will work with some lights and not the others.

The polarizer will usually remove some of the glare on the reflected light but won't usually work with the diffused light. However it does depend on the direction of the light. If you think of the light direction as a Billiard shot, any angle greater than 90 degrees from the light to the subject to the camera, will be polarized in some fashion depending on the surface of the wood. In this case the polarizer will usually work. Sometimes the polarizer will work when the light is at a lesser angle but usually to a lesser degree.

A polarizer is an incredibly handy tool but it doesn't always remove glare. It depends on the lights, the direction of the lights, and the surface quality of the piece. It's always worth putting a polarizer in front of the lens and giving it a try. It just might remove some glare. It does absorb light so you will have longer exposures.

Re: Photo help

#15

I wish I knew what you guys were talking about

Paul Zerjay

>Cause this aint helping me one bit

Re: Photo help

#16

ReYou may disagree from.....

JamieD

>.....your perspective John, but that's why I made my living as a photographer, and you as a woodturner. A polarizing filter has no effect in softening light, unless the filter is very dirty! The polarizing effects can only be viewed thru the taking lens, such as on a SLR, and are not visable or controllable when used on a rangefinder type camera. The neutral density filter factor is also variable as the filter is rotated, making critical exposure compensation possible only when the metering is calibrated thru the taking/viewing lens of a SLR. A good quality 52mm multi-coated circular polarizing filter costs between $100~400 and I certainly don't see the minimal benefits being worth that price! Not much you can disagree with here!

Re: Photo help

#17

Re:Paul- just keep it simple!

JamieD

>

Re: Photo help

#18

Re: ReYou may disagree from.....

John Jordan

>Right, and I rarely take exception with someone's turning methods. If I put his little piece in front of my camera set-up, the glare on the left would go away, and the glare on the right would be lessened. That's all I've said.

Of course my filter's not dirty, and yes I use a SLR. And one more time-it's a HUGE help to ME. I guess ignorance is bliss. :-)

John

Re: Photo help

#19

Re: I wish I knew what you guys were talking about

john lucas

>Paul We got off the deep end. What you can do first is to move one of the lights further from your booth. this will change it from a spot type highlight to a larger softer edge highlight. If you move the light far enough away it will light the the whole side of the booth of even the top and side. This produces a fairly even light on one side.

Of course if you piece is extremely glossy (think almost glass finish here) then it will see the booth and possibly you as well.

What I usually have my students do is to set one light up high about 45 degrees so is is lighting one side and the top. Then place the other light (if you need it) on the other side but place it lower than the first one and move it further away so it isn't as bright. This will ideally give you one hot spot on one side and a very large softer hot spot on the other side which looks more natural.