Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're with

Posts

Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're with

#1

Steven Antonucci

Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're with

Steve Antonucci

>I've been up and down the "upgrading" my lathe to a dream lathe (last lathe, best lathe on the market...) probably 2-3 times in the past 4 years, and each time, I can't rationalize buying one.

I turn on a Nova 3000, which I've had for at least 8 years now I think, and we've come to an "agreement". It is certainly not the best lathe on the market, but it doesn't limit my ability to do 95% of all the things that I want to do on a lathe.

Occassionally, I get a big tree that I could make a bigger bowl out of, but by the time I cut away bark and sapwood, I'm usually right back at 16". Besides, drying a big bowl is really hard, and stacking them starts to take up a lot of space...

So, assuming that you've gotten past the mini or the Craftsman monotube into a relatively high quality lathe, what is driving you to the Robust, Stubby, or 2436? I've turned on 2 of the three of them, and while they are nice, I don't need one to do what I do.

Caveat: If I every win the lottery, I'd probably buy one of each for the new shop building

So, what's driving you to plunk down $4-6K on a hobby?

Steve

Re: Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're with

#2

Re: Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're

Don at Central Illinois

>I kinda with you, Steve. However, I'm currently limited to about 8" in bowls, etc. I would like to get a lathe were I could turn some bigger bowls, but I don't think I'll ever own a Stubby, Oneway or any other HIGH end lathe. I'm hoping one of these days for a medium sized mustard monster. Santa I've been a reasonably good boy this year, in case you are luking at this site. :)

Re: Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're with

#3

Re: Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're

Brent English

>Of course I have a biased opinion here, but I make the analogy that if you're into motorcycle riding, maybe you want a big full-dress Harley, or if you're into bass fishing you want a big boat with live-well, fish finder, GPS, etc.

In that regards, woodturning is the same with any hobby. You've worked hard, maybe put the kids through school, got the house about paid off and now it's time to do something nice for yourself.

Since I already own my dream lathe, I piddle my money away on a 27 Ford hot rod. I don't need it, just want it, and it brings me pleasure.

Re: Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're with

#4

Jesper, Denmark

Re: I bypass the upgrade cycle.....

Jesper, Denmark

>I bought my first and only lathe some 10+ years ago. It is a General 20" with VFD motor. The decision was based on my general(sic) principle of buying the best tool you can afford and never buy tools in kits.

At the time, I think it was $2300, delivered with the accessories I thought I needed. I have never used the outboard larger diameter turning option, but it is there and I just now have apiece of tulipwood large enough to need it.

It is not a Oneway, but then I do not see any limitation in the General that wil get in my way.

I laso later added a 20" Agazzani to feed the lathe - and have never regretted it.

I have had the same 35 foot sailboat for over 20 years, so like in most things, it was the right choice ot the time and still is.

Neither were the most expensive choice at the time, but a considered analysis of what was the best I could afford at the time.

Re: Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're with

#5

I Remember It Well My Friend

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>I remember well seeing it on the dock at Ashman's... Morris and I were looking it over, making sure it was tight and ready to go, love knowing I touched it and that it's still your pride to own..

Take care

Jim

Re: Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're with

#6

Re: Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're

John K Jordan

>>So, what's driving you to plunk down $4-6K on a hobby?

Hey, it's good clean fun and it's just money. Be thankful woodturning is a very inexpensive hobby compared to some!

JKJ

Re: Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're with

#7

I think I will keep the wife of 11 years too

Brian Simmons, Heflin, AL

>good advice.

We should all ask ourselves why before buying or changing anything.

Re: Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're with

#8

Re: Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're

Jake Dahn (SoMN)

>Some of what drives us to have the "dream" lathe is good ol' selfish pride. The bigger/better than your neighbor syndrome.

I own a general 260 which I have never used to its limits, so my want for a oneway or robust is purely that, a want/dream.

I do believe it buying the best that one can afford, because we have all used cheap tools and a lathe is no exception. They are a pleasure to use instead of a source of aggravation.

In times like this I defer to my fathers his mantra, stated partially in jest and partially true.

"If you want something bad enough you must really need it."

Will the dream lathe make me a better turner, unfortunately no. But darn, I will look good hacking on that blank.

Jake

Re: Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're with

#9

Re: Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're

Michael Stafford

>Steve, my first lathe was a Nova 3000. I dearly loved turning on it and knew it well. I did get very tired of switching belts, up to 7 times per box, but lived with it for quite a while. I know I could have spent the money for a variable speed system but that would not have allowed me to do some of the things I have wanted to do.

