Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Close Enough - when trying a new method

Posts

Close Enough - when trying a new method

#1

Close Enough - when trying a new method

charlie belden

>Earlier, I posted an Step By Step for doing a Drozda-esque inlay rimmed, finialed lidded box. Now I've actually tested the inlaid rim procedure as well as her Green Tape trick for blending the box, inlay and lid together.

Because I was trying this out on a semi-green silver maple pruned branch, I skipped the integral finial and foot. The wood wasn't that good anyway - but of a size for suitable for this experiment.

I turned the finial separate - out of blackwood.

Conclusions from this test piece

1. The parts of the instructions I used works

2. If the finial is turned as an integral part of

the lid, you can see, in context, if it's

proportions fit with the rest of the piece.

This piece brings up several questions

a. when trying something new, use less than

perfect wood rather than potentially

wasting some good to really nice - dry

- wood if things don't work out? Of course

this can result in a nice piece - in crappy

wood.

b. since this was a test piece done to verify

that a procedure worked and so it wasn't

done in the best wood, I didn't spend a lot

of time on perfect cuts, perfect finishing,

sharp, crisp details and with so-so

proportions - it's a Close Enough piece.

In a case like this, would you go for Close Enough or would you go for As Perfect As I Can Do It?

charlie belden

ps apologies for the image quality - but it's Close Enough


img

Re: Close Enough - when trying a new method

#2

Re: Close Enough - when trying a new method

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>In my opinion, a proof of concept or procedure prototype is complete once you have proved the concept or procedure. There is no reason to do any more to it. It is time to move on and do the real thing.

Of course I have a biased opinion. In a previous life I was in R&D and we made and used an awful lot of prototypes. Most of them weren't pretty, but they did their job and that was all that mattered.

Re: Close Enough - when trying a new method

#3

Re: Close Enough - when trying a new method

Ken

>Gotta go along with that,quit while your ahead and I think you have a very nice piece.Don't see how it could be much better.

Re: Close Enough - when trying a new method

#4

Re: I find it to be true among many ......

Jamie D

>......turners, especially those new to the process, that every piece should be a "keeper!" As we refine our processes and designs, we understand that not every piece is indeed a keeper, and that real practice yields real progress. There is nothing wrong with practicing, on practice or even real wood! That being said, this image is AWFUL- direct flash, and camera/flash rotated the wrong way, overexposed, soft focus- not good practice! Delete it!! (;-D)

Re: Close Enough - when trying a new method

#5

Re: Close Enough - when trying a new method

charlie belden

>While this piece was done as a Proof of Concept, it goes a little beyond that - but Close Enough rather than Done As Well As Possible.

Attached are just a few things I see in the piece that could and, in a "real piece", should be changed. I can see what's needed to fix this one, and I'm sure I can make those changes. But I'd start with better, dry wood and sharpen more often.

And there is a dilema. Do you ALWAYS start with the best wood - even if you're doing a Proof of Concept piece - so if things go well, you can spend the time and effort necessary to end up with a nicely proportioned, near perfectly turned, and finely finished piece?


img

Re: Close Enough - when trying a new method

#6

Re: Close Enough - when trying a new method

Texian

>Charlie,

I am still using prototype tools and jigs that I made 15 to 25 years ago. They are generally bad ugly and function very well.

And I don't have any "best wood", so just start with what I have, but with the intention of giving it my best shot. If the project turns to ca-ca, the workmanship may be allowed to deteriorate thereafter.

Just depends upon your confidence in ability to perform the expected procedures, and "are you feeling lucky" that day.

Re: Close Enough - when trying a new method

#7

Good enough to me

Don Orr

>Charlie, I was just reading the article in American Woodturner this morning about Left Brain-Right Brain by Drozda and Nittman. Since you are attempting to emulate Drozda I feel the main emphasis of the article applies well here. Their ideas evolve over time and they encourage practice and development. They said that quantity equals quality. My take on that comment is that the more you do, the better you get. Practice is always important in anything new. Just like sports, music, dance, anything-practice makes progress(and maybe even perfect !) Using less than great wood is a great way to work out the process so when you get to the good wood you can do it justice. I've done it many times. I think you have done a good job on this piece and proved your concept. Now we need to see it done with nicer wood-More practice ;-)) One of my mentors told me early on that "Every cut is a practice cut til the final cut." I try to emphasize this concept when I teach as well.

Re: Close Enough - when trying a new method

#8

Re: Close Enough - when trying a new method

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I always use practice wood for practice and concept development pieces. That encourages me to a) take risks and b) slice, dice and toss the piece afterwards. Sometimes a good wood piece becomes a practice piece, but that's a different story.