Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

bansaw and chainsaw

Posts

bansaw and chainsaw

#1

bansaw and chainsaw

clay rose

>what size bandsaw should a person get in order to handle all or most blank sizing jobs? any recommendations... brand names? user experience?

also for chainsaws, what size saw is appropriate for the cutting of both large and small logs,limbs etc. to size

Re: bansaw and chainsaw

#2

Re: bansaw and chainsaw

arkie

>I gather from your post that your experiences with either are limited. I'd suggest a 16" chainsaw as a good size for a first saw, and 14" Jet or Delta as a good size bandsaw. That size bandsaw will hold it's value well. A 12" bandsaw might be okay if you get a real bargain on it.

Once you've used either for a bit, you'll know if you need to make changes, and what direction.

Re: bansaw and chainsaw

#3

Re: bansaw and chainsaw

Ken Ward

>As for the bandsaw,either of those would be a good choice,but I have heard a lot about the Ricon 14" and it seems to be a very good choice.As for the chainsaw,I would get the best you can aford.if you can't swing for one of the high dollar saws,then a 16 or 18" poulin would serve you well for small work.

Re: bansaw and chainsaw

#4

Re: bansaw and chainsaw

John K Jordan

>Clay,

My experiences:

I have two chainsaws, a small Stihl with a 16" bar and a larger with a 24" bar. I far prefer the smaller saw for most work, being easier to start, lighter in weight, better balanced, and I think safer. I only use the larger saw for large logs - it's just plain too big for most of what I do. (BTW, I've had some cheaper brands, but after years of using Stilhs I see a distinct difference in quality.)

I have two bandsaws, a 14" Delta with a riser block and some performance upgrades, and an 18" Rikon, stock. While the Delta is a great saw and I've used it enough processing turning blanks to wear out a few dozen of blades, the larger Rikon is a far better saw for this use. While the capacity to cut thick pieces is the same for both, the Rikon has more power and can handle a larger and more aggressive blade. I can work much faster with the Rikon. With the 14" Delta, I often felt like I was pushing and sometimes exceeding the limits of the saw.

JKJ

Re: bansaw and chainsaw

#5

Re: bansaw and chainsaw

Barry Irby

>I agree with John. I have two Stihl saws as well and the smaller one gets more use. There is also a cheaper small saw here and I did not even count it because the only way I can get it to run is to take it to the saw shop and have the guy tune it and start it. Then MAYBE it will start later in the same day.

I also have a 14" Delta bandsaw with a riser. I bought it because it was all I could justify. I did not have mare than about $600 at the time. Since then I have added a Carter blade release, dust port, band rollers, new spring, alignment washers and more. Probably added $300 to the cost of the saw. In hindsight, I would have been better off to have bought a bigger more powerful saw that had all the features. Mine only has a 3/4hp motor and you have to baby it to cut thick green blanks. And the table is about he size of a dime. a bigger table would make handling heavy blanks a LOT easier. You end up putting "chocks" or wedges under blanks to keep them from shifting as you cut, but as you turn the blanks on a small table the chocks fall off the edge.

I could fix both problems by installing a 2 hp motor and building an auxiliary table. But again, I should have just bought a saw that had all that from the beginning. I feel like I bought a starter kit. A big saw will do everything a small saw will do and more.

Re: bansaw and chainsaw

#6

Lyle Jamieson

Re: bansaw and chainsaw

Lyle Jamieson

>I have a different twist. Buy a good chain saw and save your money and forget about the band saw. Unless you have many thousand $$ to spend on a band saw they do not work well for turning blanks. And more importantly they are dangerous to use. Ask around and see how many turners have had close calls or worse on a band saw. A band saw is not designed to cut THICK, or WET wood, and add the uneven shapes to the risk, and you are looking for trouble. I never use a band saw for turning blanks. I have a safe secure place and method to get the turning blanks square cut to size with my chainsaw and I use the lathe to round them out. The lathe is safer and a lot more fun than a band saw.

Another issue for me is control. I want to keep the control of the color, grain and character of the wood. I sneek up on it while turning away the waste as I adjust the axis. I dont want the band saw to dictate or even influence the axis, shape, or scale of my turning.

I hope to have an article about roughing out turning blanks done for the AAW journal in the next couple months on this neglected subject. There is a lot more to it than most people realize. I want to do it fun, I want to do it easy, and I want to do it safe. Lyle Jamieson

Re: bansaw and chainsaw

#7

Re: bansaw and chainsaw

Ken Ward

>Have to dissagree with ya on the bandsaw Lyle(sorry)but I have a 12" Delta that I have been cutting bowl blanks on for about 3 yrs.I get my blades from Highland tools,that are made just for cutting wet bowl blanks and maybe its just me,but any turners I know and have seen there DVD's on recommend using a bandsaw to cut there blanks.As for Chainsaws ,I have been using them for about 40 yrs and have seen more folks messed up using them than I care to think about,but have never seen a serious accident with a bandsaw and I have had more blades break than I can remember.

