Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Question, kind of OT but not really...

Posts

Question, kind of OT but not really...

#1

Question, kind of OT but not really...

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>Ok, drawing in the depth and breadth of knowledge in this forum i am asking this:

If matter is composed of atoms, a smudge of activity forever in motion, wriggling this way and that, How it comes that the edge of our tools remains sharp?

Jorge

Reading a fascinating book about life and science of Richard Feynman, the most outstanding american physicist.

Re: Question, kind of OT but not really...

#2

Re: Question, kind of OT but not really...

Bruce Forrest

>I think the answer lies in the fact that "sharp" is a relative term. Under high magnification, even a sharp edge will appear to be fairly pitted and rough. The higher the magnification, the worse it appears.

What macroscopically appears to be very even and therefore "sharp" is microscopically still quite uneven.

Re: Question, kind of OT but not really...

#3

Steven Antonucci

How does sharp translate to breaking atomic bonds?

Steve Antonucci

>That's an even more interesting question...

What about the atomic bond of steel makes it stronger than the bond in wood? After all, it's all just protons and electrons in the end...

And how all of this happens without causing some cataclysmic reaction that causes the end of days...

Re: Question, kind of OT but not really...

#4

JL

Chemically speaking...

JL

>Molecular and atomic motion occur in a number of ways. Wiggles, waggles, vibration, etc. But your steel is in a more or less crystalline lattice. As such, the atoms are sort of "locked" into place and prefer to remain there. The crystalline structure has "tighter" bonds than the looser structure of the cellulose fibers you are cutting.

Re: Question, kind of OT but not really...

#5

Re: Chemically speaking...

john lucas

>Shouldn't we be smoking something when we have these really deep discussions. :) Next thing you know we'll be discussing where the end of the universe is. If your planet was actually one of those moving electrons then the end of the universe might actually be the cutting edge your talking about. Wow, Man.

Re: Question, kind of OT but not really...

#6

Re: Question, kind of OT but not really...

Allen Neighbors

>I think it's because we put too much faith in scientists and what they say, and not enough faith in what is actual reality. If it's sharp enough to cut, it's not dull. I don't worry about it, and I don't care what a scientist can find in his microscope.

Re: Question, kind of OT but not really...

#7

Re: Question, kind of OT but not really...

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>If you have not seen any video of Richard Feynman, you should google him. He was so great and entertaining to watch.

There is a DVD collection of his lectures out there also. I think I saw them in BN, but didn't notice the price. I have a grand nephew that I would like to get them for. He is only in about the fourth grade, but is already ahead of the next couple of grades up. His teachers have just let him go after his own interest.

Re: Question, kind of OT but not really...

#8

Re: Chemically speaking...

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>That make sense, thanks Jerome,

I had you and Jesper in mind when I posted the question.

Re: Question, kind of OT but not really...

#9

Re: Question, kind of OT but not really...

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>Keith,

Thanks for the heads up, I'll look for them.

I already found and ordered some of his books.

Yes! Give that youth more bones to chew, best investment we can make.

Jorge

Re: Question, kind of OT but not really...

#10

Re: Question, kind of OT but not really...

GalenV

>The atoms in your lathe tool are organized under your control and like everyone they want to be the first in line so when one atom is gone from the tip the next atom is right there to jump in to be first.

You are spinning the atoms in the wood on your lathe. They are getting confused and disoriented.

Therefore when the organized atoms meet the confused you know who wins. The wood flies apart since the next atom is to confused to replace it.

My very deep thoughts.

Re: Question, kind of OT but not really...

#11

Wow, and I was only wondering

Stuart Johnson

>why if you drop one Styrofoam peanut when opening a package you are still cleaning them up a week later.

Re: Question, kind of OT but not really...

#12

Also...

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>When you are cutting something, you are cutting / prying / splitting it apart between molecules or structural units. Those bonds are very weak compaired to the bonds that hold a metal's crystal lattice together. Even a diamond knife isn't sharp enough or strong enough to mechanically cut a molecule.

Re: Question, kind of OT but not really...

#13

ROTFL

mfoster

>Got a real kick out of this thread. I have to admit that physics is a passing interest of mine, and I try to read books that let me slightly understand what the current thinking in the field is. Can't really wrap my head around the math so I don't try, but I've read a number of books written for the lay person.

So do you want to talk about strings. Or that matter is really just a whole lot of empty space with a little vibration thrown in. Or that, theoretically at least, everything that comprises you, could in the next instant be your lathe.

I think I had too much to smoke. I'm heading back to the shop to turn.

Re: Question, kind of OT but not really...

#14

I am....

Steven Kubien

>...smoking something that is and it is not helping one bit. I think I may have to visit the mushroom patch to get around this one.

Steve Kubien

-relax folks, it's all in jest.

Re: Question, kind of OT but not really...

#15

scientists

John K Jordan

>>I think it's because we put too much faith in scientists and

>what they say, and not enough faith in what is actual reality.

>...I don't care what a scientist can find in his microscope.

Without the scientists studying "actual reality", understanding and therefore improving materials comes slowly, if at all, and usually by trial and error. Without the endless investigation by scientists we might still be using wrought iron tools to cut wood and bloodletting to heal what ails us (forget MRIs and laser surgery).

The most powerful of "microscopes" ever, the neutron scattering instruments in use today, can look deep into the molecular structures of materials to reveal how they are put together, how they stay together, and how they come apart.

What can this do for the woodturner? How about the possibility of far, far better materials for harder/sharper/tougher tool edges? More efficient fuels and engines for transporting our wood? New wonder medicines and procedures for when we get sick?

JKJ

Re: Question, kind of OT but not really...

#16

He, he

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>

Re: Question, kind of OT but not really...

#17

Thanks All!

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>lots of good answers, more to think of.

Mike, I am like that too, my math muscle is long gone but the curiosity still alive, hoping to get into String Theory 101 when is offered around here, or in the web.

Jorge

Re: Question, kind of OT but not really...

#18

Re: Question, kind of OT but not really... *LINK*

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>Keith,

after some digging I came up with this:


Feynman Lectures

Re: Question, kind of OT but not really...

#19

Re: Question, kind of OT but not really...

Dale Stansbery

>Well, for me, my tools never stay sharp! So, Jorge, I guess you have nothing invested in tool sharpening devices?