Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

What's Your Dream Lathe?

Posts

What's Your Dream Lathe?

#1

What's Your Dream Lathe?

Paul Zerjay

>I am presently turning on what was once my dream lathe. A Powermatic 3520B. It is more of a lathe than I am a turner and I don't know if I will ever outgrow it. But it is no longer my dream lathe. Sometime, no where in the near future I can assure you, I would like to have a Stubby 750 in my shop. When I stand alone at the lathe, I dream of being a better turner than I am, I dream of turning on a better lathe than I have, but all in all, I am grateful for what I have. Lathe and skills

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

#2

Robust!!

Greg Haugen

>I currently have the Powermatic's little brother, the Jet 1642. It does what I need it to do, from long table legs to coring bowls. My dream lathe?? Without a doubt would be a Robust! Doesn't matter which one, a Robust!! I have a Comfort Rest on my Jet, if the tool rests are that nice, the lathes have to be incredible!!! Plus since I'm only about an hour and half from them, it would be nice to have an American made lathe.

Greg H.

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

#3

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I have got it- a Oneway 1640 with full outboard turning capabilities.

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

#4

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f

>My dream lathe is a Oneway 2436 with outboard attachment (which I have had for 10 years). However I spent three days demonstrating on a Powermatic at the wood show here recently for a local supplier. What a lathe! Smooth as a Oneway and a lot cheaper (even with the recent price increases). If I was looking for a new lathe now (to supplement the Oneway), it would be the Powermatic. However, the Oneway remains my "dream machine" because I turn a lot of big bowls outboard (lots of over 20 inch stuff -=- and that tool rest is fantastic).

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

#5

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

john lucas

>Well If I had the money it might be a tough decision. I used to want a Stubby and it would still be in the running. I like the Oneway 2436. Right now I lean toward the big Robust.

Every lathe has a personality and a few things that you like and dislike. There all minor on the top lathes but Ideally I would like to turn on each one to find out what the lathe is like.

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

#6

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

Rick Allen

>I call it a "Life Lathe" as in the lathe I will turn wood on for the rest of my life. For me that is a Oneway 2436.

The downside of having such a fine lathe is that the problems with my turnings can only be traced back to me.

On the plus side the lathe nearly disappears in the woodturning process.

I can't help but smile every time I walk into the shop. I can have have a plan for what I want to turn and somehow that lathe will put a spell on me. I will walk out of the shop with a smile on my face and a smooth shiny object in my hand.

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

#7

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

Jim Canning

>Got it! The 3520B, it will last me a life time and after almost 3 years it is still sweat to use. Becouse of the cold (-9)and my 3520B is out in the garage I recently had to use an old nova lathe inside my basement. Man I can't wait for it to warm up just a little.

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

#8

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

Bill Grumbine - Kutztown PA

>Paul, I have turned on every big lathe out on the market, and some that aren't anymore. And I picked a Robust. I even sold my beloved Poolewood to buy it too!

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

#9

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

mfoster

>I've been drooling over the Stubby for few years. I guess I need to take a closer look at the Roobust after seeing the posts here. One of the nice things for me with the Stubby is that all the chucks and faceplates I have for my Woodfast will work on the Stubby. I am getting closer to taking the plunge, but will probably live with what I have for a while yet.

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

#10

I already have it - a Robust American Beauty

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

#11

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>When it came time to buy my dream lathe I did a lot of research and thinking about what I wanted to turn. I had a Oneway 1018 and the Stubby 500 at that time. Both are excellent lathes and I considered their big brothers. Some health problems delayed the purchase and the Robust came onto the market. I made 15 collection plates for our church on the Stubby and that convinced me that the Robust might be the lathe for me. My contact with Brent English of Robust sealed the deal. And I have been very pleased with my purchase. I am about to make five more collection plates on the Robust for the church to complete the set. If I were making the decision today, I would get the Robust again.

Ed

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

#12

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

Ken

>Rat's,after all that,guess I better not mention my poor little Nova 1624,but it ain't failed on anything I put on it yet.Plus I'll wear out before it does.

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

#13

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>The ones I have, a General 160-1 and a Jet Mini

Take care,

Jim

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

#14

Re Dream Lathe? New turners prospective

GalenV

>From a new turner�s prospective on a dream lathe: Any model or make that would stop instantly before you make a catch, the piece comes loose in the chuck or prevents any unintended design alterations! I guess if they can make a saw that claims to stop before you cut your finger off what I ask for should not be toooooo big a dream.