Re: bansaw and chainsaw

#8

Re: bansaw and chainsaw

Barry Turner

>I have an older Delta 14" bandsaw, actually I believe it had the Rockwell brand when I bought it. It works fine although I wish for a larger bandsaw at times, maybe a 20" Powermatic.

On the chainsaw issue, I compromised. I have a Stihl 361 with a 20" bar that is wonderful. This purchase came after years of frustration trying to use lesser borrowed saws; Poulan, McCulloch and Homelite. I'd never go back.

Re: bansaw and chainsaw

#9

Re: bansaw and chainsaw

Steve Worcester

>Interesting, I would have gone with a bandsaw as a must have and a chainsaw as a next in line. Personally, I think the chainsaw is more hazardous than the bandsaw. Both will accomplish the same task, sort of.

It really depends on needs and pocketbook. Buy as good of either as you can afford. A 16" bar on a chainsaw that can take a larger bar is better, Stihl or Husky would be preferred brands for me. Bandsaw brand is touchy, almost religious. But buy one with at least 12" resaw, and a large motor.

Re: bansaw and chainsaw

#10

Re: bansaw and chainsaw

Adrien

>I'm with Ken on this Lyle. Whacking corners off an irregular chunk of wood on the lathe can be hairy. An electric chainsaw can help; but being able to round off a piece on the bandsaw is a big help.

Any power tool can wreak havoc with human anatomy. Fortunately I was wearing gloves when I tried to amputate my thumb with a Lancelot on an angle grinder so that damage was minor.

When I got my Rockwell bandsaw, I was lucky enough to get a riser block at the same time. The 14" height has been most useful 'cause the original height would've been useless for green wood blocks.

I've only had one gas chainsaw: the Stihl has stood the test of time.

Re: bansaw and chainsaw

#11

Re: bansaw and chainsaw

John K Jordan

>I can't imagine woodturning without a band saw. (unless perhaps turning is limited to certain things or with blanks prepared by others)

Re: bansaw and chainsaw

#12

Re: bansaw and chainsaw

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryu+MBDi+0MX0Pf5O9---

>My solution is different from the others: I use a Laguna HD 16 band saw with the Laguna CircleMaster attachment. It's basically a massive circle cutting jig that allows cutting a cylindrical blank as large as about 12 inches in diameter and as high as your band saw will go. The main thing is that it allows such a cut to be done in a perfectly safe way because the wood is clamped between centers -- like a vertical lathe. I will admit that I had to do a lot of modifying and fooling around to get the Circlemaster to work on the HD 16, for which it was not designed. Of course, for outside cutting of big logs and such , you can't beat a

Sthil chain saw. Also, you might want to spring for a cheap electric chain saw for smaller work in the shop.

Re: bansaw and chainsaw

#13

Lyle Jamieson

Re: bansaw and chainsaw

Lyle Jamieson

>Hi All, This is a great thread. Lots of good points have been addressed. On the safety issue, I prefer to have the sharp tool in my hand (chain saw). Rather than have the sharp edges facing me and my fingers (Band saw). Hands and fingers can get sucked into the blade in a split second. Is a broken blade an accident, a violent dangerous event?? Both take some experience and instruction to be used safe. Once you understand the safe way to use a chain saw its hard to get hurt.

I use both gas and elect chain saws but never the band saw unless I am using flat lumber for things like finials or pens. I dont cut my bowl blanks round or even cut the corners off. That would be hard and difficult with a chain saw. I put the square tree on the lathe and get it round on the lathe to be in control longer. I dont want to give up my control to the band saw. Ill race anybody out there...you go to the band saw and I go to the lathe and lets see who gets it round first. But more important who is having more fun. I am fortunate to have a big swing lathe. The unstated issue here is those folks that are trying to turn large things on a small lathe and dont have room to spin square corners to rough them out. I dont think this is a good idea either cause that pushes the envelope to what the small lathes are engineered to handle. Scale is not all that important. A sweet shape at 7-8 inches can have a bigger impact than a larger turning where the shape is comprimized due to the scale jump. The tool control we have nowadays allows us to rough out a square blank with fingertip control and no stress on my body so why not use my lathe skills when I can.

Another unstated issue. I have seen many very experienced students trying to hack away at a tree with a dull chain saw chain. I sharpen my chains after about every other use, very frequently. Another thing to add to the learning curve, but very simple, and easy, and quick to do at home with a simple $3.00 chain saw file. The results of hand sharpening is better than most sharpening shops will do.

I dont press my case or argue my point here to state my process is right and others are wrong. Just a different approach not right or wrong, different ways to get the job done. For the newer turners looking in, it is great for them to see different points of view. Lyle Jamieson