Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Rant: Maybe I can just turn tops on my Oneway 1640

Posts

Rant: Maybe I can just turn tops on my Oneway 1640

#1

Rant: Maybe I can just turn tops on my Oneway 1640

Jim Rutten

>Because I certainly cannot turn bowls. I am so frustrated. Moreso than I have ever been. I have a dry roughed out piece of sycamore on my lathe. My bowl gouge has literally just come off the Tormek. I am doing two cuts. One is the edge of the tool up high and the handle down low in a trailing cut (i.e. Bill Grumbine's tape). The second is the tool parallel to the lathe with one sideground edge on the bowl and the other just barely off the wood. After maybe 20-30 passes and my tool rest half covered with angel hair shavings, I still have tear out that would take hours of sanding. I have watched these cuts at meetings and symposiums. I have employed these cuts on other bowls with success. AAAAAAARRRRRRRRGGGGGGGHHHHHHH.

Signed,

Pulling His Wood Chipped Covered Hair Out Jim

Re: Rant: Maybe I can just turn tops on my Oneway 1640

#2

Dominic in Bucks County PA

Sycamore is a PITA

Dominic in Bucks County PA

>Jim,

Don't feel so bad! IMHO Sycamore is a real PITA to turn. I found that no matter how sharp I got the gouge, or my technique, I STILL got tear out. I resorted to shear scraping it to as good as I could get then I wet sanded with a 50/50 mix od spar varnish and mineral spirits. The mix stiffened the wood fibers enough so that sanding was able to shear off the fibers cleanly.

Even after all that work, the only redeeming feature of the bowl was the profile. Maybe it was that particular piece of Sycamore, but it was pretty bland looking. I ended up giving the bowl to my sister and she painted vines and flowers on it. She sold it at her next craft fair. To her credit, she told everyone that it was a "collaborative" effort between the two of us. :>)

After that experience, I avoid turning sycamore. I've got too many other species around that are easier and more fun to turn.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Rant: Maybe I can just turn tops on my Oneway 1640

#3

Re: Sycamore is a PITA

John K Jordan

>That's what I thought - use a different wood!

For wood prone to tearout, I usually soak in thinned sanding sealer then make a cut. Lately I've been using shellac-based sealer thinned with alcohol. The dried sealer supports the fibers so they don't pull out during the cut. Then soak again if needed. This usually works well for me on softer woods and even wood a bit too spalted.

Oil will also work. Sanding torn grain is an exercise in frustration since the damage to the wood extends far below the surface. Even if I sand below the damage the surface will end up looking uneven. (I find cabinet scrapers better than sandpaper for many surfaces.)

JKJ

Re: Rant: Maybe I can just turn tops on my Oneway 1640

#4

Re: Rant: Maybe I can just turn tops on my Oneway

john lucas

>Jim You didn't say how thin the bowl is. When it gets really thin it tries to vibrate and will pull itself into the tool self destructing. I place my left hand on the outside of the piece to dampen these vibrations which lets the cuts go smoother.

Not that I've ever done what you did of course. I was working the other day and blew up 2 finials in a row. Now how many finials have I turned over the years. Hundreds I would guess. The song some days are diamonds and some days are stones can ring so true.

Re: Rant: Maybe I can just turn tops on my Oneway 1640

#5

Re: Rant: Maybe I can just turn tops on my Oneway

Peter Hyde

>I turned sycamore wet to a finished bowl and had no tear out problems at all. i found it to be a nice wood for wet turning. Here's the bowl.


img

Re: Rant: Maybe I can just turn tops on my Oneway 1640

#6

Re: Rant: Maybe I can just turn tops on my Oneway

Ed Davidson (Colorado Springs)

>Jim,

Have you checked to insure your lathe is turning in the correct direction? I've inadvertently flipped my Oneway into reverse before and got similar results.

Re: Rant: Maybe I can just turn tops on my Oneway 1640

#7

Re: Rant: Maybe I can just turn tops on my Oneway *LINK*

charlie belden

>Sycamore can be pretty bland wood - even if it's orange when you first cut it fresh. But if you cut it right - quarter sign - things can get interesting. Quarter sawn sycamore often have medullary rays that run square to the vertical grain. If you get lucky you can get a piece that looks like what's called lacewood. Great for flat work - tricky when turning - since you're turning side and end grain together.

Third pic on the attached web page has QS sycamore "lacewood" in the lower right corner of the picture.


3rd pic, lower right - QS sycamore

Re: Rant: Maybe I can just turn tops on my Oneway 1640

#8

Re: Sycamore is a PITA

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>If you don't like Sycamore, don't try Cottonwood.

Re: Rant: Maybe I can just turn tops on my Oneway 1640

#9

Re: Sycamore is a PITA

Don at Central Illinois

>I have, didn't like it.

Re: Rant: Maybe I can just turn tops on my Oneway 1640

#10

Re: Sycamore is a PITA

NickTuzzolino

>You are not alone. I turned 6 or 7 blanks, left them about an inch all around, and in 6 weeks they were so distorterd I scrapped every one of them. I think long pieces would be good for handles, etc. Also, there is probably a learning curve to the bowls.(no pun intended)

Re: Rant: Maybe I can just turn tops on my Oneway 1640

#11

Brad Vietje

Hang in There, Jim!

Brad Vietje

>Jim,

While others have pointed out that some woods are tougher than others, I'll add that nothing beats one-on-one mentoring to learn this turning sport.

Get thee to a turning club, and find a way to get together with other, more experienced turners, and things will improve. Soon enough, you'll be the experienced guy helping others get past the difficult learning curve.

Let us know where you are, and I'll bet someone on this list will be glad to have you over to turn in their shop to figure out how to get the best results.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Rant: Maybe I can just turn tops on my Oneway 1640

#12

Re: Rant: Maybe I can just turn tops on my Oneway

Jim Rutten

>Thanks for the advise, everyone. I think I am going to go back to turning cherry.