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

#15

Re: Re Dream Lathe? New turners prospective

Coyne

>When it came time to upgrade from my Jet mimi, I knew that whatever I bought would be IT for the rest of my life. (I am OLD) I went whole hog and selected a Oneway 2436 with stainless steel ways and the 3HP motor, and I have been so happy with it that it is embarassing. Coyne

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

#16

Re: We think alike! I went from a Woodfast....

Jamie D

>....that I used for 13 yrs. to my dream lathe, the Stubby 750, and it still works like a lifetime lathe. The only other lathe I would seriously consider these days is a Robust, and all because of the rotating (out of the way)tailstock feature, far superior to any other design on the market.

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

#17

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

robo hippy

>After 8 years on a 3520A, I wanted to up grade. The Oneway and the Serious were out of consideration. My lathe space is in a corner, so outboard turning isn't available, and anyway, I prefer a sliding headstock. The Stubby has possibilities, but the coring systems won't fit on it. The VB 36 looks like a monster, but the design says 'bowl lathe' to me no matter how it is set up. The Nichols lathe isn't made any more, but it would have been a contender. The only one out there with a sliding headstock is the Robust. It is made in the good ole USA as well. Maybe some day I will design and build my own lathe, but the Robust will have to get worn out first. That will take a lot of abuse.

robo hippy

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

#18

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

John Scheideman

>I've had my Nichols lathe for several years and still love it. It is a shame that John Nichols went out of business because he would make anything you wanted. If I had to look for another lathe I may try to find a used Nichols. There are a few little things that annoy me but I think that would be true of any lathe you buy.

John

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

#19

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

Ed in Sptbg.

>That's the way I feel, Ken. I've had my Nova DVR 3000 for about 4 years now and it handles everything I throw at it. It's very compact for it's capacities and fits my cramped little shop very well.

One change I would wish for is some type of control knob for speed changes rather than the push buttons. But that's minor. It's a keeper otherwise.

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

#20

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

Don wilcut

>I have my dream lathe already also, a VicMarc 300 short bed, with tail stock swivel. I have turned on a new PM at JCC and should I not have had my VicMarc I would purchase the PM.

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

#21

How do you figure?

Steven Kubien

>Hey Robo,

I have seen it written before about the Stubby not taking any of the coring units. When I first read that, I made some calls (ok, emails) and lots of folks are coring quite happily using the Oneway or McNaughton. Please understand, I am not trying to pick a fight or anything like that, just trying to set the record (as I know it to be) straight.

Cheers,

Steve

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

#22

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

Wally Dickerman

>I get a kick out of young turners who say that their new lathe is a lifetime lathe. they just won't get any better. When I was a young kid I can remember when my father, who had owned several Model T Fords, bought a brand new Model A Ford. Wow..That was it. They just weren't going to get any better. A self starter, windows that rolled up and down, A manifold heater, plush seats, and a lot more.

Since my first lathe in 1936, A small Sears lathe, I have upgraded many times to my present Oneway 2016. At my age, that probably is my best and final one. But there will always be something new and better coming along.

Wally

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

#23

Us young punks

Steven Kubien

>I resemble that remark! I guess my way of looking at it is that any one of these high-end lathes could be a lifetime lathe if you wanted/needed it to be. I also tend to agree with the earlier comment about (paraphrasing here) keeping up with the Jones'. I wonder how much this condition is a North American thing or if it exists elsewhere in the world? Maybe too deep for a snowy afternoon in Ajax Ontario....

Steve Kubien

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

#24

Steven Antonucci

Lathe envy :-)

Steve Antonucci

>I laugh at the idea of lathe envy too. Maybe someday there will be a TV show called "Pimp My Lathe". Then, your Stubby can be on airbags to automatically adjust to the right height vs. the inconvenience of having to block it up.

And Oneway's wont have to be white. They'll come with flames and pinstriping.

I'm not on my last lathe, but I'm not leasing it either. It's gone when it stops working or I win the lottery- whichever comes first!

Steve

Re: What's Your Dream Lathe?

#25

Don Pencil

Re: Robust!!

Don Pencil

>Yes!!! That's the ticket. Or the OneWay 2436

Know that I have a dog in this fight. But even were that not so, it would certainly be the one then other.