>In September I introduced an entirely new hand-held coring unit for woodturning amateurs I called the BowlSaw. The response was a deafening silence! It was too new! They were afraid of it! My intention was not to disturb the "establishment" but they fiercely resisted any change in their protocol. I offered the tool to several Wood Central contributors for evaluation and received almost unanimous positive responses. I continue the challenge to any brave woodturners reading this willing to try something so new that it is judged before giving it a try. I'll send you a BowlSaw at no charge if you will evaluate it for me and tell your club friends (and me) what your reaction is--good or bad. I have an ad in Wood Central and you can also find me on the web(bowlsaw.com). Dick Steussy
I am new to turning but the bowl saw was demonstrated at our last Ames turners meeting. My comments therefore are not that of an experienced turner. I have not used any wood that I just did not turn away. Since the bowl saw appears to have depth and diameter limitations the first impression I got was it was a box saw. Even if you used a large blank that could be turned to a bowl the inner piece removed with the tool would make a shallow box.
The piece turned generated a lot of heat in the blade and I wondered how this would effect the saw for future cuts.
It did make me wonder if you had a catch where you and or the tool would be. Thinking torque limiting or break away device on the handle.
As with anything new it takes more than one experience to know if it is a valuable tool.
The company I use to work for had a unique drive for a clarifier used in municipals water treatment. The design was 50 years old but had to be "sold" to every customer on its value. When they found the equipment lasted for the same 50 years I'm sure they were happy.
Here's a photo of the smaller bowl saw in mid-cut (lathe stopped). I offered to try it out, and have only gotten to use it twice so far. Thanks to Dick Steussy for the sample. In this case, I'm coring the first of two smaller bowls from the inside of a deep, end-grain bowl in spalted Sugar Maple.
While this solves a problem I don't very often have (most of my wood is plentiful and free), it can be quite useful for turners who want to make the most of small blanks of expensive or otherwise valuable wood. The bowls cored with the smaller model are pretty small, but I think people making miniatures will enjoy this tool. I have not tried the larger model yet.
The saw blade is inserted in a deep groove and rotated CCW into the spinning wood. There does not seem to be a tendency to catch -- it just resists the CCW rotation. A larger handle without the gloss finish would probably give better grip. I may rough up the handle with some 80-grit to try that theory. I'm also trying the larger model, and will turn a bigger handle to get some added grip and leverage.
I won't get to play much till we get a reasonably warm day (20's or better) after Christmas -- my "shop" has no heat. I'll write up some notes after that.
>I am a 'newbie' at wood turning tho I seem to have lots of equipment in my shop. I have not done any REAL turning (just pens) so, if you wish to supply me with your device you will be getting an evaluation from someone who has no preconceived ideas. I have nothing but time once the weather warms up.
>I am a disabled turner who can not cut my own wood. Therefore, I am forced to buy all of my bowl blanks. This can get expensive especially when seeking the more exotic woods. It seems that coring blanks would be the way to go but most of the coring systems are so expensive. I would be most interested in trying out something more cost effective.
>Edward--Your experience with exotic bowl blanks was the same as mine--they are expensive! When I saw that most of that bowl was going to go into sawdust, I was distressed. And I wasn't about to spring for $350 for a coring unit that I had to learn how to use and which would take up more space in my workshop. That's why I spent over 11 months to develop the BowlSaw.
Like all things as new and different from the ordinary approach as this tool is, I've had enormous opposition--which surprised me. I thought (and maybe I was a bit naive) that woodturners would welcome something that 1. Saved $$ by making 2 bowls for 1, and 2. Produced perfectly matched bowls, since they were made from the same piece of wood. I was wrong. But I have some loyal supporters in several states who have tried my BowlSaw and swear by it. See www.bowlsaw.com and read the testimonial page. One woodturner from Florida had about same background in pens (doing few bowls) as you and he succeeded with the tool the first try. I'm going to send you a copy of the tool free of charge for you to evaluate. Tell your friends (and me) about it (whether good or bad). Thanks. Dick