I have been accumulating large blanks for platters and bowls waiting for the day I had sufficient machine to turn them. So I finally bought a bigger lathe. I used no family resources as my profits from woodworking/woodturning paid for my new lathe. More than likely I will never test my new lathe's full capabilities but I love its versatility, mass and quietness. I have no regrets. I hope I do not need to purchase another lathe.

Re: Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're with

#10

Re: Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're

john lucas

>Steve I know the dream lathe post was fun but I'm like you. I have all the lathe I will ever need. I only have it because circumstances all happened at the same time. I had a friend who wanted to buy my Nova 3000, another friend was buying a Powermatic 3520A and I got a big bonus at work and a big commission job all at the same time. I had also heard that the lathe was going up in price Jan 1st so my friend and I jumped on them. I paid $2000 for the lathe. Looking at the prices now I think I did a good thing.

Re: Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're with

#11

JL

I'll be realistic, I turn spindles mostly

JL

>I've got a Jet 1642, I can turn boxes, the occasional small bowl and lots of legs. Would I like something else? Not really. I would like a bed extension though. I'd like to be able to turn a few longer things. What would I do with a Mustard Monster? I'd need a bed extension right off, so I could turn my stiles. I couldn't chuck my spokeshaved spindles in my chuck to turn tenons on the end.

I like my 1642. I'm very happy with it. I may want a smaller lathe by and by though.

Re: Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're with

#12

Re: Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're

Lan Brady

>Steve,

This is quite a different train of thought. I have no asperations to ever be a professional turner. It is purely a hobby and a stress reliever for me.

I have sold only a few turned items. Most of my projects are gifts to family and friends. I have on occasion, given items to charitible organizations. And dont forget items for the instant gallery at our club meetings. That is great fun!

On Sunday of the National Symposium in Richmond, I bought my dream lathe. It has given me much pleasure and peace of mind. I see this as being the chepaest form of mental health therapy EVER!

Other than my house or car, it was the biggest outlay of cash for single itme in all my life. But after that initial purchase, I have no money being spent. I use the same tools as I did with my smaller lathe

Would I do it again? ABSOLUTELY!!!!!

Good Luck with your decision, Lan

Re: Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're with

#13

Real cost of ownership is ......

Mike Brazeau

>Only what you are going to lose on the capital value when you move into the nursing home and sell the lathe and other bits or your kids do it when you are gone. Hopefully that won't happen for a goodly number of years yet. A statement like that from a fellow turner on the left coast inspired me to make the decision to buy a 2436. Haven't regretted it for one nanosecond. For any high quality lathe like a Stubby, Powermatic or Robust that statement holds true.

Re: Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're with

#14

Because it IS a hobby.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>The true justification for hobby expenses is "I enjoy it". It's a lot cheaper than going out to the bar every night and your head doesn't hurt in the morning.

In my case, I needed to replace my Conover lathe. The Robust was the only lathe that filled my needs.

Cost justification: turning is a hobby and the lathe has made the hobby more enjoyable. QED

Re: Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're with

#15

Re: Because it IS a hobby.

Roy Girolami------WebKitFormBoundarywFn+9eH9wAEIGq

>Steve, back in the day when I wanted to turn larger bowls, I made a bowl lathe based on articles in FWW. The main thing was the spindle and the motor, so I maybe have $200 in it. This thing must be 20 years old. Recently, I had some trees cut down and have some large pieces to turn into bowls. This wood is wet, so I am using my 20 year old homemade bowl lathe to rough out the blanks. My 3520 is left alone to be saved for the final turning after the wood is seasoned. My turning time is limited, so it is nice I don't have to spend time cleaning and oiling my lathe after each use.

Roy Girolami

Apex, NC

Re: Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're with

#16

Re: Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're

Curt Fuller

>I think you hit on what has kept me from going big time with a 'dream machine'(besides the cost), it's hard to get and preserve wood that's big enough to make it worthwile. I turn on a 55 year old Oliver 159 with a 14" swing. It's a good solid machine that never skips a beat. I'm sure I'd like a robust, oneway, PM, or any of the other dream lathes but I don't think they would make me a better turner.

Re: Antithesis of dream lathe:Love the one you're with

#17

Steven Antonucci

Oh my goodness! You pressed another hot button!

Steve Antonucci

>Clean and oil your lathe? Um, yeah me too...

Every once ina a while, I'll steel wool the ways and run a file across the tool rest. Twice a year, I spray some silicon lube on the banjo and the tailstock. Lathe maintenance complete.

I laugh when I see people detailing their lathes like they were at a car show. Mine is usually buried in a mount of shavings. I sweep quickly to avoid tracking (too much) into the house.

Steve