Close Enough - when trying a new method
charlie belden
>Earlier, I posted an Step By Step for doing a Drozda-esque inlay rimmed, finialed lidded box. Now I've actually tested the inlaid rim procedure as well as her Green Tape trick for blending the box, inlay and lid together.
Because I was trying this out on a semi-green silver maple pruned branch, I skipped the integral finial and foot. The wood wasn't that good anyway - but of a size for suitable for this experiment.
I turned the finial separate - out of blackwood.
Conclusions from this test piece
1. The parts of the instructions I used works
2. If the finial is turned as an integral part of
the lid, you can see, in context, if it's
proportions fit with the rest of the piece.
This piece brings up several questions
a. when trying something new, use less than
perfect wood rather than potentially
wasting some good to really nice - dry
- wood if things don't work out? Of course
this can result in a nice piece - in crappy
wood.
b. since this was a test piece done to verify
that a procedure worked and so it wasn't
done in the best wood, I didn't spend a lot
of time on perfect cuts, perfect finishing,
sharp, crisp details and with so-so
proportions - it's a Close Enough piece.
In a case like this, would you go for Close Enough or would you go for As Perfect As I Can Do It?
charlie belden
ps apologies for the image quality - but it's Close Enough




