Re: bansaw and chainsaw
Lyle Jamieson
>Hi All, This is a great thread. Lots of good points have been addressed. On the safety issue, I prefer to have the sharp tool in my hand (chain saw). Rather than have the sharp edges facing me and my fingers (Band saw). Hands and fingers can get sucked into the blade in a split second. Is a broken blade an accident, a violent dangerous event?? Both take some experience and instruction to be used safe. Once you understand the safe way to use a chain saw its hard to get hurt.
I use both gas and elect chain saws but never the band saw unless I am using flat lumber for things like finials or pens. I dont cut my bowl blanks round or even cut the corners off. That would be hard and difficult with a chain saw. I put the square tree on the lathe and get it round on the lathe to be in control longer. I dont want to give up my control to the band saw. Ill race anybody out there...you go to the band saw and I go to the lathe and lets see who gets it round first. But more important who is having more fun. I am fortunate to have a big swing lathe. The unstated issue here is those folks that are trying to turn large things on a small lathe and dont have room to spin square corners to rough them out. I dont think this is a good idea either cause that pushes the envelope to what the small lathes are engineered to handle. Scale is not all that important. A sweet shape at 7-8 inches can have a bigger impact than a larger turning where the shape is comprimized due to the scale jump. The tool control we have nowadays allows us to rough out a square blank with fingertip control and no stress on my body so why not use my lathe skills when I can.
Another unstated issue. I have seen many very experienced students trying to hack away at a tree with a dull chain saw chain. I sharpen my chains after about every other use, very frequently. Another thing to add to the learning curve, but very simple, and easy, and quick to do at home with a simple $3.00 chain saw file. The results of hand sharpening is better than most sharpening shops will do.
I dont press my case or argue my point here to state my process is right and others are wrong. Just a different approach not right or wrong, different ways to get the job done. For the newer turners looking in, it is great for them to see different points of view. Lyle Jamieson