Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

DESIGN: Aesthetics and Survival Instincts (long)

Posts

DESIGN: Aesthetics and Survival Instincts (long)

#1

DESIGN: Aesthetics and Survival Instincts (long)

charlie belden

>Aesthetics and Survival Instincts (long)

A guy standing on a sidewalk asks a passerby to hold his paper cup of coffee so he can tie his shoe. As he takes his coffee back he shows the good samaritan a photograph - it can be of a man or woman, doesn�t matter, the faces in the photos are all basically expressionless - and asks if the good samaritan has a positive or negative first impression of the person in the photo. The photo and the question are all the individual has to go on.

If the cup of coffee was hot, the response is almost always positive. And if the cup of coffee was cold, the response was almost always negative. Warm is good, cold is not good. That�s the first impression/instinctual relationship.

This guy happens to be a brain researcher and his research indicates that the same part of the brain that interprets temperature input also deals with some primitive associations/ judgements. Warm is good, cold is not.

When you think about it, there�s a very good reason for Warm Is Good, Cold Is Not Good, at least for mammals - specifically very young, helpless and totally dependent, mammals. You see, when the ambient air temperature is less than the newborn�s body temperature, the newborn must generate heat to make up the difference, less so for the reverse situation where the ambient temperature is higher than body temperature. So, when it�s cold, getting close to something that is as warm or warmer than you is a good choice - if you want to save energy and use it to survive and grow rather than to stay warm. But more important than maintaining body temperature, nutrients are required to survive and grow. Warm things are more apt to have accessible nutrients than cold things.

For newborn mammals, it�s advantageous to start out with a built in preference for warm over cold - survival depends on it. And survival also is supported by associating Warm With Nutrients.

The brain of mammals are all �hard wired� with some basic survival instincts. And given that brain space is limited by physiology, multi-tasking brain space and locating similar brain functions close to each other also makes sense.

It is reasonable and logical that the part of the brain associated with judgement should contain some basic, typically unconscious, survival instinct preferences in its core, other judgement functions built around it. The ability to pick out outlines of objects from their surroundings, to detect color differences, to judge size - and mass, to differentiate between stabile and unstabile - these all may mean the difference between surviving - or not. Surviving takes precedents over everything else. OK, so procreation may have a higher priority - but even it is about the species surviving taking precedent over the individual surviving.

Perhaps much of the human sense of aesthetic - for shapes, proportions, colors, textures, tastes, smells, sounds, etc. are, at their core - before cultural influences - unconscious - instinctual - hard wired in all normal human brains. Is this what successful �artists� tap into - at a subconscious, instinctual, �brain stem� level set of preferences?

Have fractals and Mandebolt functions combined with computer algorithms and digital displays of colored images generated based on these functions already begun producing �art� most humans find aesthetically appealing?

Will brain research reveal more of why we prefer This over That. And if so, at some point, will �artists� become extinct, or more correctly, will the term �artist� become meaningless as computer algorithms begin producing what we now think of as �art�?

OK - so let�s apply this idea of subconscious, survival instinct, aesthetic to turning.

Think about turned pieces you find interesting / attractive / appealing. And think beyond �Oh I LIKE that one!�. Think about what it is about that piece that, at a subconscious level, may touch on something instinctual that could affect your survival - or the perpetuation of the species.

The shape of the familiar champagne glass is said to be based on the shape of Marie Antoinette�s breast. A Queen Ann leg - does it have the curves of an actual calf, ankle and foot?

Why is an Onion finial attractive, or a gourd shaped hollow form more appealing than an angular, facetted form?

Why are �warm tones� pieces more apt to be bought than �cold tones� pieces?

Why are pieces with well blended curves more attractive than pieces with interrupted curves with �flats� between them or noticable �edges� where they come together?

Smooth surfaces on turnings seem to have more appeal than textured surfaces. Given the choice, would you buy a smooth fruit or a wrinkled one?

When smooth and textured surfaces are combined in a piece, does the contrast increase the focus on the smooth, and thus the appeal of the piece?

Is the answer to any or all of these questions related either to survival, either the individual or the species? If so, how can you use that information when working out your next piece?

Just wondering.

Re: DESIGN: Aesthetics and Survival Instincts (long)

#2

Re: DESIGN: Aesthetics and Survival Instincts (lon

john lucas

>I'm still working on the flight or fight thing. The rest is too deep for me.

Re: DESIGN: Aesthetics and Survival Instincts (long)

#3

The Womb

Carole Valentine

>

Re: DESIGN: Aesthetics and Survival Instincts (long)

#4

Re: DESIGN: Aesthetics and Survival Instincts (lon

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Basic survival instincts and patterns are deeply rooted. But there is layer after layer after layer of teachings and personal experiences on top of them. Add in individual variation and aesthetic appeal will be all over the map.

The time-tested traditional shapes are as close as you are going to get.

Re: DESIGN: Aesthetics and Survival Instincts (long)

#5

Re: Will there be a test?

Jamie D

>

Re: DESIGN: Aesthetics and Survival Instincts (long)

#6

Want Your Beer Warm or Cold?....

Wally Dickerman

>

Re: DESIGN: Aesthetics and Survival Instincts (long)

#7

Re: Is there a full moon ??

Russ Fairfield

>

Re: DESIGN: Aesthetics and Survival Instincts (long)

#8

Re: DESIGN: Aesthetics and Survival Instincts (lon

Bob_Macgregor

>I wonder if the psychologist did the study in the winter? If you did the same study in, say, Caracas (or Dallas in mid-July) on a hot day with a cold/warm soft drink, would the results be the same?

BOB